25karats Review

We’re independently supported by our readers and we may earn a commission when you buy through our links.

About 25karats

25karats Review

Are you looking for something truly unique for your wedding band? If so, keep reading this 25karats review to learn all about this NYC-based fine jewelry brand, which sports one of the largest collections of engagement rings and wedding bands in the US. 

Located in New York’s famed Diamond District, 25karats makes handcrafted rings in a variety of unisex styles that you would be proud to show off for a lifetime. While media hits have been scanty, the brand has a strong social media profile, with nearly 100K followers on Facebook. 

Ready to learn more about this brand that specializes in giving you the wedding band of your dreams? This 25karats review will take an in-depth look at the brand, its bestselling ring designs, customer ratings, promotions, and more to help you decide if their products are worth the buy. 

Overview of 25karats

25Karats Review

25karats was founded in 2008 by Naz Aksu & Mehmet Aksu, with a mission to not only create high-quality luxury jewelry, but also to take the stress and hassle out of the ring-buying experience. To that end, the brand has created a seamless and secure online ordering process, and its customer service team is always on hand to answer buyers’ queries and address their concerns.

All 25karats jewelry is designed and manufactured on-site at the brand’s headquarters in New York City. The brand uses exclusively conflict-free diamonds, and its jewelry is made from 100% recycled materials.

Now that you’ve got some of the background on this brand, let’s get this 25karats review rolling with an overview of the company’s most notable highlights. 

Highlights

  • One of the largest selections of wedding rings in the US 
  • All jewelry is made from 100% recycled metals, and diamonds are guaranteed conflict-free 
  • Free engraving
  • Free resizing
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Free shipping in the US 
  • Layaway plan available 
  • 60-day money-back guarantee
25Karats Review

When it comes to choosing an engagement ring and wedding band, you need to find a design that will spark joy in you for life. Check out some of this brand’s most distinctive designs in our 25karats review below.

25karats Wedding Bands Review

Shopping for wedding bands can be one of the most exciting—and stressful!—things you ever do with your partner. Thankfully, 25karats is dedicated to taking the pain and worry out of the process as much as possible. In this section, this 25karats review takes a look at some of the brand’s bestselling ring designs, many of which are unisex.

25karats Elegant Wave Design Two-Tone Wedding Ring Review

Simplicity is always what you want in your wedding band, but the art of ring-making is to add those subtle details that elevate the simple and make it sublime. It would be hard to think of any design that accomplishes that aim better than the Elegant Wave Design Two-Tone Wedding Ring.

This gorgeous band is decorated with a gleaming, gently rolling wave-shaped cut around its circumference, a beautiful stylistic accent that will make for many an appreciative double take from those who notice it. The interior is polished yellow gold, while the exterior comes in your choice of 14K or 18K solid gold, palladium, or platinum. 

You can get the Elegant Wave Design Two-Tone Wedding Ring at a width of either 6.5 or 7mm, and finger sizes ranging from 4 to 15. There are a number of price points depending on how you customize the design: pricing starts at $645 (14K gold, 6.5mm, size 4) and goes up to $2,606 (palladium, 7mm, size 15). 

25karats Color Duo Contemporary Low Dome Wedding Band Set Review

You may be joined together forever, but you’re still two different people—so why not have your wedding bands reflect that? The Color Duo Contemporary Low Dome Wedding Band Set pairs a traditional, unadorned band for the gentleman with a delicate band for the lady that is finished with a ring of small, gleaming brilliant-cut diamonds.

Apart from this distinctive differentiation, the bond between the bands is amplified by their shared two-tone design, with 14K white gold on the outside and yellow gold on the inside. The Color Duo Contemporary Low Dome Wedding Band Set will run you $786 to $1,008 for the ladies’ band depending on finger size, and $517 to $792 for the men’s.

25karats Rolex Style Bestseller Wedding Ring Set Review

You only live once, as they say, so why not live loud? The Rolex Style Bestseller Wedding Ring Set is the last word in assertive luxury. The band is a hefty 8.5mm thick, and the watchband design can be finished in either white, yellow, or two-toned 14K gold. The ladies’ version also sports eight round-cut diamonds dotted around the circumference of the band.

Depending on finger size, the 14K gold version of the Rolex Style Bestseller Wedding Ring Set ranges from $1,688 to $2,363 for the women’s band, and $1,006 to $1,890 for the men’s. And if you’re really looking to splash out, you can get the same design in 18K gold ($3,758$6,050 total), platinum ($4,525$7,346 total), or palladium ($5,858$9,597 total).

25karats Wave Design Diamond Wedding Ring Set Review

If you really want to show that you and your partner are linked for life, you’ll definitely want to check out the Wave Design Diamond Wedding Ring Set. These matching 25karats wedding bands in 14K gold sport an elegant wave design etched into their exteriors, with the women’s version attractively offset by three beautiful round diamonds.

The Wave Design Diamond Wedding Ring Set is available in finger sizes 4 to 15.75. Pricing starts at $772 for the smallest women’s band and $651 for the smallest men’s, while the largest sizes will run you $1,125 and $1,324, respectively.

25karats Bestseller Shiny Hand Braided Wedding Ring Review

A distinctive detail on your wedding band doesn’t have to be overly flashy ornamentation. Walking that fine line between the eye-catching and the understated, the Bestseller Shiny Hand Braided Wedding Ring has a lovely woven design that is sure to elicit admiring (and perhaps envious?) comment.

You can get this band in widths of 5-7mm, and in your choice of four finishes (high polish, wire matte, sand blast, and satin). The Bestseller Shiny Hand Braided Wedding Ring is available in white or yellow 14K or 18K gold, platinum, or palladium, at the following price ranges (dependent on both finger size and band width):

  • 14K gold: $649$1,721
  • 18K gold: $948$2,515
  • Platinum: $1,185$3,146
  • Palladium: $1,633$4,329

25karats Anniversary Rings Review

You’ve stuck with each other through thick and thin, so when the anniversary of your special day arrives, you want to testify to your devotion in the most breathtaking way possible. Our 25karats review continues with a spotlight on three of the bestselling 25karats anniversary rings.

25karats Sapphire Baguette and Brilliant Round Diamond Anniversary Band Review

Blue sapphires symbolize many different things, including balance, serenity, and peace. But when it comes to the Sapphire Baguette and Brilliant Round Diamond Anniversary Band, the sensation that will be evoked the most is awe. This absolute stunner of a ring features a row of sparkling sapphires that is complemented by two bounding lines of white diamonds.

You’ve got no less than eight choices of precious metal with this ring: it comes in 14K or 18K yellow, white, or rose gold, as well as palladium or platinum, and is available in finger sizes 4 to 13.75. Price points are as follows:

  • 14K gold: $2,474
  • 18K gold: $2,740
  • Platinum: $2,939
  • Palladium: $3,390

25karats Classy Diamond Fancy Ring (0.16 ct.tw) Review

They call it classy for a reason! The Classy Diamond Fancy Ring is the ideal gift to bestow on the fancy lass in your life. The design strikes the perfect balance between old-fashioned ornateness and contemporary intricacy, with the dot pattern swirling around the lodestars of eight round-cut diamonds.

Available in 14K or 18K white, yellow, or rose gold, as well as platinum or palladium, the Classy Diamond Fancy Ring starts at $764.

25karats Low Set Trellis Setting 7 Stone Round Shank Anniversary Band (3/4 ct. t.w.) Review

There’s craftsmanship and then there’s craftsmanship, and the Low Set Trellis Setting 7 Stone Round Shank Anniversary Band is definitely the latter. The intricate wire-frame setting provides a delicate-looking but secure home for the seven glistening round-cut diamonds, which are perched daintily atop the thin band.

You can get the Low Set Trellis Setting 7 Stone Round Shank Anniversary Band in 14K white, yellow, or rose gold ($1,621), 18K gold in the same color options ($1,816), platinum ($1,969), or palladium ($2,298).

Who Is 25karats For? 

25karats Review

If you’re planning that life-changing moment and need something exceptionally stunning to make things official, 25karats has got you covered. Its incredibly wide selection of engagement rings, promise rings, and wedding bands has something for every style, from the subtle to the jaw-dropping.

The well-designed brand website makes customizing your ring by size and metal type a breeze. Also, the fact that all 25karats rings are made in the US means you can rest easy knowing both that the quality will be there, and that the manufacturing is done in an ethical manner. 

Further on that last point, 25karats uses exclusively conflict-free diamonds, and its bands are made from 100% recycled metals. So tick eco-consciousness off on your list of must-haves as well! 

25karats Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

25Karats Review

Since there are now quite a number of reputable online fine-jewelry retailers out there, you want to be sure you’re getting the best product at the best price available. When this 25karats review checked out customer feedback on this brand, it quickly became clear that many buyers feel that this is exactly what they received from 25karats. 

In the testimonials section of the brand website, customers consistently discuss the remarkable quality and design of the rings they purchased, as well as the brand’s exemplary customer service. One reviewer attested to the incredible variety of rings to choose from:

We are so pleased with our wedding set purchased from 25karats. I stumbled across the site searchIng for matching his and her wedding bands, and to my amazement they had countless styles to select from. The rings are just as beautiful as the pictures. Customer service was outstanding!!!

This same buyer also got a taste of 25karats’ responsiveness to customer issues, saying that

I gave an incorrect size for my ring. I called customer service, to let them know my ring was too small, my husband’s ring was just right. I shipped the rings back to be resized and 25karats returned them back to me in a week!!! Thank you 25karats!!

Third-party sites tell a similar tale. On TrustPilot, 25karats has an “Excellent” rating of 4.7/5 stars based on 30 reviews. One buyer recounted how the brand quickly helped them overcome their trepidation about purchasing such an expensive product on the internet:

I was very impressed with 25karats product, beautiful rings, and with their service. Was concerned about ordering online at first, but this company meets all expectations. Everything was on time and actually a better quality than expected. Thanks 25karats.

Wedding Wire has more good news for 25karats, awarding the brand 4.8/5 stars based on 64 reviews. One commenter noted how the brand’s attentive customer service team helped them navigate the tricky problem of finding the right style to suit two very different kinds of aesthetics:

These guys made our day! Finding our wedding bands was the most stressful part of the planning since we have very different tastes, but the agent at 25karats was professional and really on top of the subject. He was not only very patient but also very convincing. We ended up getting a matching set that we decided we both are happy about!

From everything this 25karats review could find, customers are over the moon about the craftsmanship and quality of this brand’s distinctive creations, as well as their experiences with its customer service team. The very few negative reviews we flagged were all addressed by the brand in extensive and detailed replies.

Is 25karats Worth It?

25karats Review

Based on all the info that this 25karats review could locate, we have little hesitation concluding that this brand is definitely worth it. The convenient ordering process, attentive customer service team, and completely in-house operation make what can be an extremely stressful experience into something that actually enhances the joy of your special moment.

The brand’s ethical and eco-conscious manufacturing is another definite plus, and the fact that this doesn’t entail any mark-up on the price tag is the cherry on top!

25karats Promotions & Discounts 

25karats Review

Fine jewelry can be a pretty pricey investment, so any way you can shave off a few dollars is welcome! Although the brand does occasionally offer discount codes, at the time of writing this 25karats review there are none currently running. However, we did find a few ways you can save.

  • Check back their website frequently for the seasonal coupons
  • Sign up for their newsletter to receive 10% OFF

Where to Buy 25karats 

25Karats Review

You can peruse the 25karats collection on the brand website, 25karats.com. If you’re in New York City, you can also stop in at the brand’s showroom to shop in-person. 

FAQ

25Karats Review

Who owns 25karats?

Naz & Mehmet Aksu co-founded 25karats in 2008 and still own it today. Naz Aksu is the current CEO of the company.

Does 25karats ship internationally?

Yes, the brand does indeed ship internationally! All international orders are liable for a flat shipping fee of $75

What is 25karats’ Shipping Policy?

25karats offers free shipping for all orders within the continental United States. All deliveries are fulfilled via FedEx. 

Orders up to $500 in value are shipped via FedEx Ground (5-7 business days), with the option to upgrade to 2-Day or Overnight shipping for an additional fee of $14 and $25, respectively. Orders valued between $500 and $2500 ship via FedEx 2-Day delivery, with the option to upgrade to Overnight for $10. Orders of $2500 and up ship for free via Overnight exclusively. 

As noted in our 25karats review above, international shipping is available for $75. Customers are responsible for any applicable duties, taxes, or fees. 

What is 25karats’ Return Policy?

25karats offers customers 60 days from the shipment date to return or exchange an item they are not fully satisfied with. In order to qualify for a return, all items need to be unworn and undamaged, and be accompanied by the proper documentation. Please note that engraved or custom jewelry and special orders are not eligible for return. 

To begin the return or exchange process, contact the 25karats customer service team to obtain a return merchandise authorization number (RMA #). Pack up your item(s) in their original packaging, include a copy of the sales receipt, and write the RMA # in a visible spot on the shipping box. The brand asks that customers obtain insurance for the package as well.

Return shipments should be sent to the following address: 

25K Shipping & Receiving Dept. 
64 West 48th St., Suite 1002 
New York, NY 
10036

You will receive an email notification once your return has been received. After the item has been inspected and deemed eligible for a return, your refund will be processed in the original form of payment within 5 business days. 

How to Contact 25karats

Got any questions after finishing this 25karats review? You can reach out to the brand’s customer service team via: 

  1. Phone: 1-800-201-3404 (Monday-Friday, 9:30am-6:30pm EST)
  2. Email: [email protected] 
  3. Contact form on brand website 
  4. Live chat on brand website during aforementioned service hours

Explore more options for everyday jewelry and statement pieces with these top designers:

Jeulia

Helloice

Maria Black

Melinda Maria

Girls Crew

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *