Frye Boots Review

About Frye Boots

Frye Boots Review

Frye specializes in manufacturing quality leather boots for men and women. Though Frye Boots focus primarily on shoes and boots, the brand also sells bags, clothing, and other accessories such as hats, sunglasses, and wallets. 

With a 213K following on Instagram, the Frye company has been affiliated with several celebrities including Matt Shultz, Chris Hemsworth, and The Lumineers. Their stylish footwear has been a cultural staple since their inception, landing their original Campus boot a display within the Smithsonian. 

This Frye boots review will take an in-depth look at the brand, their bestsellers, customer ratings, promotions, and more to help you decide if these boots are the right fit for you (no pun intended). 

Overview of Frye Boots

Frye Boots Review

The Frye brand has a long-winded history, dating back over 150 years. Starting in 1863, founder John A. Frye opened his shoe store on Elm Street in Marlboro, Massachusetts. In 1888, the company crafted their very first boot, which now resides in the Marlboro Historical Society

Frye Boots continues to expand its company by manufacturing its signature, high-quality boots to adapt to ongoing fashion trends, such as Cowboy Western and significant historical events such as World War II. 

Frye Boots Review

Throughout the years, Frye became a well-known boot brand that has been seen on countless celebrities of its time, including Jackie Kennedy, Barbra Streisand, Gene Autry, Carole King, Jennifer Hough, Jessica Biel, Miley Cyrus, and many more. 

After experiencing several iconic fashion eras of the ’70s, ’80s, and ’90s, Frye continues to hone their craft. They launched their official website and collaborated with brands such as Burton and Cutler. Frye is also partnered with Feeding America to give back to the community. 

Frye Boots Review

Before we get into this Frye boot review, let’s go over some initial pros and cons. 


  • Boots offered in numerous styles for men and women
  • High-quality footwear 
  • Frye Boots donates a portion of their sales to Feeding America
  • Permanent sale outlet 
  • Offers AfterPay 
  • Military and student discounts 


  • Pricier than other boot retailers 

Frye Boots Womens Review

Frye Boots Review

The Frye company has a vast selection of boots for ladies to choose from. From Autumn Cut Frye ankle boots to heavily inspired Horseback Frye riding boots, there are multiple styles to suit your current aesthetic

Their women’s collection includes short, mid, and tall selections, wide calf boots, and boots for cold weather. Below, you’ll see our take on their top sellers in the Frye boots for women category. 

Veronica Combat

Everyone should have at least one pair of boots to stomp in. If you want a badass touch to every outfit you pair them with, you can’t go wrong with a classic combat boot. Designed to withstand the toughest of environments, these boots won’t go down without a fight. 

Frye’s Veronica Combat boots are long-lasting with Goodyear welt construction. The leather and rubber sole offers reasonably comfortable padding, and a 1-inch heel adds a bit of height to your step. These femme fatale boots come in 10 different color options, including three in oiled suede.

Made out of charcoal, soft Italian leather, these Frye Combat Boots feature a streamlined silhouette. This cute ankle boot would look great with a pair of military green skinny jeans or a sexy skater dress and a black leather jacket for an iconic grunge-inspired look. The Veronica Combat boots are priced at $380

Natalie Engineer Short

For those big sweater, legging clad days when you can’t be bothered, the Frye Natalie Engineer Short boots are the ideal footwear. Its slip on and off design is perfect for when you just want to quickly pull on a pair of comfortable city boots on your way out of your apartment. 

Natalie Engineer Short boot features smooth vegan Italian leather, a side buckle, and Goodyear welting for durability. The thick rubber outsole has deep indentations, providing excellent traction and solid footing. A shearling lining adds extra comfort to these industrial-chic boots.

Combine these Frye Engineer boots with comfy leggings, an oversized turtleneck, and a matching beanie for cozy cold-weather vibes. The Natalie Engineer Short booties retail for $475.  

Paige Tall Riding

The Paige Tall Riding boots are all about equestrian chic. Featuring an overlapping front panel and intricate stitching, these boots are made out of a stunning leather that’s been washed and antiqued for a more vintage look. A notched backing adds some additional style details.

The Paige Tall Riding boot is also knee length with a layered shaft and a low stacked leather heel (measures at 0.5”). These Frye riding boots have mini pull tabs for easy on and off. The Frye Paige Tall Riding boots are priced at $544

Melissa Button Lug

The Melissa Button Lug boot is a versatile and simple boot that goes with anything and everything in your closet. These equestrian style tall boots are contoured through the ankle and have a flattering shape to go with leggings and an overcoat or even an above the knee dress. 

These boots also have a hard-wearing leather design, a modernized topline, and a newly updated signature button for an added Western detail. Plus, the Melissa Button Lug has pull tabs for easy pull on. 

The Melissa Button Lug comes with a slight heel and lug soles that provide long-lasting comfort that you can wear all day. The Melissa Button Lug boots are currently on sale for $398.

Frye Boots Mens Review

Frye Boots Mens Review

The mens Frye boots category has an array of styles to choose from, whether you’re aiming for a cowboy, lumberjack, or urban aesthetic. 

Frye designs men’s lace-up boots, Chelsea boots, Western boots, and boots for cold weather. This Frye boots review will go over some of their most popular styles within this category. 

Conway Harness

The Conway Harness boots have a cool Victorian steampunk meets cowboy look. The boots are quite subtle, with only a harness ring attached with conjoining straps on the side as a stylish detail. The leather is stonewashed to give it that antique, well-worn look

The Conway Harness boots from Frye are square toed and have a leather and rubber outsole with a rubber heel cap for added durability and traction. Plus, the harness accent on the ankle for an additional Western look.

These boots feature a Goodyear welted construction with a snap button harness ring. That way, you can easily slip them on and off by using the inside zipper. It is also designed with a snub toe and comes with leather lining and a stacked leather heel. The Frye Conway Harness boot costs $544

Prison Boot

The Frye Prison Boot reminds us of Andy Dufresne from Shawshank Redemption. Orange jumpsuits aren’t exactly the best look, so well worn boots like these are a better kind of tough. The goal here is to look intimidating, without actually committing any crimes.

The Prison Boot has leather lacing with metal eyelets, an interior leather lining, and its oil-resistant rubber outsole provides traction and added durability. Also, the boots feature a polished stonewash leather upper that has been tumbled in stones in a wooden drum and then polished for a well-worn look.

Featuring washed-out leather, these Frye Prison Boots are part of the brand’s Made in the USA collection. These lace-up boots have Goodyear welted construction and are perfect for matching that rugged vintage aesthetic. If you want the Frye Prison Boot, you’ll be fined $516

Campus 14L

If Woodstock and bell-bottom jeans tickle your fancy, the Frye Campus 14L boots are an homage to the iconic period of 60s fashion. Frye actually manufactured them at the cusp of the 1960s. Signifying the American values of rebellion and freedom, these boots are made for peace, not war.

The Campus 14L boot is handcrafted with a crunch leather upper and has a Goodyear welt construction for durability. The smooth leather lining, specially formulated insole, and stacked leather heel add comfort and cushioning that feels like a second skin. Plus, the leather outsole has a rubber heel tab for added traction.

These boots are made out of Frye’s signature Montana leather that they place in a big vat with dark colors and hung dry for a ‘crunch effect.’ Go for a more modern 60s look with some acid-washed skinny jeans, a band tee, and some hippie sunglasses. The Frye Campus 14L boots cost $54

Bowery Chelsea 

The Bowery Chelsea boot is perfect for everyday wear at the office or for your occasional outing or hike. With the black and stonewash design, these boots can bring your casual look some elevated style and character. 

With the signature Goodyear welted construction, rubber-injected lug soles, the convenient pull tab at the back, and the elasticated side panels help for easy pull on. Plus, the Bowery Chelsea boots have a built-in leather lining, cushioned leather footbed, and a leather outsole for added comfort and durability. 

If you are looking for a quality boot that stands the test of time, while also providing comfort for all-day wear, the Bowery Chelsea boot is currently on sale for $350

Frye Boots Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Frye Boots Review

This Frye boots review found a generally positive customer response based on its research. Buyers comment that the boots are fashionable, high quality, and fit fairly well. On Zappos, 77% of customers rank Frye with a 5-star rating

These are Fryes. Which is the same thing as saying; high quality leather, cool look, and very comfortable. I have had different styles, and never had to return a pair for any reason!” Says one Frye boots review on Zappos.

There are also positive reviews on some of the shoe models on their Amazon page. Customers are overall pleased with their shoe purchases, with some commenting that it took a while for them to break in their Frye boots. “Give them a few wears and break them in … the boots are more comfortable each time I wear them,” reads one Frye boots review on Amazon. 

Frye Boots Review

The Campus 14L boots scored an overall 4.6 out of 5 rating out of 216 global reviews and one reviewer stated that “The boot is well made the leather is beautiful and you know you have a leather boot when you have it in your hand the leather is thick and I can see that the more you wear them the better they will get.” 

Here is a summary of how Frye boots rank on Amazon: 

  • Women’s Veronica Combat boots: 4.3/5 star rating out of 539 reviews 
  • Women’s Natalie Short Engineer boots: 4/5 star rating out of 94 reviews
  • Women’s Paige Tall Riding boots: 4.1/5 star rating out of 778 reviews
  • Men’s Conway Harness boots: 4.9/5 star rating out of 13 reviews 
  • Men’s Prison Boot: 4.4/5 star rating out of 84 reviews 

The most common complaint this Frye boots review came across is that the boots are quite pricey. Some customers have also reported customer service problems and incorrect sizing when trying to order the boots online. 

Are Frye Boots Worth It?

Frye Boots Review

If you’re willing to spend a decent amount of money on a good pair of durable boots, this Frye boots review would readily recommend the brand. Are Frye boots high quality? Yes, absolutely! I’d say their boots are investment pieces, meaning that you’d be paying for boots that will last you a long time

With a hefty price tag attached, in return you’ll receive quality, well-crafted boots that are worth the money. As one Amazon reviewer stated, “I believe these are going to be keepers and I’ll love them for a long, long time!” 

This shoe company has stood the test of time, which makes them more trustworthy and reliable when it comes to manufacturing high-quality shoes. Also, there are multiple boot styles to choose from, ranging from the 60s inspired Frye Campus Boots to Texan Frye cowboy boots. While a lot of its customers reported having to break in their Fryes, that’s the case with many boots – and it’s usually a good sign of an exceptional boot.

Frye Boots Promotions & Discounts 

Frye Boots Review

This Frye boots review found that they have a sale outlet, where customers can purchase shoes for as much as 50% off. Frye also has a 15% discount for students and military personnel. 

Customers can also sign up for their newsletter to receive $50 off their next order of $250 or more. As of lately, Frye is gifting a $100 gift card with every $400 you spend on your order.   

The company has a Frye Black Friday sale every year, ‘Black Fryeday’, which includes up to 50% off on shoes, boots, and accessories. 

Where to Buy Frye Boots

Frye Boots Review

You can buy all the best Frye boots at or:

  • Frye Amazon 
  • Frye Nordstrom
  • Frye Hudson’s Bay
  • Frye Walmart 


Are Frye boots made in the USA?

Only some Frye boots are made in the United States. They do have a separate collection for both men and women called Made in the USA. 

Do Frye boots run large or small?

Frye boots generally run large. The company states that the boots will gradually decrease in size as you wear them

Are Frye boots good for wide feet?

Frye recommends ordering a half size up if you generally wear half sizes and if there are no wide sizes available. 

Do Frye boots have arch support?

This Frye boots review checked their website, but didn’t find information on arch support. However, on some customer review pages, some say they have minimal arch support

How long do Frye boots take to break in?

According to a few customer reviews, some have reported it took a couple of weeks for Frye boots to break in if you wear them consistently. 

Will my Frye boots stretch out?

This Frye boots review found out that yes, Frye boots will stretch out the more you wear them.

Can you wear Frye boots in the rain?

Like all leather boots, it’s not optimal to wear during rainy days, but they will still hold up if you care for them.

How do you care for Frye boots?

Fortunately, Frye makes it very easy for customers to take care of their leather boots. They have a whole collection of leather care goods ranging from the waterproof balm, leather polish cream, to horsehair brushes. They have a Leather Care Kit that contains all the essentials to keep your boots looking fresh. 

How do I find Frye boots sizing? 

This Frye boots review found out that sizes vary for each product and can be found on individual product pages. This Frye boots review will provide sizing charts for both men’s and women’s shoes. 

Frye Boots Review
Frye Boots Review

What is Frye’s Shipping Policy?

Frye offers to ship anywhere within the United States and also provides international shipping. In terms of shipping options, they provide Next Business Day shipping and UPS 2nd Business day within the United States. For international orders, they use DHL Express. Customers can track their orders by going onto their website and visiting their account page. 

What is Frye’s Return Policy?

This Frye boots review found out that they offer free returns. If customers are not happy with their orders, they are encouraged to visit their return portal on their website. Customers will receive an email with a pre-paid return label, then have 60 days to return their purchases. The products must be unworn and in new condition

Refunds are made in the original form of payment within 10 business days of the return. If customers would like an instant return, they can select their instant return option and receive their refund as store credit

How to Contact Frye

If you have inquiries that were not addressed in this Frye boots review, you can contact the team through:

  • Phone: 1(800)-826-3793 
  • Email: [email protected] 
  • Online chat on the website 
  • Message form on the website 

Check out your options for stylish, high quality boots:

Thursday Boots

Jack Erwin



Ask the community or leave a comment

Ask a Question
Big Frye collector & wearer
Asked by Renee Hughes (3 years ago) Reply

Please bring back the original women’s Campus boots from the 70s with the stitched design and chunky heel that were featured in magazine articles. I’d buy them with a quickness. Had a pair that got stolen. Right now my favorite pair are the 150th anniversary Americana 15r boots.

Horrible Experience
Asked by Laura Egan (3 years ago) Reply

I bought shoes that did not fit! I inquired about returning them and followed instructions! I am now being hounded by collections even though I provided proof of return. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE! They act like you never returned their product and keep trying to get money from you!. This is a horrible website and I warn you all to close out and not order anything!!!!

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required