Caraway Bakeware Review

About Caraway Bakeware

Caraway Bakeware Review

If you’re an avid user of Facebook, TikTok, or Instagram, then you’re probably already familiar with Caraway Bakeware. Their eye-catching ads showcase a glimmering assortment of monochrome pots and pans. Aesthetically pleasing in design, it’s the type of kitchenware you’d see influencers and celebs use in cook-related social media posts. 

Boasting over 411k Instagram followers, Caraway Bakeware is considered a top choice for home cooks and professional chefs. They’ve also been featured in several magazines, such as Cosmopolitan and Esquire. Oh, and did I mention that Caraway’s products are used by multiple celebs, including Kate Hudson and Mindy Kaling? 

If you value aesthetics, trends, and functional kitchen tools, this brand could be the perfect fit for you. Keep reading, as my Caraway Bakeware review will take a closer look at the company, its products, customer ratings, promotions, and more to help you decide if they’re worth checking out.

Overview of Caraway Bakeware

Caraway Bakeware Review

Picture this. You just picked up an amazing cookbook at your local library. Flipping through, you settle for beef bourguignon with salade niçoise for dinner. Such a sumptuous menu requires an arsenal of professional kitchenware, right? Unfortunately, your only options are a scratched nonstick pan and a chunky saucier that was seemingly built in the 18th century.

For those looking for an upgrade, Caraway Bakeware offers a great selection of modernized products. Their inventory includes frying pans, muffin tins, baking sheets, aprons, and more. But where did this brand all start?

Eye-opening epiphanies typically come in times of danger. For soon-to-be founder Jordan Nathan, it was accidentally burning a Teflon pan. The toxic fumes of exposed chemicals not only triggered some fright but also shock as well. 

Nathan was astounded that something so lethal could be found in an everyday product, which served as the initial inspiration for his brand, Caraway, committed to producing safe-to-use kitchenware.  

Shortly after its 2018 debut, Caraway managed to raise over $5.3 million in seed funding. Today, their headquarters are located in the heart of New York City. 

Before my Caraway Bakeware review gets cookin’, let’s go over some initial highlights.


Caraway Bakeware Review
  • A wide selection of non-toxic, aesthetically pleasing kitchenware to choose from
  • Positive customer reviews 
  • Eco-friendly 
  • Provides a recycling program to help mitigate waste 
  • Free shipping on orders over $90

Caraway Bakeware Review

Long gone are the days of cheap frying pans and Teflon kitchenware. This brand is home to dozens of non-toxic, well-built cookware. For those in need of some recommendations, I will highlight a few notable contenders within my Caraway Bakeware review.

Caraway Bakeware Set Review

From bread to cake, sourcing the best ingredients can ensure another round for seconds but let’s not forget the importance of professional-grade kitchen equipment.

You’d be surprised by the amount of cooking fails associated with poorly made pots and pans. If you’re not keen on burning your brownies, the Bakeware Set is considered a level-up of what you’ve already got.

Non-toxic, coated in ceramic, and oven-safe for up to 550° F, you can take care knowing that this bundle is equipped to handle the wear and tear of cooking. Available in 7 colors, you can buy the Bakeware Set in two different options:

  • 11-piece set: $395 (originally priced at $545)
  • 5-piece set: $245 (originally priced at $295)

The 11-piece Caraway Bakeware Set includes:

  • 18” x 13” baking sheet 
  • 10” x 15” baking sheet 
  • 12-cup muffin pan 
  • 9” x 13” rectangle pan
  • 18” x 13” cooling rack
  • 9” square pan 
  • 1lb loaf pan
  • Two 9” circle pans 
  • Two storage racks

The 5-piece set features one storage rack, two baking sheets, one rectangle pan, and one 12-cup muffin pan.

Caraway Baking Sheet Review

I once made the mistake of baking brownies without coating the pan with butter. Trust me, the last thing you want to do is to scrap your mistakes with a wire sponge on a Saturday afternoon. 

If you prefer the ‘peel, pop, and let cool’ approach, the Caraway Baking Sheet can do just the trick. Lined with a non-stick ceramic coating, this kitchen essential is a must-have for baked goods.

Built with handles, this cooking tray can help ensure an easy grip from to or from the oven. The Caraway Baking Sheet comes in large (18” x 13”) for $55 and medium (15” x 10”) for $45. If you want both sizes, you can buy them in a bundle for $90 instead of $100 when purchased individually.

Caraway Bakeware Circle Pan Review 

Cake-making is not only an art, it’s also a skill. It takes a high level of expertise and patience to create something that’s both delicious and pleasing to the eye. If you want to simplify the process, the Bakeware Circle Pan can help ensure zero stickage. 

Lined in ceramic and completely non-toxic, you can take care knowing that those oven burns are completely your fault.

Made with a 9” diameter, the Bakeware Circle Pan can easily make cakes for weddings, birthdays, or anniversaries. It currently retails for $70 instead of $80 if you want to buy a pack of two. Those who just need one can expect to pay $40 at checkout. 

Caraway Baking & Cooling Duo Review 

Ideal for cookies, brownies, macarons, and puffed pastries, the Baking & Cooling Duo can help ensure that your two-hour afternoon activity stays intact.

It provides an ample amount of space for baked goods to pipe down, as it comes in an 18” x 13” tray. Non-toxic and coated in ceramic, it saves you the need to buy cooking spray and parchment paper.

Provided in several different colors, the $95 Baking & Cooling Duo is currently on sale for $85. If you already have the baking sheet, you can buy the cooling rack on its own for $40.

Who Is Caraway Bakeware For?

Caraway Bakeware Review

Elegantly designed and exceptional in quality, Caraway Bakeware is something you’d find in a Food & Wine magazine. It’s the kind of brand that you’d champion on Instagram or TikTok, as it mainly caters to the aesthetically-pleasing side of food. 

Price-wise, I think it’s fair to say that Caraway Bakeware is quite reasonable. They aren’t as impressive as professional-grade stainless steel pans, but they’re relatively reliable if you’re a novice home cook.

Caraway Bakeware Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Caraway Bakeware Review

Caraway has taken the internet by storm. Praised for its product quality and aesthetics, it’s practically become the Gucci of kitchenware. If you prefer specifics, their products hold over 2.1k reviews in total, averaging 4.9/5 stars. Home cooks reported that its products are well worth the money, as their pans and trays are easy to use and clean

One reviewer said this about the Bakeware Set: “The quality and color of the Bakeware set is everything I have been looking for, added bonus they all match! So I get to look fancy and like I have it all together with my friends.”

Another reviewer expressed their appreciation for the brand’s pans: “Not only is the material better for our health but they are the easiest pans to cook in. I love them. Not to mention they are so sleek and cute.”

While writing my Caraway Bakeware review, I also found several independent blogs and magazines that took to critique the brand’s equipment.

Food Network and Prudent Reviews stated that their trays and pans passed the quality control test. Both authors concluded that Caraway is a trusted source in providing affordable, non-toxic kitchen tools

Food Network wrote: “Eco-conscious families, newlyweds looking for a cookware overhaul, and first-time home buyers (or renters!) in search of adding a fresh pop of color to their kitchen will all love Caraway’s versatility, colorful design, and clever organization.” 

And then Prudent Reviews said: “If you’re set on buying ceramic non-stick cookware, Caraway is one of the best brands to buy. It’s got a modern design, thick and sturdy aluminum base, high heat tolerance, and heats quickly and evenly.”

Given the significant amount of positive feedback, there are a lot of reasons to make curious customers commit to their final order.

Is Caraway Bakeware Legit?

Caraway Bakeware Review

The number of negative comments pales in comparison to the number of positive ones I found online. All things considered, Caraway is legit.

Is Caraway Bakeware Worth It?

Caraway Bakeware Review

If you encountered a Caraway ad before, you’re probably within the targeted demographic that values aesthetics and modernized kitchenware. I can confidently report that this brand is not a product of false advertising, as home cooks attest to its quality and durability

Available in several fun colors, Caraway products are not only functional but can also add a pop of color to your cupboard. 

Caraway Bakeware Promotions & Discounts 

Caraway Bakeware Review

Before I end my Caraway Bakeware review, I thought it best to feature a few special offers provided by the brand. 

I found out that they have a refer-a-friend program, where customers can receive a free linen (with their next order) for every successful referral.

The brand is also currently having a Holiday Sale. They’re offering up to 20% off all of their non-toxic essentials. You can also bundle up to unlock greater savings. The Offer is auto applied at checkout. The savings are as follows:

  • 10% on orders $85+
  • 15% on orders $425+
  • 20% on orders $525+

Where to Buy Caraway Bakeware

Caraway Bakeware Review

Looking to modernize your kitchen space? If so, you can head over to to see what they have in store. You can also find their products sold on:

  • Indigo 
  • Bed Bath & Beyond 
  • Nordstrom 
  • Crate & Barrel 


Caraway Bakeware Review

Who owns Caraway Bakeware?

Caraway Bakeware is owned by CEO Jordan Nathan. 

Does Caraway Bakeware ship internationally?

Unfortunately, I found out that they only ship within the United States at the time of my Caraway Bakeware review.

What is Caraway Bakeware’s Shipping Policy?

Caraway offers free shipping on orders that total $90 or more. In terms of wait times, it typically takes 2-5 business days for packages to arrive. It’s worth mentioning that the brand provides expedited delivery for a select fee. 

To help keep tabs on your purchase, the company will issue a tracking number alongside a confirmation email. 

What is Caraway Bakeware’s Return Policy?

Caraway offers a 30-day window for customers to send back their products. If your item is damaged in any way, the brand may charge a restocking fee of up to 15%.

Thankfully, it appears that the company provides a free shipping label for buyers to use. To start a return, you must use their portal located on their website. 

How to Contact Caraway Bakeware

For any questions or concerns unrelated to my Caraway Bakeware review, you can contact the brand through:

Check out similar brands you might like:

Calphalon Review

Misen Cookware Review

Made In Cookware Review

Zwilling Non Stick Pan Review

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required