Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Review

About Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth Review

Brilliant Earth is the global leader in ethically sourced fine jewelry. The brand sells Beyond Conflict-Free™ diamonds, engagement rings, and fine jewelry both online and in showrooms across the country.

As noted in Hello Magazine and The Zoe Report, Brilliant Earth is one of the most ethical jewelry brands on the market. They have 735K Instagram followers who love flaunting their glittering engagement rings. 

In my Brilliant Earth engagement rings review, I’ll go over what makes this company stand out, how they verify their diamond sources, the details of their best-selling products, returns policy, and so much more, to help you make an informed decision.

Overview of Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Review 1

Beth Gerstein and Eric Grossberg founded Brilliant Earth in 2005. Placing ethical expectations as high as their standard for quality trinkets, they are now a global leader in ethically sourced and environmentally responsible jewelry production. 

Instead of cutting corners and acquiring diamonds as cheaply and quickly as possible, as most brands do, Brilliant Earth goes out of its way to remain certified with the Responsible Jewelry Council and push the boundaries even further.

Brilliant Earth’s diamonds are tracked on each step of their journey, from where they were mined through responsible practices, all the way to your doorstep.

That way, the company goes through the effort to ensure that it is absolutely not involved in slavery or human conflict ‘blood diamond’ activity.

On top of all that, Brilliant Earth uses recycled materials to create stunning jewelry, and they donate 5% of their profits to support mining communities around the world while nurturing rainforests that have been devastated by negligent excavation projects.

The quality of their jewelry is also world-class. From Brilliant Earth morganite rings to emerald engagement pieces, customers around the world (and their partners) report great satisfaction in their purchases.

It’s not a surprise, because Brilliant Earth also has so many customization options that your head would spin, if not for their easy-to-use website. With their simple interface, you can easily control, compare, and adjust your jewelry until it’s just right for you. 

Keep reading this Brilliant Earth engagement rings review for a few notable highlights about the brand:


  • Brilliant Earth offers a range of diamond rings, necklaces, and earrings 
  • Highly ethical practices that only source from humane and environmentally responsible communities
  • Offers both natural diamonds and artificial diamonds
  • Many customization options to create the ideal ring
  • Donates 5% of their profits to nurturing damaged rainforests and building healthy mining communities around the world
  • Payment installment options through Affirm cuts down on upfront costs
  • Excellent 30-day return policy
  • 24/7 customer service

Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Review

In this Brilliant Earth engagement ring review, I will examine in detail nine of the brand’s bestsellers. By the end of it, you will know how much these Brilliant Earth diamond rings cost, design options, best features, and much more.

Brilliant Earth Petite Twisted Vine Diamond Engagement Ring Review

The Twisted Vine Diamond Engagement Ring can be set with a round, oval, cushion, princess, pear, emerald, marquise, asscher, radiant, or heart-shaped diamond. Your options for carat size go from 1/3 carat to 2 ¾ carats.

Four claw prongs highlight and secure your diamond of choice, while a diamond pavé flows naturally with the twisting gold. 

You must choose between 18K yellow gold, 18K white gold, 14K rose gold, or platinum. The only price difference comes with platinum, which costs $2,100, while the rest cost $1,590.

Brilliant Earth Demi Diamond Engagement Ring Review

Coming in a classic and elegant band and completely covered in a diamond pavé, the Demi Diamond Engagement Ring glitters brilliantly like a comet. It will work with any outfit and maintain its classic Audrey Hepburn charm over the decades.

You must choose a diamond shape from 8 standard options, as well as the carat size and material. This gorgeous ring costs $2,275 in 18K white gold, yellow gold, and 14K rose gold. In platinum, it costs $2,530.

Brilliant Earth Moissanite Waverly Lab Diamond Ring Review

This is a champion among Brilliant Earth moissanite engagement rings. With 6 shapes, 8 dimensions, and 4 gold (and platinum) options to choose from, you can truly make it a unique piece of jewelry that checks all the boxes on your wishlist.

A timeless halo around the center stone combines with a pavé band for a punch of sparkle that lights up a room on its own. In this case, it’s second to the power of the pure moissanite. 

Starting at $2,180, the Moissanite Waverly Lab Diamond Ring can cost as much as $4,300 if you max out all the customizable elements. Whichever option you choose, Brilliant Earth moissanite rings are always colorless and “super premium” quality.

Brilliant Earth Tapered Baguette Diamond Engagement Ring Review

This time-honored design is destined to become a prized family heirloom someday. The simple creation uses baguette diamonds to huge the center diamond from either side, with a concentrated, powerful glitter effect. 

The rest of the center band is available in 18K white gold, yellow gold, rose gold, or platinum. You must choose your diamond from 8 shapes and a carat size ranging from 1/3 carat to 2 ¾ carats

The Tapered Baguette Diamond Engagement Ring costs $1,350 in 14K rose gold, or 18K white gold and yellow gold. Platinum is $1,590.

Brilliant Earth Sapphire Waverly Diamond Ring Review

The Sapphire Waverly Diamond Ring brings together the best of gemstones and diamonds. Its finely shaped and elegant diamond pavé band holds an ocean-blue sapphire. This is a statement piece and will stand out with a rich sparkle of color. 

The encircling diamond halo adds a ton of allure, drawing your eye into the depths of the sapphire. If you are searching for Brilliant Earth halo engagement rings, this is definitely one you want to check out. 

The Sapphire Waverly Diamond Ring is a favorite among Brilliant Earth sapphire engagement rings, perfect for the unconventional lady in your life. You can buy it in standard quality with a round 5.5mm sapphire for $2,800.

Changing the shape to cushion, oval, or emerald will increase the price by as much as $1,160, and the dimension can go as high as 7mm for a price increase of $2,000.

The 18K yellow gold and white gold, and 14K rose gold ring options cost the same amount, while platinum costs an extra $260.

Brilliant Earth Petite Comfort Fit Wedding Ring Review

Among Brilliant Earth wedding bands for women, the Petite Comfort Fit Wedding Ring is made for those who couldn’t care less about bells and whistles. Classic and refined, it carries a traditional romantic pride and will never go out of style. 

It comes in a rich 18K yellow gold or white gold, and a vibrant 14K rose gold makes it stand strong next to any engagement ring. Rounded for comfort, it can be purchased for $320 in 1.5mm width, and also in 2mm, 2.5mm, and 3mm, up to an extra cost of $250

The yellow gold, rose gold, and white gold options do not change the price; if you want it in platinum, the cost goes up by $200.

Brilliant Earth Yvette Diamond Ring Review

The Yvette Diamond Ring stands out for its exquisite marquise diamonds that angle down in the center, highlighting a single round diamond in the center. If you’re searching for Brilliant Earth rose gold engagement rings, don’t miss this one. 

The magnificent diamonds shine with the finely crafted gold in a way that catches and holds your gaze.

The unique shape and 1/6 carat (total) diamonds make it an ideal companion for an engagement ring—or any other ring—to stack on top, but it also looks stunning on its own. 

You can buy it in 14K rose gold and 18K yellow gold or white gold for $1,060, or in platinum for an additional $260.

What Kind of Diamonds Does Brilliant Earth Use?

Brilliant Earth Jewelry Review

You get to choose all the elements of your jewelry. A beautiful Brilliant Earth 2 carat diamond ring, for example, can be designed with a natural or lab-created diamond. Either way, you get to choose the shape, color, clarity, cut, and (of course) the price.

My Brilliant Earth engagement ring review found comparing diamonds an easy process. Many of their pieces are accompanied with high quality videos, so that you see exactly what you are buying.

Rest assured that they’re sourced only from eco-sustainable, non-conflict, non-abusive sources

Can You Negotiate With Brilliant Earth?

Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Review

Brilliant Earth offers flexible payment options to help facilitate a stress-free shopping experience including Affirm, Wells Fargo financing, custom financing, and more. You can find out more information on Brilliant Earth’s flexible payment options here.

Brilliant Earth’s showrooms offer a low-pressure welcoming environment for customers. Their associates do not earn a commission and will work with you to find the perfect piece of jewelry within your budget.

Brilliant Earth Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Review

In order to round out my Brilliant Earth engagement ring review, I took to the web for some more perspective on the brand. I wanted to know what buyers (and bride-to-be’s) were saying about their jewelry.

On their official site, many Brilliant Earth rings received a solid 5/5 star rating. The Petite Twisted Vine Diamond Engagement Ring was no exception.

Buyers raved about its elegant style, the fact that it was less expensive than other brands, and that it matched the pictures. 

One customer shared, “This ring is impeccable…The shape, clarity, weight, and color are immaculate. Style wise; I was able to find something that exemplified my fiancé’s personality. All those who went into creating this ring in its final form have my respect and gratitude.” 

On Trustpilot, my Brilliant Earth engagement ring review found that customers were overall pleased with the brand, giving it a “great” score of 4.1/5 stars. They love the customization options, and also the responsive customer service. 

Another point in the brand’s favor is that their diamonds come from an ethical source. One customer shared:

“I love that Brilliant Earth uses ethically sourced diamonds. Came across a beautiful necklace they posted on social media. Bought it for my girlfriend and it’s amazing! Ordering was easy.” 

Turning to Consumer Affairs, Brilliant Earth has a 4.2/5 star rating. Customers appreciate the wide range of products that can be used for events and life milestones other than engagement and marriage.

For example, unconventional gemstone pieces like the Brilliant Earth emerald engagement rings can provide buyers with versatility. 

Is Brilliant Earth legitimate? I only see reassuring ratings from Trustpilot and Consumer Affairs that confirm it’s a quality brand. On the official Brilliant Earth website, customers across the board express great appreciation for the totally ethical production. 

Are Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Worth It?

Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Review

There’s no doubt that Brilliant Earth is worth it. It is a compassionate brand that cares about the environment and their customers, going out of their way to provide top-quality customer service and assist with any concerns.

Plus, many love that their return policy is exceptional, and shipping is free. What’s more, the brand allows you to purchase their products through Affirm payments, making it easier than ever to make one of the biggest (and most important!) purchases of your life.

Customers from multiple websites give the brand solid ratings. Brilliant Earth lab-created diamonds are stunning and durable, with amazing customization options, so you and your partner are perfectly pleased with the result.

On top of that, the website and order process is easy to navigate, putting the buyer in control at all times. All in all, I believe that Brilliant Earth is worth the buy.

Brilliant Earth Promotions & Discounts

Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Review

Brilliant Earth has a dedicated promotion and offer page on their website where you can find all their latest deals!

Where to Buy Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings Review

In my research for this Brilliant Earth engagement ring review, I found that you can purchase their jewelry from the official website,, and nowhere else.


Brilliant Earth Review

Who owns Brilliant Earth?

Beth Gerstein and Eric Grossberg co-founded Brilliant Earth in 2005 and still own it today. They operate out of San Francisco.

How do you choose a diamond on Brilliant Earth?

Choosing a diamond on Brilliant Earth is a fun process. There are so many details to consider, but the user interface is easy to navigate. You start by choosing between 8 diamond shapes. 

Then you use a slider to set your price range, desired carats, quality of cut, color, and clarity. The diamonds are then listed for you to consider and compare. 

Does Brilliant Earth use real diamonds?

Brilliant Earth offers natural and lab-created diamonds. Their authentic stones are sourced from conflict-free and environmentally responsible sources.

Is Brilliant Earth GIA certified?

Yes! Brilliant Earth loose diamonds and rings are certified by GIA and the IGI, HRD, and GCAL grading organizations. They use the GIA color scale to evaluate and categorize their precious stones.

What sizes does Brilliant Earth have?

The brand carries ring sizes from 44.2mm (size 3) to 67.2mm (size 12). To find your perfect fit, ask them to send you a Brilliant Earth ring sizer—a complimentary service to ensure an error-free purchasing experience. 

You can also print out their Ring Sizing Guide and wrap it around your finger for a measurement.

Does Brilliant Earth offer a lifetime warranty?

Yes! This Brilliant Earth engagement ring review is pleased to say the brand offers a lifetime warranty on all of their fine jewelry, except for estate and vintage products.  

But you should know that it only covers “manufacturing defects”. Additionally, any alterations made to Brilliant Earth jewelry by someone outside of the brand would make the warranty for the product void.

What shipping does Brilliant Earth use?

Brilliant Earth shipping is free for the US, Canada, the UK, and Australia. They partner with FedEx for all of their orders but do not make any promises about delivery time because most products are unique and take different amounts of time to prepare. 

Once your order has been confirmed, expect it to arrive on or before the date shown on your confirmation email. Special deliveries can be arranged by calling 1-647-498-5665.

Does Brilliant Earth have a return policy?

Brilliant Earth has a wonderful return policy. Within 30 days of your order, you can exchange your purchase or receive a full refund. 

The company also pays for the return shipping if your order is a ring, loose gemstone, or a diamond. Check these boxes off to ensure the process goes smoothly:

  • Contact Brilliant Earth at 1-647-498-5665 to make your return within 30 days
  • Keep your item in “original, unworn condition”
  • Modified, resized, engraved, previously exchanged, and custom-designed items cannot be returned
  • A delivery request that places the delivery date past the 30 days does not change the return deadline
  • Keep the original documents that came with your order and include them in the return
  • Pack everything into the original packing material and double box it for the return

How to Contact Brilliant Earth

For any questions beyond this Brilliant Earth engagement ring review, get in touch with the brand through the following channels:

  • Phone: 1-647-498-5665 
  • Live chat on the website 24/7
  • Use the online contact form

Visit one of Brilliant Earth’s showrooms through a virtual appointment.

Looking for more engagement ring options? Here are a few brands we trust:

Manly Bands


Blue Nile

Gabriel & Co

James Allen

Ask the community or leave a comment


Customer Reviews

Leave a review

5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Stars

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required