Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks Review

When it comes to finding quality meat, the steaks are high. No one wants to settle for a poor cut when you could have a choice slab marbled to perfection. 

With that in mind, I’m putting two of the best meat distribution companies head to head for your consideration. Introducing Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks.

About Omaha Steaks 

Omaha Steaks have a history that’s as American as apple pie. The company was founded by Latvian immigrant B.A. Simon in 1917 and has kept a Simon family member at the helm ever since.

They grew out of a single-office meat packaging company into one of the nation’s most celebrated meat delivery services. They’ve evolved alongside technology to make their services as effortless as their meat is delicious. 

About Kansas City Steaks 

Kansas City Steaks has its origins in, you guessed it, Kansas City. They began as a quaint butcher shop in 1932 with a single goal in mind: to give customers the best meat possible.

They’ve kept this goal in mind as they grew over the past 90 years. They prioritize customer satisfaction over everything, which is why they put so much work into wet aging their steaks, cut only the finest meats from the bone, and ensure all their items with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. 

Nowadays, the brand ships their steaks, chickens, and other meats to hungry American mouths in every state.

Deciding which company to shop with isn’t as simple as choosing whether you want the lean cut or the fatty cut of a pork chop (hint: always go for the fatty cut).

That’s why I’ll cover the most important details of each company in this Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review. 

I’ll gaze into my all-seeing orb to tell you about the two brands’ practices, products, customer reception, deals, and more so that you can be the most informed customer on the internet.

What To Consider

Target audience 

It wouldn’t be fair to compare a private slaughterhouse that sources fresh meat to a mass-producing meat factory that throws pigs into the meat grinder without a second thought. 

That’s why I’m measuring two brands with similar people in mind in this Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review: honest folks who want easy-to-prepare meats.

Variety of products 

Much like how the Romans expanded their vision outside of Italy, it’s imperative that you expand your vision of meat beyond steaks.

There are numerous meat companies that specialize in just fatty chunks of steak, but how many can you name that distributes chicken, pork, seafood, desserts, wine, and seasonings?

I can name two, and I’m not providing any hints as to which ones I’m thinking of.

Value packs   

Buying a single steak can often feel like a missed opportunity. You pay a large amount only to receive a single serving. 

That’s why I’m happy to report that both Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks have membership opportunities, business discounts, packaged bundles, and more. 

Sustainability 

These two companies each have a long history of meat distribution in the United States, but come up short in regards to their meat practices and cattle-raising protocol. By that, I mean that neither offers a clear vision of what goes on behind the scenes.

Accessibility 

While researching for this Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review, I found that the former brand has over 50 in-store locations across the United States as well as the ability to send their products across most of America and Canada.

Likewise, Kansas City Steaks work to get their meats in the hands of Americans in all of the nation’s 50 beautiful states.

Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast vs Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast Review:

This is a head-to-head comparison of two steak companies that are so proud of their prime slabs of meat that they each include steak in their company’s name. 

It’s only fitting that I get into the juicy details of each brand’s juiciest cuts in this Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review. Get out your cleavers and bibs, this one is about to get bloody.

The Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast is a family gathering in the form of meat. The brand wants you to take it easy when it comes time to indulge in this fatty delight. They’ve done the honors of carving it for you.

This steak is flash-frozen to preserve its freshness. That also makes preparation easy. You can slice it as is, or throw it between two slices of bread and make yourself a mock Philly Cheesesteak.

Additionally, the Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast has been aged for nearly a month, turning into a ticking time bomb of flavor. Omaha Steaks even went the extra mile and trimmed this roast’s exterior fat layer for you. 

It comes in 4lbs and 8lbs sizes.

By comparison, the Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast is available in sizes from 3.5lbs to 6lbs. While that’s a bit smaller, this roast isn’t lacking in its own powerful flavor. 

That’s because this roast is marbled, aged for 28 days, and as tender as a Christmas card from your grandma. It’s also been deboned. To further enhance this item’s convenience, Kansas City Steaks offer some preseasoned varieties of this roast:

• Garlic and Herb Prime Rib Roast 
• Traditional Rib Roast
• Roasted Steakhouse Rub Prime Rib

The Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast is also injected with a solution of water, salt, potassium phosphate, and sodium citrate that increases its tenderness and final aroma. Some might err away from this solution, but Kansas City Steaks use it to optimize their item’s delicacy.

These are both prime meats (pun unintended) that can either feed an entire family or keep you feeling full until you start your own family. 

The Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast comes in a larger size and doesn’t seem to contain any injected solutions, which may be the deciding factor between these two items.

Omaha Steaks Marinated Salmon Fillets vs Kansas City Steaks Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon Review:

There’s a reason the fourth food group is called “meat and alternatives,” and it’s not the Beyond Burger. Many home cooks leave salmon to the experts – namely fishermen or sushi chefs – but I know there are some adventurous cooks reading this Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review.

This segment is for those who are up for the challenge of cooking salmon at home. The first step to making the best fish of your life is selecting the right fish. 

Thankfully, there are two solid options in the form of the Omaha Steaks Marinated Salmon Fillets and the Kansas City Steaks Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon.

The former is Omaha Steaks’ sublime take on salmon. The fish in question can sometimes be finicky to flavor properly. Luckily, this brand has your back.

The Omaha Steaks Marinated Salmon Fillets come preseasoned with olive oil, paprika, garlic, pepper, onion, and oh my god I just had to wipe the drool off my keyboard. To simplify cooking even more, Omaha Steak individually packages, slices, and debones each fillet.

They epitomize that their salmon fillets are a breeze to cook, claiming you can have a serene fishy experience on the dinner table in less than 15 minutes. The salmon used in Omaha Steaks Marinated Salmon Fillets are ethically farmed off the coast of Chile.

Meanwhile, the Kansas City Steaks Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon appears as pleasing to the eyes as it does to the stomach. Its deep hue communicates that an expertly prepared salmon is about to swim down your gullet and that you’ll likely love it. 

This salmon fillet doesn’t come preseasoned but it seems that Kansas City Steaks are confident enough in their craft – and your cooking skills – that it doesn’t need to be. Each fillet comes vacuumed-sealed to preserve peak freshness. 

That vacuum sealing also preserves the Kansas City Steaks Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon texture, which sits at the perfect level of firmness.

Both of these salmon fillets may have you swimming upstream to get your hands on more. The  Omaha Steaks Marinated Salmon Fillets is better for people who don’t want to think about their cooking and simply wish to consume.

On the other hand, the Kansas City Steaks Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon grants more freedom flavor-wise because it doesn’t come pre-seasoned. 

Omaha Steaks Customer Favorites with Free Digital Kitchen Scale vs Kansas City Steaks Tour of Good Taste Review:

Name the top five most important kitchen utensils off the top of your head. They’re probably a frying pan, a cutting board, a chef’s knife, a good spatula, and a salt grinder among your selections.

Sorry to say pal, but you’ve got it wrong. The best kitchen tools are the foods you prepare. This section of my Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review will compare each company’s kitchen sink offerings, in that these are their sampling packs that deliver choices of their best products. 

First up is the Omaha Steaks Customer Favorites with Free Digital Kitchen Scale. One of its obvious advantages is that it comes with a digital kitchen scale, an instrument I recommend for any home cook.

This favorites collection includes the following:

• 4 Omaha Steaks Butcher’s Cut Filet Mignons
• 4 Omaha Steaks Boneless Chicken Breasts
• 4 Omaha Steaks Burgers
• 4 Omaha Steaks Gourmet Jumbo Franks
• One package of Omaha Steaks All-Beef Meatballs
• 4 Omaha Steaks Caramel Apple Tartlets
• 1 jar of Omaha Steaks Seasoning

Now that’s what I call a feast. If you order that item please invite me over for your next holiday dinner.

Kansas City Steaks aren’t shy about their offerings though. The Kansas City Steaks Tour of Good Taste includes these select items:

• 4 Kansas City Steaks Strip Steaks
• 4 Kansas City Steaks Chicken Breasts
• 8 Kansas City Steaks Classic Steakburgers
• 1 Kansas City Steaks Original Steak Seasoning packet
• 1  Kansas City Steaks Cook Book 

Based on quantity alone, Omaha Steaks offers more in this category. Their variety simply dwarves Kansas City Steaks’. However, never doubt the potential of a good cookbook, as it can open up more doors to great cooking than a piece of meat ever could.

Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks: Quality of Ingredients 

Now, this is where things get a little bit trickier. Both brands are a little stingy when it comes to divulging where exactly their meat comes from and how it’s raised.

I do know that both brands have grass-fed products, but Kansas City Steaks primarily relies on corn-fed animals to get their cuts.

I’m not making any headlines by saying that grass-fed is better than corn-fed, but that is the truth of the matter, giving Omaha Steaks a slight edge in this department.

Fortunately, I do know that both of the brands rigorously test for quality after the 28-day aging process.

Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks: Price & Value

Meat is not valued by its weight, but by its quality. With that being said, this section of my Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review will pit the two brands’ best-selling products against each other in a head-to-head comparison of their prices.

Here are the costs of the Omaha Steaks products:

• Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast: $150 for a 4oz roast or on sale for $300 for 8oz roast (regular 8oz roast price is $600)
• Omaha Steaks Marinated Salmon Fillets: on sale for $30 for 4 fillets or $60 for 8 fillets, regular price is $60 for 4 fillets and $120 for 8 fillets
• Omaha Steaks Customer Favorites with Free Digital Kitchen Scale: on sale for $141, regular price is $295

I’ll keep this section sweet and simple by showing you Kansas City Steaks’ prices in list form:

• Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast: $156 for a 6lb. roast
• Kansas City Steaks Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon: $85 for 4 7oz fillets or $125 for 8 7oz fillets
• Kansas City Steaks Tour of Good Taste: currently on sale for $150, regular price is $225

Evidently, neither brand offers a premium price compared to the other. When you take out factors like sales promotions and garnished seasonings, you’re getting similar amounts of meat for similar amounts of money. 

Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks: What Do Customers Think?  

Now for the juiciest of sections, the main event of the Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review. It’s time to weigh in on what real customers think about each brand. These consumer insights can help fill in any gaps you may have about either company.

Let’s start this rodeo by comparing each brand’s customer scores from their respective websites. Here’s what Omaha Steaks buyers rated as the best-selling products available:

• Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast: 5/5 stars based on close to 10 ratings
• Omaha Steaks Marinated Salmon Fillets: 4.7/5 stars based on more than 450 ratings

Omaha Steaks product reviews were assaulted by the word “delicious” like it was trying to orchestrate a company takeover. Clearly, the brand’s customers enjoyed every bite of their purchases. 

This satisfied buyer said that the Omaha Steaks Boneless Heart of Prime Rib Roast was “Excellent. You really appreciate your meal and feel like your in your own private restaurant !!!”

Customers also adored how easy the meals were to prepare. They appreciated how Omaha Steaks took most of the legwork out of preparing the meat, granting customers more time to carry out their daily tasks and rituals without slaving over a hot kitchen pan.

This convenience is demonstrated in this 5/5 star customer review of the brand’s salmon fillets: “Wonderful and simple great for a last minute meal.”

Now those are some high points of praise! Let’s see if Kansas City Steak drummed up an equal amount of applause from their customers:

• Kansas City Steaks Prime Rib Roast: 4.3/5 stars coming from over 500 ratings
• Kansas City Steaks Tour of Good Taste: 4.4/5 stars coming from more than 50 ratings
• Kansas City Steaks Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon: 4.1/5 stars coming from more than 30 ratings

Customers gave consistently high praise for the company’s convenience. They lauded the brand for delivering easy-to-prepare and equally delicious meat products. 

One happy customer had this to say about the Kansas City Steaks Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon: 

“I have searched around and tried at least six different places to purchase quality frozen salmon steaks. after i tried Kansas City, i stopped the search. Very pleased with their delivery, quality, and even the price.”

They weren’t the only buyers who stopped looking elsewhere for meat after discovering Kansas City Steaks.

While researching for this Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review, I found that the company’s products were so good that they turned skeptical meatheads into devoted company loyalists. 

In the effort of fairness, I also gathered scores from across the web for both Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks. Here’s how they were perceived in parts beyond their corporate domains.

Omaha Steaks earned a 4.3/5 stars average score from more than 60 customer reviews on Influenster, and a 2/5 stars average score from over 60 ratings on TrustPilot. 

Meanwhile, Kansas City Steaks earned a great 4.6/5 stars overall score from more than 14,000 customer testimonials on Facebook and a 2.5/5 stars average score from over 65 customer ratings on Yelp.

In summary, both companies pleased customers more than they let them down. However, I found that both Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks left some buyers wanting more in regards to more tender products and customer service. 

Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks: Promotions & Discounts

There are probably only two things on this planet that people like more than savings, and those are discounts and promotions (okay, technically three if you include puppies).

Thankfully, it seems like this section of my Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steak review is heating up to be quite the contest. These two brands each have their own impressive set of sales currently underway.

Currently, Omaha Steaks has a company-wide 50% discount on their products. I don’t have to spell out those savings for you, but I will spell out this additional deal. 

Each address they send their products to earns a 50% discount, meaning that if you split the order with some friends then you could both save big!

Furthermore, every purchase over $110 gets a special price on the Omaha Steaks Butcher’s Cut Filet Mignons. You could grab four of these tasty cutlets for only $75.

There are even ways to save if you’re asleep at the wheel and miss out on this event. Sign up for their email newsletter and you’ll gain access to exclusive deals as well as earn a $30 discount on orders totaling more than $159.

Finally, the Omaha Steaks Steaklover Rewards program allows members to earn money with every purchase. Members earn points that they can later put towards future Omaha Steaks orders by engaging with the company on social media, referring friends, and buying goods.

Okay, I’m nearly out of breath covering all of Omaha Steaks’ promotions. I’ve got enough juice to cover what Kansas City Steaks has in store though.

You could also join the brand’s illustrious Steak of the Month club wherein they’ll send you some of their best cuts every month. They offer 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month long subscriptions, and each other includes free shipping.

That’s about all Kansas City Steak offers in terms of deals. I’ll wrap up this section by stating that both brands keep their ears open for ways to reward dedicated customers.

However, Omaha Steaks offer a bit more for their buyers.

Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks: Shipping & Returns 

The penultimate segment of this Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks review will be a final duel between the company’s shipping policies and return frameworks. 

This is the lowdown on Omaha Steaks’ shipping set-up. They charge $20 for orders under $170. Greedy little meat munchkins can save themselves on the shipping fee by purchasing more than $170 worth of products at once. 

That’s right: Omaha Steaks provide free shipping if you’re willing to go the extra mile.

If your tastebuds can’t bear to wait for a single extra single then good news. There are speedier delivery options than standard shipping. Express shipping costs an additional $20 and should arrive within 2 to 3 business days.

Want your steaks even more quickly? Say no more, as you can select the company’s rush shipping service and have them in 1 to 2 business days for $40.

Want your steaks at a last minute’s notice and need them urgently? Omaha Steaks has you covered there too – their Saturday rush shipping scheme delivers orders placed on Friday by Saturday afternoon and costs $50.

Here are the shipping charges associated with each region Omaha Steaks delivers to that are outside of the continental US:

• Canada: $43
• Alaska and Hawaii: $40
• Puerto Rico: $40
• The US Virgin Islands: $125

So, while their shipping covers a large area, their return and refund policy is cut and dry. You won’t be able to send any product back to the company because you can’t return purchased food.

With that being said, you can contact Omaha Steaks directly and ask them to replace your order or offer you a refund. They’ll be happy to do both.

What are Kansas City Steaks happy to do though? They’ll happily ship their products to any of the 50 United States. Sadly, they don’t offer shipping to any other locations.

Another dour thing to mention about their shipping is that they don’t openly publish their shipping times. Those are only displayed at the checkout once you’ve entered your address and selected your shipping speed. 

Here’s what I do know about Kansas City Steak’s shipping. Their regular shipping option costs $20 and will arrive on a workday. If you want your package shipped on a particular day then they charge an extra $2.

They have more options than that though. Their 2-day delivery service costs an additional $10 and their Saturday 2-day delivery plan will add another $25 to your shipping fee.

Their fastest delivery option, overnight shipping, requires that you pay an extra $40.

As a way of thanking customers for shopping with them, Kansas City Steaks provides buyers the chance to redeem a refund if they find their purchase unsatisfactory. This refund comes in the form of a gift certificate or an item of equal value.

There are a point worth mentioning to sum up this section.

Both Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks have similar shipping fees and shipping options.

The difference is that the former company ships to more areas, publishes their shipping times, and provides free shipping if you’re willing to spend enough on the company website.

Who Will You Shop With?

Don’t let your favorite Bruce Springsteen track determine which of these companies you should shop with. Both “Nebraska” and “Kansas City” fans can enjoy supreme steaks, burgers, roasts, and sausages from either Omaha Steaks or Kansas City Steaks.

What’ll ultimately sway your opinion is your location – Omaha Steaks ships to more places, after all. However, if you’re anywhere within any of the 50 United States then you’re free to choose either company.

You could do a lot worse than these two companies. After all, you could be ordering frozen Beyond Beef patties from Amazon. Now THAT’S when you know you’ve hit rock bottom.

---

Check out other articles you might like:

Kansas City Steaks Review

Omaha Steaks Review

ButcherBox vs Omaha Steaks Review