Plum Paper vs Erin Condren: Comparing Planner Personalization

About Plum Paper

Fifteen years ago, Kristina Kardous established Plum Paper. She sought to provide truly customizable planners, filling a gap in the market for organizational tools that adapt to individual needs. A blooming plum-colored tree inspired her to name the company, reflecting the brand’s commitment to quality and desirability. From its humble beginnings in a spare bedroom, Plum Paper has grown into a thriving business. 

Today, they offer a wide range of beautifully designed, customizable planners, notebooks, and stationery. Plum Paper empowers customers to create unique planning systems. They provide extensive customization options, enabling users to tailor their planners to their specific lifestyles.

About Erin Condren

In 2005, Erin Condren founded her eponymous brand. She aimed to create stylish and functional organizational solutions, and her company has since become a leading name in the planning industry. Erin Condren produces planners, organizational tools, and personalized stationery. They emphasize vibrant designs and high-quality materials to inspire productivity, creativity, and balance. Their LifePlanner™ collection and accompanying accessories showcase a commitment to aesthetic appeal and streamlined organization. 

While they offer customization options, Erin Condren concentrates primarily on the visual aspects of planning, showing a strong brand identity centered on colorful designs and a sense of community. The brand helps customers achieve their goals and reduce stress through organization, focusing on a curated aesthetic experience.

What to Consider?

Let’s dive deep and figure out which planner is the perfect fit for you! This section will compare Plum Paper and Erin Condren, looking at their features, customization options, and pricing. You will see which planner will best support your planning style and help you achieve your goals.

1. Customization Options

The ability to customize a planner allows users to align the tool with their individual needs and preferences. A wide range of customization options can lead to a more personalized and effective planning experience.

Plum Paper

Plum Paper offers users a broad spectrum of customization features. Customers can select from numerous layout options, add specialized sections like meal planning or budgeting directly into the planner, and customize the text and sections within the layouts. They also provide flexibility in start month and planner duration, and allow for the addition of extra pages. This level of customization ensures the planner adapts to the user’s lifestyle.  

Erin Condren

Erin Condren focuses primarily on aesthetic customization. Users can personalize the cover design, choose coil colors, and select from a limited number of interior design themes. While they offer various layouts, the ability to customize the layout itself is more constrained compared to Plum Paper. They sell a wide range of accessories and stickers separately.  

Verdict

For those seeking a planner they can truly make their own, Plum Paper provides the superior customization experience. 

The key difference lies in the type of customization offered: Plum Paper allows users to tailor the internal layout and content to their specific needs, such as choosing page layouts, adding specialized sections, and personalizing section titles. Erin Condren, conversely, emphasizes external aesthetic customization, allowing users to personalize covers and coil colors, but with less flexibility in the planner’s internal structure. 

Plum Paper empowers the user to design a planner that perfectly reflects their unique needs and planning style. This level of control ensures a more seamless and effective organizational tool, as the planner adapts to the user, rather than vice versa.

2. Layout Variety

The availability of different layout options allows users to choose a planner structure that suits their individual preferences and planning styles. A wider selection of layouts can accommodate a broader range of user needs.

Plum Paper

Plum Paper provides users with choices that cater to various planning needs and routines, such as daily task management, detailed hourly scheduling, weekly goal setting, academic planning, fitness tracking, or even specialized layouts for homeschooling or meal planning.

Erin Condren

Erin Condren also provides daily, weekly, and monthly layout options. Their selection aims to address general planning requirements and offers users a variety of structures to organize their schedules.

Verdict

Plum Paper distinguishes itself with a significantly broader selection of layouts. The difference between the two brands lies not just in the quantity, but in the variety of specialized layouts offered. 

Also, Plum Paper creates layouts that reflect a deeper understanding of diverse planning styles, allowing users to find a truly tailored fit. This flexibility makes Plum Paper a more adaptable and user-friendly choice for individuals with unique planning requirements.

3. Integrated Planning Features

The ability to integrate various planning tools and sections within a single planner can streamline organization and enhance efficiency. Combining multiple planning needs into one resource simplifies daily management.

Plum Paper

Plum Paper offers the option to integrate a variety of planning features directly within their planners. Users can add specialized sections for meal planning, budgeting, fitness tracking, and other personalized needs. This allows for a consolidated planning experience, simplifying their organizational process and eliminating the need for separate notebooks or planners.

Erin Condren

Erin Condren provides planners with standard sections for daily, weekly, and monthly planning. They offer separate accessory books and sticker packs for specialized planning needs, like budgeting or meal planning. These accessories are designed to complement their planners but are not integrated within them.

Verdict

Plum Paper distinguishes itself by offering integrated planning features. They empower users to build an all-in-one planner, simplifying their organizational process and creating a more efficient and cohesive planning experience

4. Internal Content Personalization

Users can personalize the internal content of a planner to tailor the tool to their specific needs and preferences. A higher degree of personalization can enhance the planner’s functionality and usability.

Plum Paper

Plum Paper provides users with the option to personalize various aspects of the planner’s internal content. Customers can customize section titles, add specific events to monthly spreads, and even modify the text within layouts. They provide a high degree of control over the planner’s internal structure and content.

Erin Condren

Erin Condren focuses primarily on aesthetic customization. While users can choose from various layouts and designs, the ability to personalize the internal content, such as section titles or specific text, is limited. They offer a range of stickers and accessories that users can use to personalize content, but these are separate purchases.

Verdict

Plum Paper excels in internal content personalization.  They enable users to directly customize planner content, whereas Erin Condren provides pre-set layouts and relies on separate accessories.

5. Scheduling Flexibility

The ability to customize scheduling options within a planner allows users to align the tool with their specific time management needs. Flexibility in scheduling can accommodate diverse lifestyles and work patterns.

Plum Paper

Plum Paper offers users significant scheduling flexibility. Customers can choose their planner’s start month and duration, allowing them to begin planning at any point in the year. This feature accommodates users who don’t necessarily adhere to a traditional calendar year.

Erin Condren

Erin Condren typically offers planners with set start months, usually either January or July. While they provide various layouts, the flexibility to choose a custom start month is not a standard feature.

Verdict

Plum Paper offers a significant advantage in scheduling flexibility. They can let users choose their start month and duration, they provide a planner that adapts to individual timelines.

6. Price

The cost of a planner, relative to its features and customization options, determines its overall value. Understanding the price range and available sizes helps users make informed purchasing decisions.

Plum Paper

Plum Paper offers daily planners in three sizes: A5 (5.8″ x 8.3″) starting at $49.95, 7″ x 9″ starting at $51.95, and 8.5″ x 11″ starting at $63.95. They provide extensive customization options, including layout choices, specialized sections, and internal content personalization, all within these price ranges.

Erin Condren

Erin Condren’s LifePlanner™ collection offers a wide range of options. Based on the information provided, their coiled LifePlanners, featuring weekly and monthly views, start around $60.50 (though sales are frequent, bringing prices down). They also offer Daily LifePlanner™ Duos that start around $80.50. Their planners come in various sizes, including A5, 7″ x 9″, and 8″ x 10″. Prices vary based on features, design, and binding type (coiled, softbound, ring agenda).

Verdict

Plum Paper delivers a more cost-effective solution for users seeking deep customization. They provide a wider range of internal customization features, such as tailored layouts and integrated planning sections, within a lower starting price range ($49.95 – $63.95). 

In contrast, Erin Condren’s coiled LifePlanners begin at a higher price point (around $60.50) and focus primarily on aesthetic personalization, with less flexibility in internal structure and content. This means Plum Paper users get greater control over their planner’s functionality without breaking the bank.

Plum Paper vs Erin Condren: What Do Customers Think?

To get a real sense of how these planners perform in everyday life, we’ve gathered feedback from users across various platforms—from dedicated planner communities and Reddit threads to general review sites. Let’s take a look at what people are saying about Plum Paper and Erin Condren, and see how their experiences compare.

Plum Paper

Plum Paper customers frequently express high satisfaction with the brand’s exceptional customization options and the resulting personalized planning experience. Many users appreciate the ability to tailor their planners to specific needs, from layout choices to specialized sections. They highlight the ease of integrating various planning functions into a single, cohesive tool, which simplifies their organizational process.

“I absolutely love that I can design my planner exactly how I want it. It’s like they read my mind!”

The brand’s commitment to user-driven design is often praised, with customers noting the intuitive and adaptable nature of Plum Paper’s products. The flexibility in start months and planner duration is also a recurring point of positive feedback, as it allows for planning on individual schedules. Customers find the value for the cost to be excellent, given the level of customization and the quality of the planners.

“I’ve tried so many planners, but Plum Paper is the only one that truly fits my unique planning style. It’s worth every penny.”

Furthermore, the customer service is frequently complimented, with users reporting positive interactions and timely support.

Erin Condren

Erin Condren customers often express appreciation for the brand’s vibrant designs and aesthetically pleasing planners. The visually appealing covers and coil colors are frequently mentioned as positive aspects. Users enjoy the wide range of accessories and stickers that allow for personalizing the planner’s appearance.

“The colors and designs are just so inspiring! It makes planning fun.”

The brand’s LifePlanner™ collection is recognized for its high-quality paper and durable construction. Customers find the pre-designed layouts to be functional for general planning needs. The community aspect of the brand is also valued, with users enjoying the shared experience and inspiration.

“I love my Erin Condren planner! It’s beautiful and helps me stay organized. Plus, the stickers are adorable.”

Many customers appreciate the brand’s focus on helping them achieve goals and reduce stress through organization, and find the products effective in their daily lives.

Plum Paper vs Erin Condren: Promotions and Discounts

When comparing Plum Paper and Erin Condren, their promotional strategies and discount offerings differ. Understanding these differences can help customers maximize their budget and make informed purchasing decisions.

Plum Paper

Plum Paper is currently offering an Honest Brand Review exclusive 10% discount on their customizable Daily Planners with code HBR10. This discount applies to all sizes:

• A5 (5.8″ x 8.3″) Daily Planners: Starting at $49.95 (with 10% off using code HBR10)
• 7″ x 9″ Daily Planners: Starting at $51.95 (with 10% off using code HBR10)
• 8.5″ x 11″ Daily Planners: Starting at $63.95 (with 10% off using code HBR10)

Erin Condren

Erin Condren frequently runs promotions and offers discounts. Their website often features:

• Sitewide events with percentage discounts.
• Flash deals with limited-time offers.
• Sales on specific collections, such as LifePlanners.
• They also offer 15% off when you sign up for their news letter.

Plum Paper vs Erin Condren: Shipping and Returns

Understanding the shipping and return policies of Plum Paper and Erin Condren is crucial for making informed purchasing decisions. Here’s a comparison of their key aspects:

Shipping Policies

• Plum Paper

• Offers a variety of shipping options, including standard and priority, catering to different delivery speed needs.
• Ships internationally to a broad range of countries, providing accessibility to a global customer base.
• Clearly states shipping times, although they are estimates and subject to potential delays.
• Provides flexibility in shipping address changes before the package is shipped, offering a degree of customer control.
• Ships to P.O. boxes, accommodating customers with this delivery preference.
• Free shipping on continental US orders over $100.

• Erin Condren

• Offers free economy shipping for orders over a certain threshold, which could be attractive for larger purchases.
• Provides specific shipping estimates for various options, but does not take responsibility for shipping carrier delays.
• Simplifies international shipping by including fees in the total.
• Also ships to P.O boxes.
• Does not specify the ability to change the shipping address.

Return Policies

• Plum Paper

• Maintains a clear distinction between custom and non-custom items in its return policy.
• Offers a window for returns on non-customized items, ensuring customer satisfaction.
• Addresses damaged or incorrect orders with a defined process.
• Has a clear cancellation policy.

• Erin Condren

• Has a straightforward return policy with a specific timeframe.
• Also addresses damaged or incorrect orders.
• Also has a final sale for personalized items.

Verdict

Plum Paper presents a shipping and returns framework that prioritizes customer flexibility and clarity. Its comprehensive international shipping, adaptable address change policy, and distinct handling of custom versus non-custom returns offer a more accommodating experience. The way that Plum Paper handles returns, and shipping, is more customer-oriented. 

The brand’s transparent communication and customer-centric policies make it the preferred choice for those seeking a reliable and adaptable shopping experience. Erin Condren, while offering free shipping for larger orders, and simplified international shipping, lacks the same level of flexibility and customer-oriented policies.

Who Will You Shop With?

Given the choice, a discerning shopper seeking a personalized and transparent planning experience would likely choose Plum Paper. The image displays starting prices for their daily planners across three sizes, immediately providing the information needed to make an informed decision. This directness in pricing builds trust and eliminates potential surprises. The prominent ‘Explore Layouts’ and ‘Customize Now’ buttons invite active participation in the planner’s design, indicating a brand that values user input.

Plum Paper’s approach allows for a level of customization beyond simple aesthetics, extending to the planner’s functionality and internal structure. The availability of three sizes ensures that various planning needs are met, whether for portability or detailed scheduling. 

Furthermore, the Honest Brand Review exclusive 10% discount with code HBR10 adds significant value. Plum Paper creates an appealing shopping experience by offering transparent pricing and empowering users to fully customize their planners. When it comes to a brand that prioritizes the customer’s planning journey, Plum Paper stands out as the top choice.

---

Check out similar brands you might like:

Banks Journal Review

Papier Review

Ugmonk Review

Karst Review