InsureMyTrip vs. SquareMouth: How They Compare on Options, Support, and Benefits

About InsureMyTrip

InsureMyTrip began in 2000 as the first website built specifically to compare travel insurance plans online. Over the past 25 years, it has grown into a trusted marketplace where travelers can see plans from more than 20 carefully vetted providers in one place. The idea is simple: make it faster and easier for people to choose coverage that fits the way they travel.

The company’s platform handles everything from the initial quote to the final purchase. Along the way, licensed customer care agents are available to answer questions, explain benefits, and help travelers make sense of policy details. If something goes wrong during a trip, that same team offers complimentary assistance with claims.

InsureMyTrip’s offerings range from single-trip protection to annual coverage, group policies, and plans for cruises, international travel, or specific visa requirements. Optional add-ons like “Cancel for Any Reason” or rental car coverage give travelers flexibility to tailor their plans. Serving millions of customers and offering coverage for trips to over 250 destinations, the company continues to focus on making the travel insurance process less complicated and more transparent.

About SquareMouth

SquareMouth launched in 2003 with the goal of helping travelers compare a large selection of travel insurance policies in one place. Over two decades, it has insured more than 4.1 million travelers and built what it calls the largest travel insurance marketplace in the United States.

Its platform lets users compare plans from over 20 providers, all of which are reviewed for financial strength and backed by the company’s Zero Complaint Guarantee. Travelers can sort options by coverage type, price, and benefits, with categories that include single trip, annual, cruise, adventure, and travel medical policies.

SquareMouth also places emphasis on customer service. Their team is available before, during, and after a trip to answer coverage questions and assist with claims. The company’s resources include plan reviews, coverage guides, and price comparison tools, aiming to help customers make informed choices.

What to Consider?

Choosing a travel insurance marketplace often comes down to more than just price. Factors like experience, how they operate, the kind of support they offer, and the range of coverage options can all make a difference. Below, we look at how InsureMyTrip and SquareMouth compare in key areas that matter to travelers.

Company History and Experience

A brand’s time in the industry often reflects how well it understands traveler needs and the insurance landscape. Longer experience can also mean stronger relationships with providers and a more refined platform for customers.

InsureMyTrip

Established in 2000, it has over 25 years of experience and was one of the earliest travel insurance comparison sites. Over the years, it has served millions of travelers and expanded its partnerships to more than 20 vetted providers.

SquareMouth

Launched in 2003, it has two decades of experience and has insured more than 4.1 million travelers. It’s recognized for growing into one of the largest travel insurance marketplaces in the U.S.

Verdict

InsureMyTrip comes out ahead with a longer track record, offering five more years in the industry and holding a pioneering place in the online travel insurance space.

Role in the Travel Insurance Industry

Where a company sits in the market can influence its credibility and the kind of trust travelers place in it. Some brands lead with innovation, while others focus on scale and volume.

InsureMyTrip

Known as the first dedicated travel insurance comparison website, it set the standard for how travelers shop for coverage online. Its focus remains on transparent, unbiased listings and customer-first tools.

SquareMouth

Holds the title of the largest travel insurance marketplace in the U.S. in terms of providers and plan volume, offering a broad catalog for comparison.

Verdict

InsureMyTrip stands out for being a pioneer in the field, shaping how online comparison shopping for travel insurance works today.

Claims Support

How a company handles claims assistance can make a big difference when travelers face emergencies or disruptions. Hands-on help can reduce stress and improve the odds of resolving issues quickly.

InsureMyTrip

They provide complimentary claims assistance from licensed agents. This means customers get step-by-step help at no extra cost when filing with a provider, available before, during, and after the trip.

SquareMouth

They offer claims advocacy to help customers work with their chosen provider and emphasize its Zero Complaint Guarantee.

Verdict

InsureMyTrip takes the lead here with free, licensed-agent claims support that’s built into the service rather than positioned as an add-on.

Coverage Reach

The number of destinations and providers a platform can cover affects its usefulness, especially for international travelers.

InsureMyTrip

Lists coverage for trips to more than 250 destinations worldwide and works with over 20 vetted providers.

SquareMouth

Works with 20+ providers and offers a variety of plan types but doesn’t emphasize destination coverage count in its public information.

Verdict

InsureMyTrip has the advantage with a clearly stated global reach that helps travelers confirm their destination is covered before they even begin comparing plans.

Plan Recommendation Tools

Not all marketplaces offer smart tools to help travelers narrow down their options. These features can save time and prevent decision fatigue.

InsureMyTrip

They use a recommendation engine that factors in over 100,000 real customer reviews along with trip details to highlight the most relevant options.

SquareMouth 

They provide filtering by coverage type, price, and benefit, and publish all reviews for transparency, but don’t have an automated recommendation tool tied to reviews.

Verdict

InsureMyTrip wins here for its built-in recommendation system that blends customer insight with tailored plan matches.

Range of Coverage Options

The more flexible the offerings, the more likely a traveler will find coverage that fits their specific trip.

InsureMyTrip

Provides single-trip, annual, and group coverage for up to 10 travelers, plus cruise-specific, visa-specific, medical-only, evacuation, and accidental death plans. Add-ons include CFAR, rental car coverage, and sporting equipment protection.

SquareMouth

Offers single-trip, annual/multi-trip, group coverage for 10+ travelers, medical-only, flight, cruise, and adventure-specific plans like safari, backpacking, and scuba diving.

Verdict 

InsureMyTrip edges ahead by offering visa-specific plans and smaller group coverage flexibility, along with customizable add-ons that aren’t as emphasized by SquareMouth.

International Travel Support

International trips often require specific types of coverage, sometimes tied to visa requirements or country-specific entry rules.

InsureMyTrip

InsureMyTrip highlights its international coverage, including plans that meet Schengen visa requirements, making it easy for travelers to choose compliant options.

SquareMouth

They offer plans for international destinations but put more focus on activity-based options rather than visa compliance.

Verdict

InsureMyTrip takes this category for clearly catering to travelers who need to meet formal visa or entry requirements.

Pricing Policies

Pricing policies can show whether a company offers real flexibility and transparency after purchase.

InsureMyTrip

Most plans cost 4–10% of prepaid, nonrefundable trip costs. They offer a Price Guarantee along with a money-back review period for cancellations within a set window.

SquareMouth

The average cost is also 4–10% of trip cost, with a Best Price Guarantee, but no widely promoted money-back review period.

Verdict

InsureMyTrip leads by combining competitive pricing with the extra security of a money-back review period.

InsureMyTrip vs SquareMouth: What Do Customers Think?

Hearing from travelers who have used these platforms gives a clearer idea of what the experience is like beyond the features on paper. Both InsureMyTrip and SquareMouth receive strong praise, but the feedback shows how each stands out in practice.

InsureMyTrip

Travelers describe the process as “quick and easy to get and compare quotes” and “very easy to review travel insurance options, compare costs, and purchase travel insurance.” 

Many appreciate having “a lot of choices” and say the site is “easy and quick” to use. Repeat customers mention coming back multiple times, with one noting this was “the 10th time I’ve used this site” and that they “recommend highly” after having “great success” when claims were needed. 

Other reviews highlight how “smooth and easy to understand” the process is, with a layout that makes it “well organized and easy to use.” 

Customers also value being able to “plug in the trip info, then see/compare all the options side-by-side,” whether they need a low-cost option or full coverage, adding “we will continue to use your site.”

SquareMouth

Customers often say the site is “so easy to navigate” and that it “takes the stress out of buying insurance.” 

Many like that it is “very easy to compare policies and purchase one online” while also having the option to call and “ask questions and discuss policies.” 

Price transparency is another plus, with one traveler sharing they found “the same coverage from the same companies through Squaremouth” for less than buying directly. Others point out how “the insurance specialists are real experts in the field” and can narrow down the policies that work best for their needs. 

The guarantee of help with claims is also mentioned as something that adds confidence when booking coverage through the platform.

InsureMyTrip vs SquareMouth: Promotions and Discounts 

Travel insurance prices are generally regulated, so deep discounts or coupon codes are uncommon. Still, some travelers check for seasonal deals or promotional offers before making a purchase. Here’s the current situation for both InsureMyTrip and SquareMouth.

InsureMyTrip

At present, InsureMyTrip does not advertise any official discounts or promo codes on its website. While some third-party sites list potential offers, these are not confirmed by the company.

SquareMouth

SquareMouth does not provide promotional discounts or coupon codes. The company notes that offering financial incentives on insurance plans is restricted by U.S. regulations.

InsureMyTrip vs SquareMouth: Policy Delivery and Cancellations

How quickly you receive your policy and what options you have if you change your mind can influence peace of mind after purchase. Both InsureMyTrip and SquareMouth provide instant policy access, but their approaches to cancellations differ.

InsureMyTrip

Once a policy is purchased, documents are sent directly by email, and customers can also access them through their account. The company offers a money-back review period, typically 10–14 days depending on the provider, as long as the trip hasn’t started and no claims have been filed. Travelers can update their policy before departure to reflect new prepaid trip costs or other changes.

SquareMouth

Policies are delivered via email immediately after purchase, and users can download them from their online account. Cancellations and refunds are subject to the individual provider’s terms, as SquareMouth does not promote a standardized review period. Policy changes are also handled according to the provider’s rules.

Verdict

InsureMyTrip takes the lead by offering a clear, brand-level money-back review period along with easy policy updates, giving customers more flexibility if plans change shortly after purchase.

Which Will You Choose?  

Travel insurance shopping should be simple and supported. Both marketplaces do a good job, yet one feels more complete for most trips. The nod goes to InsureMyTrip.

InsureMyTrip has built that trust over 25 years, starting as the first online platform dedicated to comparing travel insurance plans. Today, it brings together more than 20 vetted providers, covers trips to over 250 destinations, and offers policy options for everything from single vacations to annual travel, group coverage, and even visa-specific requirements.

Policies arrive in your inbox right after purchase, and there’s a money-back review period if you need to make a change early on. Licensed agents are available before, during, and after your trip to answer questions and guide you through the claims process at no extra cost. The recommendation engine blends real traveler reviews with your trip details, making it easier to find coverage that fits without second-guessing.

There are other platforms that compare a wide range of travel insurance plans, but InsureMyTrip’s combination of long-standing experience, human support, and built-in flexibility make it a standout choice for travelers who want peace of mind from the moment they start looking for coverage to the day they return home.

---

Next, check out other similar articles we’ve published:

Tally Review

LendKey Review

Sable Card Review

Lemonade Insurance Review