Food & Beverage

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

About Magic Spoon  

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

Magic Spoon specializes in healthy versions of traditional and often sugary cereal alternatives. Marketed as a cereal brand for adults, Magic Spoon has gained widespread recognition for its novel idea. According to Fast Company, “Magic Spoon is an adult version of what you love as a kid- without the sugar, carbs, or guilt.”

Boasting a following of over 235k on Instagram, the company has also been featured in media outlets such as CNN, Forbes, and Delish. With brands that dominate the cereal playing field such as Fruit Loops, Lucky Charms, and Cocoa Pebbles, how does Magic Spoon measure up?

Keep reading this Magic Spoon cereal review as we will explore the brand, its products, customer ratings, promotions, and more, to help you decide if their products are worth the buy. 

Overview of Magic Spoon

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

It all started with a bowl of cereal (surprised as much?) More specifically, Gabi Lewis and Greg Sewitz, grew up eating cereal for breakfast every morning.

It was usually the same brands that offered that classic sugary bite, which inevitably led to a carb-induced crash later in the afternoon. Their love of unhealthy cereal prevented them from being productive.

The two friends searched for healthier alternatives to their sugary favorites but ended up with nothing. Gabi and Greg soon found out that the average American eats 100 bowls of cereal a year.

Even so, nearly every option on the market contained no substantial nutritional value. And so, they decided to take action. Gabi and Greg sought to create the ultimate cereal that still held that sugary nostalgic factor but with fewer carbs.

Founded in 2019 with its headquarters in Brooklyn, New York, Magic Cereal was born. Designed as a guilt-free treat for adults, grownups can still feel like a kid again without undergoing that sugar-induced crash later in the day. 

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

“We experimented for over a year to create a cereal inspired by the flavors and nostalgia of Saturday-morning-cartoon cereal but upgraded for a 21st-century consumer. A guilt-free treat that tastes like you remember and you can eat at any time of day.”

Before we get into this Magic Spoon cereal review, let’s go over some initial pros and cons.


  • Multiple flavors of cereal to choose from including fruity, peanut butter, cocoa, and more
  • Magic Spoon cereals contain 0 grams of sugar, is low in carbs, and high in protein 
  • Customers can subscribe to have their Magic Spoon cereal boxes be delivered each month
  • Positive buyer reviews
  • 100% Happiness Guarantee for a full refund if customers are unsatisfied


  • Only available within the United States 
  • Customers must purchase at least one case (4 boxes) per order

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

The memory of waking up early for school, going to the kitchen to pull out your favorite cereal for breakfast, and eating it as you watch your morning cartoons, is such a nostalgic feeling.

Unfortunately, we aren’t as energetic as we were when we were kids and we quickly grew up to realize that most traditional cereal brands are chalked full of unhealthy sugars and carbs. But that doesn’t mean we can’t still enjoy it. 

Magic Spoon inhabits that same nostalgic-for-your-childhood factor by subtracting all of those unnecessary calories. We’ll take a look at all the cereal they have to offer, so read on.

Magic Spoon Maple Waffle Cereal Review 

Think like a kid. What is even better than a birthday cake? A birthday cake waffle, of course! This Magic Spoon cereal contains those iconic childhood flavors of sweet vanilla cake, creamy frosting, and a touch of rainbow sprinkles.

To make it breakfast appropriate, they’ve added the taste of hot, crunchy waffles with a drizzle of sticky, buttery, maple syrup to bring it all together. While a birthday cake waffle probably contains thousands of calories, a bowl of this cereal has only 3 grams of net carbs.

This tasty maple-flavored cereal contains 11 grams of protein, and only amounts to 100 calories with nothing artificial added. Make the Magic Spoon Maple Waffle Cereal the ultimate birthday cereal (we don’t recommend adding a celebratory candle in your bowl) for $39, available in cases containing four boxes.

Magic Spoon Frosted Cereal Review 

Contrary to belief, those iconic kids commercials of Tony the Tiger recommending his Frosted Flakes to aspiring young athletes to get them energized for their next game- is false advertising.

High in sugar, it’ll provide a quick boost of energy but is not enough nutrients to keep you going for the rest of the day. Instead of opting for the Tiger, go for the wizard holding a spoon riding a bunny, which is the mascot featured on the box of Magic Spoon Frosted Cereal

Containing hints of mellow vanilla and campfire marshmallow, this Magic Spoon cereal has the same classic taste without a heaping tablespoon of sugar. A bowl only contains 3 grams of net carbs, 11 grams of protein, and 110 calories.

For a set of four boxes, the Magic Spoon Frosted Cereal costs $39, which is approximately $1.39 per serving. However, you can save 10% if you sign up for a subscription, which amounts to $35. This now works out to just $1.25 per bowl. 

Magic Spoon Blueberry Cereal Review 

Blueberry muffins are one of the most iconic breakfast foods out there. But if you’re a committed cereal fan, try out the Magic Spoon Blueberry Cereal. With sweet notes of summertime blueberries, you’ll be sure to be as happy as an astronaut riding an octopus. At least, that’s what we can tell from the box.

With 3 grams of net carbs and 11 grams of protein, this cereal is devoid of any artificial flavorings and amounts to only 110 calories. Pour yourself a serving of richly flavored Planet Blue O’s with the Magic Spoon Blueberry Cereal for $39 ($1.39 per bowl) or subscribe for $35 ($1.24 per serving).

Magic Spoon Peanut Butter Cereal Review 

The peanut butter spectrum goes like this: you either hate it or you love it. The Magic Spoon Peanut Butter Cereal is made for people of the latter. If your dreams are made of velvety smooth peanut butter with hints of crunchy nuts, chances are that this specialty cereal isn’t just going to be consumed at breakfast. 

There’s no need to feel guilty in satisfying your peanut butter cravings too as this is a much healthier version of any cereal alternative. The peanut butter cereal includes 3 grams of net carbs, 11 grams of protein, and contains 130 calories.

Pour some cold milk into your bowl and bam, you’ve got a peanut butter smoothie dancing upon your taste buds. For a one-time purchase, you can buy the Magic Spoon Peanut Butter Cereal for $39 ($1.39 per bowl) or subscribe for $35 ($1.25 per bowl). 

Magic Spoon Cocoa Cereal Review 

Chocolate. The word alone brings forth images of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, trick-or-treating, or receiving a box full of treats from your secret Valentine. It can also remind us of breakfast, too, where we ate numerous bowls of Count Chocula and Cocoa Pebbles.

But let’s face it, it isn’t the healthiest choice first thing in the morning. That is, with the exception of the Magic Spoon Cocoa Cereal. The Magic Spoon Cocoa Cereal will take you back to those whimsical, Willy-Wonka-esque memories of unwrapping a chocolate bar for a sweet snack.

Made out of rich, dark cocoa, this chocolatey cereal is completely guilt-free. It contains only 3 grams of net carbs, 11 grams of protein and amounts to 110 calories. This chocolatey goodness is priced at $39 ($1.39 per serving) or $35 ($1.25 per bowl) by subscription.

Magic Spoon Fruity Cereal Review 

Some of us grew up eating a bowl of Fruit Loops, as we tried to worm our way out of the maze printed on the back of the cereal box. If the memory of Toucan Sam has you craving for a bowl of fruity deliciousness, try opting for the Magic Spoon Fruity Cereal instead.

High in protein, it is a much healthier alternative, as it only contains 3 grams of net carbs and 110 calories. Flavored with those child-like notes of orange, cherry, blueberry and other fruity combos, a bite of these colorful o’s will be sure to bring upon a toothy grin.

In one bowl, you get a vibrant mix of turquoise blue, tropical red, and summertime yellow. The Magic Spoon Fruity Cereal costs $39 for a one-time purchase ($1.39 per serving) or $35 ($1.25 per bowl) by subscription.

Magic Spoon Cinnamon Cereal Review

As chocolate and sugar continue to be a coveted kid favorite, cinnamon is usually left as the underdog. But let’s face it, churros, oatmeal, French toast, and of course, the cinnamon roll, wouldn’t be the same if it just contained only sugar. The Magic Spoon Cinnamon Cereal puts this integral spice in the limelight. 

The inclusion of nutty cinnamon with that subtle kick of pepperiness is the perfect combination to offset any intense sugary flavor. But don’t mistake this as an average bowl of Cinnamon Toast Crunch.

The cinnamon-flavored cereal only contains 4 grams of net carbs, 11 grams of complete protein, and accounts for just 100 calories. A set of 4 boxes costs $39 ($1.39 per bowl) or $35 ($1.25 per bowl) if you subscribe to Magic Spoon.

Magic Spoon Variety Box Review 

Sometimes we like something different to look forward to every morning. The Magic Spoon Variety Box gives you a taste of all of their iconic flavors including fruity, frosted, cocoa, and blueberry.

While it’s meant that you enjoy each box of this rainbow quartet separately, why not try combining two cereal flavors to create something unworldly? Take, for instance, mixing the Magic Spoon Fruity Cereal and the Magic Spoon Blueberry Cereal for the maximum sugary explosion. 

The variety box sets are Magic Spoon cereal keto options, meaning that is perfect for anyone on a ketogenic or low-carb diet. If you’re wondering how this contains 0 grams of sugar, the answer is allulose (a sugar found in figs and maple syrup). It tastes just like regular sugar but has no glycemic impact and virtually no calories.

The Magic Spoon Variety Box Set costs just $39 for a one-time purchase, which is just $1.39 per serving. You can also subscribe to get it delivered monthly for $35 ($1.25 per serving).

Magic Spoon Cereal Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

This Magic Spoon cereal review found that the majority of customers enjoy it. On the company website, there are over 17,000 customer reviews with an average of 5/5 stars.

Customers report that their cereal tastes good and was almost identical to their brand-name counterparts. They also state how they loved that the cereal provided them with a healthier alternative

“I bought one case, and immediately signed up for a subscription. Fruity and blueberry are identical in taste to their brand name counterparts, but they taste even better –it’s crazy! … I will never eat regular cereal again. Plus, I can eat two bowls a day and still lose weight,” one reviewer wrote on the Magic Spoon website.

There are also positive reviews on their Facebook page as well. Over there, they have a ranking of 4.4/5 stars with over 396 ratings. There are continued accounts of buyers happy with the flavor and helped them gain energy for the day ahead. Some people have noted that they won’t go back to their traditional cereal brands again. 

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

“I have a cereal subscription and it’s amazing! I’m not doing keto, but I love the nutrition facts and the great tasting flavors! I mix the cocoa and peanut butter (because, duh!) and the frosted and fruity are my other faves,” one Magic Spoon cereal review says on their Facebook page.

This Magic Spoon cereal review found a few customer complaints on their Amazon page and Facebook. Some customers noted that the cereal sticks to their teeth in an unpleasant way.

Additionally, some weren’t a fan of the price, stating that it was more expensive than healthy grocery store alternatives. There were also some customers that didn’t like the taste.

“I ordered 4 boxes and ended up with 6. I paid $60.00 for 6 boxes of cereal. This cereal tasted awful.  Over priced!! Yucky!!! Don’t waste your money,” one Magic Spoon review wrote on their Facebook page. 

Is Magic Spoon Cereal Worth It?

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

This Magic Spoon cereal review recommends this company to anyone looking for a healthier version of their favorite cereal. All of their flavors look enticing to the eye and seem to be identical to those store-bought alternatives like Fruit Loops and Cocoa Pebbles.

Customers can still enjoy their childhood favorites without the guilt of ingesting hundreds of calories and unnecessary sugars. While many adults enjoy the cereal, Magic Spoon products are great for kids as well, indicated by the mascots and fun activities included on the boxes.

While there are many positive customer reviews that praise the taste of their cereal, it is quite expensive, especially with shipping fees attached. On the other hand, if you eat cereal daily and find yourself gaining weight, it’s not a bad idea to test out Magic Spoon cereal. 

Magic Spoon Cereal Promotions & Discounts 

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

We couldn’t find a Magic Spoon promo code at this time, but keep checking their website regularly for updates.

Where to Buy Magic Spoon Cereal

Magic Spoon Cereal Review

You can shop this tasty breakfast and snack food on Their cereals are also available on the Magic Spoon Amazon page.=


Where is Magic Spoon Cereal manufactured? 

This Magic Spoon cereal review hasn’t come across any information about where their cereal is manufactured. However, we do know that their headquarters are based in New York. 

What is Magic Spoon made of? 

Magic Spoon cereal ingredients are made with a variety of natural additives. This includes ingredients such as milk protein blend, sweetener blend, oil blend, tapioca starch, cocoa powder, and more. 

How long does Magic Spoon take to ship?

Magic Spoon uses DHL and UPS as their main couriers. The company only ships within the United States, this excludes international orders including Magic Spoon Canada. Once customers place their order online, it will process within 1 business day. Customers can monitor their orders by using the tracking number given to them through email. 

What is Magic Spoon’s Return Policy?

This Magic Spoon cereal review hasn’t come across the company’s return policy. If customers are unsatisfied with their order, they can contact Magic Spoon customer service for a full refund under their 100% Happiness Guarantee. 

How to Contact Magic Spoon

If you have questions that are unrelated to this Magic Spoon cereal review, you can contact the company via email at [email protected].

If you’re not sold on Magic Spoon, check out healthy cereal from Schoolyard Snacks.

Ask the community or leave a comment

Ask a Question
You didn't have any opinion on the fake 5-star reviews, how nobody can submit new reviews, or how their cereal tastes like gritty, burned chocolate sauce?
Asked by Mario Lopez (2 years ago) Reply

See title.

too expensive
Asked by rose (2 years ago) Reply

too costly not enough cereal in each box

Asked by Marilyn (1 year ago) Reply

Please send ingredient label of each cereal. Thanks. MH

Answered by Grant (1 year ago) Reply

Y when they make something like this they have to take the piss with the price.$39 for 4 boxes.u are of your tits.thats litrely $10 for a box of just wow thats just pure greed.its discusting that u charge this u should be ashamed.

Nutritional Panel Impossible to Read Online
Asked by sabi (1 year ago) Reply

Not sure there is any real food in this product. Why not just step away from the addictive nature of hyper-palatability and over indulgence that we’ve been trained to expect from every morsel we tuck into?

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required