Table of Contents
About Made In Cookware
With a sleek, modern feel, Made In Cookware offers a professional-quality selection of cooking essentials. The brand was founded in 2018 by Jack Kalick and Chip Malt with the mission “to redesign the kitchen landscape they grew up in.”
The Texas-based company sources, designs, and crafts its cookware all in the USA. Made In is used by professional chefs around the country but has a small family feel, developed out of the pair’s 100-year family history in kitchen supply.
About All-Clad
All-Clad has been around for half a century, founded in 1971 by John Ulman. His mission was to deliver maximum performance in all of the brand’s products, designing and manufacturing its cookware in the USA with bonded 18/80 stainless steel and aluminum.
This Pennsylvania-based brand is credited with inventing the innovative technique of crafting single pieces of cookware from bonded layers of metal—this technique has been adopted by other companies, and is just one of the reasons why restaurants turn to All-Clad’s collection for their kitchens.
Ready for a little head-to-head? It’s all coming up in this Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review. First, we’ll take you through a few important things to keep in mind as you browse, moving on to product comparisons, and finishing off with a contrast of the brands’ quality, value, feedback, and policies.
Made in Cookware vs All-Clad: What to Consider
There’s a lot to unpack in this Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review, so before we get started, we wanted to give you a little rundown of the key points to keep in mind when making your decision. You’ll discover more about each brand in the sections to come, so we’ll make this list brief.
Product range
There are perks to being able to purchase a range of kitchen tools and accessories in one purchase—it’s convenient. But selecting a brand that specializes in a specific, smaller range of essentials is beneficial too.
Both Made In and All-Clad offer similar products that range from cookware to knives to accessories. The main differences between the two are the latter’s kitchen electrics and a slightly larger selection.
Target audience
You may be thinking cookware is for cooks, and you’re right, but what about bakers and professionals? Even though we found that Made In is used by Michelin star chefs, both brands make professional-grade products. More of a baker? Both companies have great stocks.
Design and durability
We understand that some people only care about kitchen essentials that work, but there are also those of us who care about aesthetics. Durability is a top priority for both of the companies, but they do differ in design slightly, with Made In looking a little more modern.
With All-Clad, you’re getting 18/80 stainless steel across the board. With its competitor, you’ll find a mix of materials that include French porcelain, 18/80 stainless steel, and others.
Sustainability efforts
If you like to be a friend to the environment with everything that you do (or buy), then each brand’s sustainability efforts might sway you one way or the other.
We couldn’t find much information about All-Clad’s sustainability efforts but the simple fact it manufacturers its products from recyclable materials in the USA is a great start. Made In goes into more detail, stating that its factories follow eco-friendly practices.
Extras
Made In has a recycling program and its tags contain seeds to plant (how fun?!), two more elements that make it a sustainable pick. While we didn’t find that All-Clad has extras like this one, it does have an amazing sale section which is pretty fun too.
Accessibility
Sometimes your decision comes down to where a brand ships to or how much its products cost. While scoping out products for this Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review, we found that on average, they’re pretty on par in terms of prices and what you can expect for professional-grade cookware.
Both collections are available directly from the brands’ websites, but we saw that Made In offers international shipping and is found in stores like Bed, Bath, and Beyond. All-Clad doesn’t ship outside of the USA but is found in places like Crate & Barrel and Williams Sonoma.
The next section of this Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review will walk you through a selection of the brands’ cookware fit for sizzling, stewing, and sautéing up your favorite dishes. Let’s just go ahead and get things cookin’.
Made In Cookware The Sous Chef vs All-Clad 10 Piece Pots and Pans Set – D3 Everyday Stainless Review
Uniformity in the kitchen is key if you want the same standard for your crisp veggies as you do for your soups and stews. Inclusive cookware sets are critical for this, and so we’ll start this part of our Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review off by looking at one from each brand to see how they stack up.
The Made In Cookware The Sous Chef set includes seven pots and pans with four lids, along with a 2 oz can of Carbon Steel Seasoning Wax. This helpful bundle will take you through perfect, stick-free eggs, fresh pasta dishes, soups, and searing steak. It includes:
- 10″ Stainless Clad Frying Pan
- 10″ Non-Stick Frying Pan
- 12″ Carbon Steel Frying Pan
- 2 QT Stainless Clad Saucepan with Lid
- 3.5 QT Stainless Clad Saute Pan with Lid
- 4 QT Stainless Clad Saucepan with Lid
- 8 QT Stainless Clad Stock Pot with Lid
The three frying pans in this set are shiny black, while the sauce and saute pans have a professional steel look. Right now, The Sous Chef is on sale for $600. Normally, you’d find it for $802.
Made In Cookware The Sous Chef
- Inclusive set has everything you need
- Range of sizes for all types of dishes
- Mix of non-stick and stainless steel
- Comes with seasoning wax
- Oven safe up to 600°F
As for the competitor, the All-Clad 10 Piece Pots and Pans Set D3 Everyday Stainless set is triple-ply and includes six pots and pans and four lids. Outfitted with drip-free rims, contoured handles for an easy grip, the cookware is oven safe up to 600°F and made from 18/80 stainless steel. The set contains:
- 8.5-inch Skillet
- 10.5″ Skillet
- 1.5-quart Saucepan
- 3-quart Saucepan
- 3-quart Sauté Pan
- 6-quart Stockpot
Durable and ready to cook, this set will help you create your favorite dishes, heating up quickly and providing even heat distribution. You can get it for $600.
All-Clad 10 Piece Pots and Pans Set D3 Everyday Stainless
- Interchangeable lids
- Variety of sizes
- Professional-looking
- Oven safe up to 600°F
- Made from 18/80 stainless steel
Though the Made In set is a little larger than All-Clad, its normal price speaks to that fact—you’re getting more but you’re also paying more. Both offer a range of pots and pans with thoughtful details like wide, large handles and drip-free rims. At the end of the day, your decision may come down to one of size.
Made In Cookware The Bakeware Set vs All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Set, 5 piece Set Review
Winter is the best time for baking. Cuddly, shrouding sweaters aren’t just for warmth, you know. This section of our Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review will take a look at each of the brands’ bakeware sets to suss out what they’re made for and from, as well as if one may cook up a better batch of treats.
How do we find out? By looking at materials and design, of course. With the Made In Cookware The Bakeware Set, its pieces are made from French porcelain, a material that is as much about looks as it is for results. It’s safe in this oven up to 650°F, is thermal-shock resistant, and non-porous, meaning heat won’t escape. The set includes the following:
- 8×8″ Square Baking Dish
- 9×13″ Rectangular Baking Dish
- 10×6.6″ Oval Gratin Baking Dish
Helping you whip up everything from casseroles to cookie bars, this set will last a long time, is non-stick (without need for a coating), and comes with either a navy, red, slate grey, or olive rim for an attractive touch. Right now, the set’s on sale for $150 but is normally $217.
Made In Cookware The Bakeware Set
- Oven safe up to 600°F
- Has handles for easy gripping
- On sale
Like its competitor, the All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Set, 5 Piece Set is non-stick ceramic with a PFOA-free finish to help your goodies slide out easily. Equipped with large, easy-to-grip handles, you won’t have to worry about dropping the pan.
Warp-resistant, and oven-safe up to 450°F, you’ll experience even heating across the pan, meaning all cookies will come out the same no matter where they’re placed. In the set, you’ll get a baking sheet, two circular cake pans, a loaf pan, and a cooling rack for $100.
All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Set, 5 Piece Set
- Nonstick
- Even heat distribution
- PFOA-free
- Comes with a cooling rack
In the grand scheme of things, these two sets are very different. Made In is made of porcelain while All-Clad is ceramic. Both are non-stick, but generally, we find porcelain to be longer-lasting, even though the risk for breaking it when dropping is much higher.
Both offer even heating and handles that are easy to grip, and each set will cook up different things—Made In is great for casseroles whereas All-Clad has cookies covered.
Made In Cookware Stainless Clad Stock Pot vs All-Clad D3 Stainless 3-ply Bonded Cookware, Stockpot with Lid, 12 Quart Review
An essential for any kitchen, stockpots hold and heat liquids, but with a great one, you’ll experience a richer flavor when cooking up broths and soups. Both of these brands are a great choice, and below, this Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review will walk you through the details.
The Made In Cookware Stainless Clad Stock Pot is made from one piece of 5-ply 18/80 stainless steel. Crafting this piece from one sheet of metal means that the thickness around the pot will be the same and your food will be heated evenly.
Need to finish your dish in the oven? You can pop this baby in at temperatures up to 800°F and is compatible with induction stoves. It offers 12 quarts of space and comes with a lid, totaling 7 lbs of weight. This is the biggest pot the company has, and it’s $200.
Made In Cookware Stainless Clad Stock Pot
- Made from 18/80 stainless steel
- Even heat distribution
- Comes with a lid
- Holds up to 12 quarts of liquid
The All-Clad D3 Stainless 3-ply Bonded Cookware, Stockpot with Lid, 12 Quart uses the brand’s signature bonded construction of 18/80 stainless steel with an aluminum core. It’s compatible with induction ovens and is oven safe up to 600°F.
Cooking up anything from pasta to soups and sauces, the pot has a wider base that’s ideal for sautéeing up garlic and veggies before adding liquids, as well as tall sides and a lid to help reduce evaporation during cooking. The pot also features riveted stainless steel handles for a better grip and is $460.
All-Clad D3 Stainless 3-ply Bonded Cookware, Stockpot with Lid, 12 Quart
- Holds up to 12 quarts
- Made from 18/80 stainless steel
- Heats evenly
- Comes with a lid
- Made In the USA
With the same size and look and similar materials, both of these pans are matched in terms of quality. From their details, we understand that they cook in similar ways, and both come with a wide base and lipped edge at the top to reduce evaporation. At the end of the day, with this one, your decision may come down to price.
Made In Cookware vs All-Clad: Quality
Both Made In and All-Clad manufacture their products in the US and offer professional-grade cookware. With that in mind, the quality for each collection is going to be high already, but we did a little digging to find out more.
Made In is crafted completely in the USA—that includes sourcing the materials and making its pots and pans. Pushing for sustainability wherever possible, the brand says that it works with manufacturers that are environmentally conscious and employ people who live in the area (thus reducing CO2 footprint from travel).
Built from 18/10 stainless steel, the cookware is 5-ply and fully clad. The outside is made from magnetic 403 stainless steel, while the core is made from 3 layers of heavy-gauge aluminum.
Those who have bought from the brand say that the pans are very high quality, don’t discolor, and disperse heat evenly. In addition, the pans don’t rock or warp—a good sign that they’re indeed made very well.
As for All-Clad, the brand makes its cookware at its own factories in Pennsylvania. Created in 1971 as a metal crafter shop, it uses high-grade materials like 18/80 stainless steel and aluminum to create pans with optimal heat conducting properties.
The construction uses a multi-clad process that bonds two exterior layers of stainless steel with an aluminum core. With serious standards in its factories, its pans are known for their durability and unmatched performance.
Both companies use 18/80 stainless steel which is the king of a durable and reliable cooking experience. In terms of quality, this cookware is pretty matched, so your final decision may come down to the construction of each.
Made In Cookware vs All-Clad: Price & Value
So far in this Made In vs All-Clad review, these two competitors are well matched. In this section, we’ll take a look at the prices for both and compare them in terms of value.
We’ll be looking at what’s included in their sets since both brands are pretty matched in terms of quality. The Made In Cookware The Sous Chef set includes 11 pieces for $600 (or $802 when not on sale). The All-Clad D3 Set has 10 pieces for $600.
Both made from 18/80 stainless steel offering the same professional-grade cooking experience, Made In Cookware’s pots are slightly larger, offering more room, and so, hold a higher value.
When they’re not on sale, this means that both of these sets are pretty matched when it comes to what they’re worth, so we’re going to need to look a little deeper.
The next thing we looked into was where and how each brand makes its products, and this may be where the big differences come into play. Made In is a newer brand which doesn’t mean it has less value, but it doesn’t quite have the valued reputation that its competitor has garnered over the last 50 years.
Sourcing and crafting its cookware in the USA, the brand is a slightly more sustainable option than All-Clad, simply due to the fact that its factories employ local workers and eco practices when possible.
All-Clad manufactures its cookware in the USA as well, its big value in the fact that it’s known for its high-quality steelwork.
So what’s the verdict? Does one come out on top? To us, it’s a matter of perspective. Do you prefer reputation over new-age practices…or a modern feel rather than a traditional one?
Made In Cookware vs All-Clad: What do Customers Think?
If there’s one thing we know about cookware, it’s that as pretty as it may look, the purpose of it is to cook. That’s why this section of our Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review exists, and here, we’ll take a look at what customers had to say about both brands in terms of quality and performance.
Made In is the newer kid on the block when it comes to professional cookware, but regardless of that, it has really high reviews across the board. After combing the web for ratings and feedback, here’s what we found:
- MadeInCookware.com—The Sous Chef: average of 4.9/5 stars from 11,648 reviews
- MadeInCookware.com—The Bakeware Set: average of 4.9/5 stars from 658 reviews
- Facebook: average of 4/5 stars from 228 reviews
After digging through some of the comments, we were pleased to see customers sharing success stories with the brand’s cookware. Some common bits of feedback included:
- Very well made
- Features beautiful detailing
- Heats evenly
- No discoloration after tons of use
- Love their eco-friendly tags (you can grow a plant from them)
A lot was said about the construction and cooking performance of Made In’s cookware, but more so, people really seem to love this company as a whole. Being that it’s new to the scene, customers are impressed with the quality.
So how about All-Clad? Ahead, you’ll find a summary of its ratings on its website and off.
- All-Clad.com—10 Piece Pots and Pans Set – D3 Everyday Stainless: average of 4.8/5 stars from 188 reviews
- All-Clad.com—Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Set, 5 piece Set: average of 4.8/5 stars from 28 reviews
- Costco—14-piece Stainless Steel Set: average of 4.7/5 stars from 252 reviews
Looking through reviews, we found a few common points of feedback. You’ll see those below:
- Evenly distributes heat, results in more developed flavor
- Good-looking cookware
- Worth the investment
- Easy to use and clean
Overall, feedback was highly positive for this brand. Customers really like the construction of its cookware and the quality that it’s maintained over 50 years of business.
The reviews for each of these brands were pretty similar. Customers like both of the companies from a business standpoint, but for different reasons.
With Made In, shoppers love the fresh and modern vibe of its site and selection. With All-Clad, it’s an authentic and trustworthy reputation.
Made In Cookware vs All-Clad: Promotions & Discounts
Professional-grade cookware is expensive. There’s no way around it. If you want top-notch stuff, you should be prepared to pay for it.
With that said, while we carefully made our way through each of the brand’s websites for this Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review, we were sure to keep note of any promotions that popped up because, well, who doesn’t like saving a few bucks? Here’s what we found:
- Sale on select items
- Military discount (email for more info)
- Yearly sales & promotions
- Free shipping & returns
- Free Shipping on orders $100+
- Promotion section, up to 57% off
- Annual sales & promotions
We noticed that while All-Clad had a more impressive sale selection, Made In offers free shipping and returns. Both brands hold annual promotions, but Made In gives military discounts. In terms of who you’d save more money with, well, it depends on what you’re shopping for.
Regardless of the item, you’ll get your order shipped for free with Made In, as with All-Clad, you’d need to spend a certain amount. With that said, it’s not hard to rack up a total of over $100 with either of these brands, so most likely, you’d get free shipping anyway.
Made In Cookware vs All-Clad: Shipping & Returns
Shopping online is fun. You scope out the perfect product, make your purchase, and then get to dreaming of all the tasty dishes you’ll be cooking up soon.
Of course, “soon” is what you hope for, and to fill you in on what the deal for Made In and All-Clad is when it comes to delivery, we’ve bundled together everything we could find about their shipping policies and have included the same for returns—just in case.
Shipping
- Orders are processed in 2 business days
- Offers expedited shipping options for the US
- Free shipping on US orders over $50
- Free shipping on international orders over $100
- Ships to over 200 countries, APO & FPO addresses
Returns & Warranty
- All items come with a lifetime warranty for defects
- All products have a 45-day risk-free trial
- US returns are free
Shipping
- Ships to the continental US only
- Orders are delivered via UPS Ground
- Processing times are about 48 hours
- Your order will typically arrive in 3-7 business days
- Shipping is free for orders over $100
Returns & Warranty
- You can 45 days to return your items (they must be unused and in their original packaging)
- All cookware comes with a lifetime warranty that covers defects
We’ll be honest here, Made In’s policies are pretty appealing. With free US shipping, international delivery, free returns, and a risk-free trial, buying and trying their cookware is easy.
That’s not to say that buying from All-Clad isn’t, we find that there are benefits of buying from a brand with simple shipping locations—that is, if you live in those locations. If you don’t you can always shop select products on Amazon or high-end stores like Williams Sonoma.
Who Will You Shop With?
Choosing the right cookware is a big decision, but quality companies make it easier with flexible policies and fool-proof products that you may never want to return. This Made In Cookware vs All-Clad review checked out two high-quality brands matched in construction, materials, and extras, but as you probably learned, they each come with different perks.
For Made In, that means international shipping, a free trial, a lifetime warranty, and sustainable, reliable production. This newer brand also comes with a modern feel, with a sleek, approachable website that’s as informative as it is nice to look at.
If you’re more of the traditional type, All-Clad may be the more appealing choice. With 50 years in the game, its cookware is built to last, and it has a reputation you can bet on. Though its shipping locations are limited, it offers a lifetime warranty and a killer sale section.
Both brands are excellent choices for all kinds of chefs, offering a wide selection of cookware for the modern and traditional home. Your choice may come down to personal preferences, and not one of quality since that’s pretty much a given with either.
Check out some of our other comparison reviews you might enjoy:
Ask the community or leave a comment
WRITE A REVIEWCustomer Reviews
Leave a review