Made by Mary Review

About Made by Mary

Made by Mary Review

Made by Mary jewelry is designed to add a shining touch to your look and your life, offering a radiant collection of stylish, handcrafted and minimal jewelry. Each piece is one-of-a-kind, ideal for marking every moment, big or small. 

With pieces designed for everyday wear, Made by Mary has garnered an impressive following of 502k on Instagram and 43.5k on Facebook. The brand has also been mentioned in popular media outlets such as Popsugar, People, and Refinery29, just to name a few.

So what’s in store for this Made by Mary review? You can expect a close look at the brand, with answers to any question you can think of. I’ll be sure to check out its background, best-selling jewelry pieces, and customer feedback, along with details about promos and FAQs, to help you decide if it’s worth the buy.

Overview of Made by Mary

Made by Mary Review

Made by Mary was created in a time of darkness, when Mary Moody fought against the struggles of postpartum depression and sought to rediscover herself as a new mom. She found solace in the world of fine jewelry–specifically how it is crafted and the fact that every shiny piece has a deeper meaning.

The overall idea was quite simple: that you can carry your treasured moments with you in the form of sentimental jewelry. Eventually. Moody’s passion project turned into something more, and the brand was brought to life in 2013 in Draper, Utah.

Today, the brand expresses a juxtaposition of the power and strength of femininity and womanhood with the softness and elegance that is fine jewelry. Plus, all of the pieces are still handcrafted in the brand’s home state, employing female artisans who strive to develop jewelry that signifies the most important moments in life. 

Before we get into this Made by Mary review, let’s go over some highlights:


Made by Mary Review
  • Wide collection of elegant and minimal handcrafted jewelry
  • All pieces are hand cut, stamped, shaped, assembled, and packaged by the brand’s small team in Draper, Utah
  • High quality materials including silver, gold fill, mixed metal, and gold plating
  • Many products are easily personalizable 
  • Jewelry sets available 
  • Rewards program
  • 60 day warranty
  • Free standard shipping on all US orders

Made by Mary strives to keep fine jewelry accessible, so it offers a number of different metals and finishes to ensure everyone can indulge in the quality pieces. Options include solid gold, gold filled, gold vermeil and plating, sterling silver, and more.

The jewelry collection is just as vast as the metal selection, including hand-stamped disc pendants, rings, gemstone pieces, and hair accessories. The styles merge minimal and eclectic, with careful details and unique touches that make them extra special. 

Almost all of the pieces can also be customized with different names, stamps, and color options, as well as lengths and sizes. 

With all that being said, you may be looking for a little more clarity about these shiny jewelry pieces. And while I can’t cover everything the brand has to offer, I’ve gathered some of the top sellers to give you an idea of what all the hype is about. 

Made by Mary Jewelry Review

Carefully forged, meaningful jewelry lies at the heart of Made by Mary. So, it only makes sense that each of the best selling styles should feature simple customization and unique designs that stand out, while still offering a simplistic and comfortable look. 

Made by Mary Mini Birth Flower Stacker Necklace

Made by Mary Review
Made by Mary Mini Birth Flower Stacker Necklace

Carefully handcrafted, the Mini Birth Flower Stacker Necklace features up to 5 super small and dainty discs, hand stamped with the hand-drawn designs from the birth flower collection. 

Whether you want to collect the flowers associated with those you love or gift mom a necklace that subtly reminds her of her children, this Made by Mary necklace features a sentimental charm (in more ways than one). 

This style is easy to customize, available in gold filled, sterling silver, or rose gold, as well as a few different length options and a wide variety of flowers to choose from. Gift the Mini Birth Flower Stacker Necklace to yourself or someone you love for $46.

Made by Mary Satellite Choker

Made by Mary Review
Made by Mary Satellite Choker

The Satellite Choker unites dainty with detail, featuring a soft and subtle, lightweight chain decorated with small spheres every inch or so. It’s ideal for adding a little sparkle to your decolletage and can easily be paired with one of the brand’s many pendants. 

Available in gold filled, rose gold filled, or sterling silver, as well as a number of different lengths so it can sit exactly how you’d like, the Satellite Choker retails for $48.

Made by Mary Mini Oval Locket Necklace

Made by Mary Review
Made by Mary Mini Oval Locket Necklace

Sentimental and thoughtful, the Mini Oval Locket Necklace contains the biggest memories in a sweet and dainty shiny locket. It offers the perfect length to sit close to your heart, while the shiny face can easily be engraved for an extra personal touch. 

The locket is ideal for gifting empty or with an image, whether you’d like to mark a special memory or allow the recipient to choose their own. 

To add photos to your locket, follow these simple steps:

  1. Open the locket and remove the clear plastic insert with a pair of tweezers
  2. Choose your photo and size it to be 8mm wide and 11mm tall
  3. Place the plastic insert over the photo to trace the perfect shape
  4. Cut out the photo and place it inside the locket, sealing it in with the plastic insert
  5. Repeat these steps to add a photo to the other side of your locket

This Made by Mary locket is available in gold filled or silver and retails for $98.

Made by Mary Knot Ring

Made by Mary Review
Made by Mary Knot Ring

Ever heard the phrase “if you like it put a ring on it”? The Knot Ring seals the deal, tying together those loose strings to celebrate relationships, commitments, and connection. The thin band features a small and simple knot at the center, representing anything you can imagine.

The ring symbolizes so many different things and can easily be worn as a wedding ring, friendship ring, or reminder to continue to push through with the strength of love at your side. 

Whether you feel tied to someone for life or want to celebrate the reference you have with yourself, opt for the Knot Ring, which comes in gold filled or sterling silver and a number of different sizes for $32.

Made by Mary Evie Hoop Earrings

Made by Mary Review
Made by Mary Evie Hoop Earrings

A classic pair of hoops belongs in every jewelry collection, but the Evie Hoop Earrings add a special, custom touch to your daily ensemble. They feature the classic circular shape decorated with an interchangeable, tiny pendant stamped with your design of choice. 

Lightweight and versatile, they are designed for everyday wear and can easily be customized daily since the charms are sold individually. The earrings pair seamlessly with the hand stamped pendant necklaces for a cohesive and thoughtful look. 

While they are ideal for everyday wear, the brand recommends removing them when sleeping, showering, and swimming to maintain the integrity of the materials. 

Simple yet stylish, the Evie Hoop Earrings come in gold filled, sterling silver, and rose gold filled for a total of $48.

Made by Mary Jewelry Box

Made by Mary Review
Made by Mary Jewelry Box

Now that you’ve picked out all your new jewelry pieces, it’s important to store them properly. Designed to contain all the pieces you hold near to your heart, the Jewelry Box comes with built-in storage to ensure your pieces stay together and knot-free. 

The box is carefully crafted from high quality vegan leather with a narrow shape ideal for storing on your nightstand or vanity table. It comes with 7 necklace hooks, a spacious pouch, and 3 unique removable trays so you can properly store your earrings, necklaces, rings, bracelets, and more without worrying about tangles or messes. 

Ideal for containing the memories you have collected throughout the years, the Jewelry Box comes in a honey or cream finish made from vegan leather or microfiber for $120.

Who Is Made by Mary For? 

Made by Mary Review 1

While jewelry is the ideal way to add a little depth and sparkle to your life, so many pieces are mass produced, not very unique, and thus a little less meaningful. 

Made by Mary flips the narrative, carefully crafting pieces to develop something new and special, as well as support small artisans. The brand focuses on developing fine jewelry for every day, featuring simplistic and casual, yet elegant and stylish shiny finishes. 

The products are also ideal for gifting as they can be personalized with engraving, or you can opt for different birth flowers and styles that have a special meaning.

Made by Mary Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Made by Mary Review

Chances are you’ve tuned into this Made by Mary review to discover your new go-to jewelry pieces, or perhaps the perfect gift for someone you love. While we’ve established that the company is dedicated to providing meaningful, high quality designs, it only makes sense to turn to the experiences of real customers. 

To start, let’s take a look at how some of the top sellers are rated on the brand’s website:

  • Mini Birth Flower Stacker Necklace: 4.9/5 stars out of 140 reviews
  • Satellite Choker: 4.9/5 stars out of 518 reviews
  • Evie Hoop Earrings: 4.3/5 stars out of 151 reviews

One shopper describes how her piece symbolizes each of her children, while also being versatile and high quality–she also mentions that she’ll be back for more:

“I am so in love with my birth flower necklace! I have all 3 kids on there and it goes with everything – I haven’t taken it off! I’ve gotten so many compliments on it and my older kids love to look at it.

Another reviewer has nothing but good things to say about the dainty and lightweight design:

I get so many compliments on this dainty necklace. It’s probably my favorite of all my necklaces and really all the ones on the website. I love it on its own and layered with other necklaces. It’s the perfect minimalist choker for any outfit or occasion!”

Made by Mary also earns an impressive rating on Etsy, with 5/5 stars out of 3,790 reviews. One reviewer notes the quality of both the pieces and the brand’s customer service:

“This necklace was delicate and beautiful. Just what I was hoping for. Their customer service was phenomenal as well. They checked in to ensure I wanted to continue my order, after the start of COVID, and sent me a message when my purchase was on the way. Truly, everything about this purchase was perfect!”

On Facebook, Made by Mary is rated 4.3/5 stars out of 243 reviews. One patron appreciates the designs and prices, branding the company as the perfect place for gifts and documenting special memories:

Beautiful quality pieces at an affordable price. I’ve bought different pieces from them as gifts for friends, new moms, and myself. Recently ordered their jewelry box and it is stunning and functional.”

Doing my research for this Made by Mary review, I’m happy to share that I found almost nothing in terms of bad reviews–the only comments seemed to depend on preferences, and the return process is seamless. 

The brand is highly rated for its high quality collection of fine jewelry at affordable prices. The unique, thoughtful designs add a special touch to the everyday pieces, and many shoppers highlight how often they receive compliments. 

Is Made by Mary Worth It?

Made by Mary Review

If your wardrobe is missing a few shiny accessories, or you want to share a thoughtful gift with someone you love, Made by Mary is worth the buy. They are never mass produced, but instead intentionally designed to be meaningful and refined.

The pieces are carefully handcrafted and packaged, ensuring a unique and personal touch with every purchase. The high-quality materials ensure a long lasting tarnish resistant finish, while the price is tough to beat when it comes to fine jewelry! 

Made by Mary Promotions & Discounts 

Made by Mary Review

While there aren’t any Made by Mary discount codes available at this time, we did find that you can shop the sale section for up to 50% off. Plus, users can refer a friend, gifting and receiving a $15 off Made by Mary coupon code. 

The brand also has a rewards program that offers extra savings for regular shoppers. Here’s how it works:

  1. Sign up: when you create a free account you’ll automatically earn 25 points
  2. Earn points: earn 1 point for every dollar spent, as well as birthday rewards and points for following the brand’s social media platforms
  3. Redeem points: redeem your points for cash to put towards your order

Where to Buy Made by Mary

Made by Mary Review

After searching the web for information to include in this Made by Mary review, I found that the jewelry is exclusively available on, as well as the brand’s Etsy page.


Made by Mary Review

Who owns Made by Mary?

At the time of this Made by Mary review, the company is owned by its original founder and creator, Mary Moody.

Does Made by Mary Ship Internationally?

If something in this Made by Mary review caught your eye, you’ll be happy to hear that the brand offers international shipping. Orders are shipped via DHL with a production time of 6-10 days and shipping time of 3-4 weeks, costing $15-$25

What is Made by Mary’s Shipping Policy?

Anxiously awaiting your order after reading this Made by Mary review? Fortunately, the company offers a number of different shipping options so you can get your order ASAP:

  • Standard: production time of 6-10 days and delivery time of 9-17 days, free 
  • Expedited: production time of 6-10 days and delivery time of 8-15 days, flat fee of $9
  • Rushed: production time of 1-2 days and delivery time of 2-4 days, $20-$30
  • DHL to Canada: production time of 6-10 days and delivery time of 2-3 weeks, flat fee of $15

Buyers can track their packages by heading over to the website. 

What is Made by Mary’s Return Policy?

Not sure which of the Made by Mary rings is right for you? Fortunately, the brand offers free returns and exchanges on unworn, non-custom pieces with original packaging within 14 days of delivery.

Shipping costs, customized items, and final sale items are non-refundable. The brand also offers a 60 day warranty for any manufacturing defects–simply contact them as soon as you notice an issue or error.

How to Contact Made by Mary

Made by Mary Review

I hope you enjoyed this Made by Mary review! If you have any further questions about the brand or its products, you can contact them by emailing [email protected].

Check out similar brands you might like:

Vitaly Jewelry Review

Mint and Lily Review

Helloice Jewelry Review

Maria Black Jewelry Review

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required