Pair of Thieves Socks and Underwear Review

About Pair of Thieves

About Pair of Thieves

Pair of Thieves is a bold brand focusing on socks and underwear for men and women. Their products have a wide variety of designs that are both stylish and comfortable. The following Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review provides an in-depth look into the company and its products to ensure you make the right purchase decision.

Overview of Pair of Thieves

Overview of Pair of Thieves

Pair of Thieves socks and underwear come in a multitude of designs and colours. Many brands are either too plain or too loud in terms of design and colour. But the brand strives to provide a strong variety for their customers. This allows customers to wear Pair of Thieves underwear and socks for any occasion.

The founders, like Pair of Thieves underwear, are light and breezy. Cash Warren, Alan Stuart, and David Ehrenberg are three friends who shared a common goal—to sell quality Pair of Thieves underwear and socks to people at a fair price. These three founders work as a team to ensure they are an enthusiastic brand with a clear sense of design. Alan Stuart is so passionate about Pair of Thieves socks and underwear designs that he works with his own design studio, One Long House, to create unique designs for the brand.

I must say, I have never seen a more passionate group of founders. When I took a look at their website for this Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review, I got a sense of their friendliness in their description of themselves and their products. It makes you want to browse their products, based on their charm alone. They are a company that profits from making their relationship with their customers as strong as the relationship between the Pair of Thieves team. 

Pair of Thieves focuses on four core values: 

  • Providing breathable, yet stylish, underwear and socks
  • Putting their charming personalities into their products and their website, providing customers with friendly remarks through their online shopping experience
  • Designing Pair of Thieves underwear and socks for all occasions
  • Ensuring that their products are high-quality at a low-budget price range

This Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review takes a look at the benefits and downsides to the brand:


  • Free shipping on orders over $35
  • Underwear is seamed with non-chafing material
  • Their Give Back program allows customers to provide the less-fortunate with much needed socks


  • Can only be shipped within the US
  • Buyer must pay shipping on returned items 
  • Slightly more expensive than the average sock

Pair of Thieves Socks Review

A Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review found that the brand offers socks in no show, low-cut, crew, ankle, dad & kids, and multi-packs. We’ll go through some of the most popular sock types:

Pair of Thieves No Show Socks

Pair of Thieves has a wide variety of no-show socks. The average pair is $10, but there are a couple of less popular pairs currently on sale for $5. Pair of Thieves no show socks are easily made invisible with certain shoes, but also have a non-slip quality to them so that they don’t slip off your feet as you’re walking.

The Men’s Prism Cushion No Show Socks pictured below have an interesting earthy color scheme. They’re subtle, yet they can offer a splash of color while going shoeless.These socks are made from combed cotton, polyester, and nylon. It’s cushiony feel allows for comfort when you’re on your feet all day.

Pair of Thieves Low-Cut Socks

The brand has a wide variety of low-cut socks as well. Similar to the no-show socks, the average pair is $10 but there are some pairs currently on sale for $5. Also made from combed cotton, polyester, and nylon— Pair of Thieves low-cut socks are perfect for matching any outfit. 

The Whoa in White Women’s Cushion Low-Cut Socks are a fun design, currently on sale for $5. With a cushioned heel and toe, they would make any day a comfortable day. The contrast of the busy polka dot design along with the light blue heel and toe really works for them. These socks are classy and snazzy, all the while feeling extremely comfy with a 4-way stretch and extremely breathable fit.

Pair of Thieves Crew Socks

Pair of Thieves crew socks usually have a starting price of between $10-$14, but some are currently on sale for as low as $7.50! Pair of Thieves socks definitely have the most designs in this category of socks and the majority of them are not suitable for subtle or plain looks. But with crew socks, they are meant to display themselves on your calves. So why not make them interesting? 

Although they have a select few basic crew sock designs, I find myself more intrigued by the vibrant, unique, and fun designs. With so much variety and such a strong difference between every crew sock designs, your socks definitely won’t be mistaken for anyone’s but your own.

While writing this Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review, these Disney Aladdin-inspired Give Me Some Tassel crew socks got my attention. Aladdin fan or not, these socks are super trendy and unique, perfect for a bold addition to any outfit. I mean, how many socks have tassels on them? 

Just like most of Pair of Thieves socks, these are made from combed cotton, nylon, and polyester while providing a comfy, stretchy fit! Currently on sale for $10.50, these funky socks are a must-have for anyone looking to spice up their wardrobe.

Pair of Thieves Blackout/Whiteout Socks 

Pair of Thieves has a special line of both men and women’s socks that aims to help those in need. When purchased in a pack of either blackout or whiteout socks, they donate three pairs to charity. How awesome is that? You get more socks, and help the less-fortunate at the same time!It’s a win-win for everyone. 

Sadly, only plain black and white socks are eligible. But the cause behind it makes it worth buying. Everyone needs a pair of black or white socks for certain occasions. With multiple sock types available in the Pair of Thieves Blackout/Whiteout line, packs range from $20-$80. With a minimum of three pairs and a maximum of 9 pairs included. 

The Blackout Striped Ankle Socks have a cool athletic vibe. Also available in reverse colours, this pack of three socks are on sale for a reasonable price of $20. I think the white stripes at the top create such a vivid contrast within the socks that give the socks a hint of style and make them slightly less plain. 

Like most Pair of Thieves socks, these are made of combed cotton, polyester, and nylon and have a comfy fit with a 4-way stretch. In terms of fit, they are described as being somewhere in between no-show socks and crew socks. Not too short and not too long, and three pairs of socks will be donated if purchased. This Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review confirms that the brand has good intentions.

Pair of Thieves Underwear Review: For Men

A Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review found styles for men including boxer briefs, long boxer briefs, slim fit boxers, loose boxers, trunks, and briefs. We’ll take a look at some of the brand’s bestsellers for men.

Mega Soft Slim Fit Boxers

Pair of Thieves Mega Soft Slim Fit Boxers usually go for $20, but some pairs are currently on sale for $13. With a variety of designs and colours, they are made with modal, cotton, and spandex. The breathable fabric allows for stylish comfort and non-chafing seams. The designs for this line of Pair of Thieves boxers are quite limited, mostly in plain dark colours. If you’re into basic underwear, these would be for you.

Cool Breeze Boxer Briefs

Pair of Thieves Cool Breeze Boxer Briefs come in a wide variety of designs and colours. These usually go for $22, but some are on currently sale for $10. They are fashionable and comfy, with a mixture of mesh and quick-drying fabric to make any activity a dryer one. 

Also made with non-chafing seams, these Pair of Thieves boxer briefs are stretchy and suitable for being active. I chose to feature the above design in this Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review because it proves that athletic clothing doesn’t just need to have the moisture-absorbing material — it also should to be stylish.

Many athletes have to choose function over fashion when it comes to buying activewear. But with Pair of Thieves boxer briefs, you can have the best of both worlds for $22.

Pair of Thieves Underwear Review: For Women

The brand offers underwear for women in thong, hipster, bikini, and boy short styles. A Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review found some top sellers available for women:

Mega Soft Thong

The Mega Soft thong has a sexy and simple design, available in the blue leaf Happy Mondays pattern pictured above and Solid Aegean, featuring the same attractive ocean blue. These are the only thongs offered by Pair of Thieves, priced at $10 and currently on sale for $8. This is a very reasonable price for women’s underwear, which can get quite steep.

This thong is invisible under dresses and workout tights, so you never have to be self-conscious about underwear lines. The Mega Soft thong features no-chafe seams and four-way stretch, so it hugs without squeezing. The Mega Soft thong contains a comfortable cotton and modal blend. The fabric is naturally airy and breathable.

Cool Breeze Hipster

The Cool Breeze is one of two styles available in the Hipster category, priced at $10 and on sale for $8. They offer moderate coverage in the back, while still being a little cheeky. The Cool Breeze features four-way stretch and no chafe seams. Paired with their breathable cotton fabric, these undies are built for comfort.

A benefit of the Cool Breeze Hipster is their moisture-wicking capabilities. They’re designed to keep you dry by absorbing moisture, so these would be a good option for sweaty workouts. Colors are limited to black and charcoal, so if you’re into more creative underwear designs, these might not be for you.

Pair of Thieves Socks and Underwear Review: What Do Customers Think?

Pair of Thieves Socks and Underwear Review: What Do Customers Think?

Pair of Thieves underwear is rated positively on the website and generally have 4 star ratings. Many of the reviews rave about how soft the underwear is. Pair of Thieves reviews can also be found on Amazon. In particular, the Cool Breeze Boxer Briefs have 4/5 star rating on the site. In a Pair of Thieves Boxer Briefs review, one customer described them as “amazingly comfortable.” On the other hand, another Pair of Thieves boxers review expressed that “they ride up constantly and started to fray after only being washed a couple of times.”

Pair of Thieves socks reviews on the website are similarly positive, the majority of them having 4/5 star ratings. Some of the packs have been given 5/5 ratings as well. Customers praise the comfiness of the socks and were especially happy that the no shows stay put on their feet. Pair of Thieves socks have 4 and 5 star ratings on Amazon, with many customers expressing their love for the true to size fit and soft feel of their pairs.

Pair of Thieves Promotions & Discounts

For this Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review, we hunted for the best deals:

  • Use Pair of Thieves promo code SPEND25 to save 25% off your order when you spend more than $150
  • Use Pair of Thieves discount code HOLONIS25 to save 25% off of any Pair of Thieves order!
  • Get a $10 Pair of Thieves coupon for your next order when you refer a friend!

Pair of Thieves Sizing


  • Men: S-XXL
  • Women: XS-XL


  • Men: 8-12 (one size fits all)
  • Women: 6-8 (one size fits all)


Where to Buy Pair of Thieves 

Unfortunately, no retail locations currently exist for Pair of Thieves, but you can purchase Pair of Thieves products via their website. Pair of Thieves Target and Amazon are other options.

Pair of Thieves Shipping Policy

According to a Pair of Thieves socks and underwear review, here’s what you need to know about shipping:

  • They can only ship within the U.S. unless you order externally from either Target or Amazon, which will have individual shipping prices and policies.
  • Orders are shipped from Los Angeles via USPS.
  • They provide free shipping on orders over $35 for a limited time only!
  • First class and free shipping will take anywhere between 3-7 business days.
  • Priority mail will take anywhere between 2-3 business days.
  • Once the current free shipping over $35 promotion is over, standard shipping will be free on orders greater than $50.
  • If an order is less than $50, shipping will be calculated by the item(s) weight with an additional $3 handling fee.
  • Priority mail is also calculated by the item(s) weight plus a 15% upcharge.

Pair of Thieves Return Policy 

Pair of Thieves has a No Regrets Guarantee policy where you can get a full refund or exchange for a worn item, excluding shipping costs, within 90 days. The only catch is that it can only apply to your first item. 

For returns and exchanges on any other items you purchase from Pair of Thieves: 

  • A pair without wear and in its original packaging with proof of purchase can be used to have an item exchanged within 90 days. 
  • A pair without wear and in its original packaging with a proof of purchase can be used to have an item returned within 30 days. 
  • Your shipping costs cannot be refunded. 
  • For all refunds and exchanges, the buyer must always pay the return shipping.

Contact Pair of Thieves

For any other inquiries regarding Pair of Thieves policies, promotions, or products:

Contact them by submitting a request through their website.

They are also available to answer any questions online from Monday to Friday from 9am-6pm PST. 

It’s always better to have options. Check out these other top underwear brands:

Tommy John for men, women, and kids

MeUndies for men and women

Thinx for women and girls

Knixwear for women

Ask the community or leave a comment

Ask a Question
Asked by Brandon (2 years ago) Reply

I bought the now show socks from Pair of Thieves after reviewing a lot of websites for best bang for the buck and landed on Pair of Thieves. These socks were awesome until I dried them. After I dried them they shrunk and could not be worn anymore unless I wanted to cut my heel or destroy my toes. I have pictures. They even ripped at the middle because of the tightness.

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required