Food & Beverage

Rastelli’s Review

About Rastelli’s 

Rastelli's Review

Rastelli’s is a meat and butcher shop and delivery service based in the United States. This family-owned company offers premium beef, poultry, lamb, pork, veal, and seafood, all sourced from responsible farms and operations. 

Unlike many delis and grocery stores, Rastelli’s does not carry products made from factory-farmed animals.

This Rastelli’s review finds the company takes pride in sourcing its meats from free-range, grass-fed animals raised without hormones, steroids or antibiotics

Rastelli’s began as a brick and mortar butcher shop, but Rastelli’s meats are also now available for online orders through their website. This growing company has been featured in Rolling Stone, Food & Wine, and CNN

This Rastelli’s review will take a look at the butcher shop’s best-selling meat and seafood products, so you can decide if they belong on your dinner table!

Let’s start by checking out the highlights of buying from this popular family food brand.

Brand Highlights

Rastelli's Review
  • Offers detailed information on where they source their meat and seafood
  • Founders have years of experience as butchers
  • Many products are certified organic 
  • All of their meats come from free-range, humanely raised animals
  • No hormones, steroids, or antibiotics used in the production of their meats
  • Some plant-based products also available
  • Pursuing ASPCA “Shop With Your Heart” certification, but do not have it yet

Rastelli’s Meat Shop Review

Keep reading my Rastelli’s review as I shop through some of this brand’s best selling meat and seafood products! First, I’ll look at their unique take on the hot dog.

Rastelli’s Round Hot Dogs Review

The Round Hot Dogs come in flat, flower-shaped patties reminiscent of the hefty, ⅓ lb Roadhouse burgers found on picnic tables across America every summer.

They are meant to be enjoyed on a hamburger bun and their unique shape makes them perfect for holding all of your favorite toppings. 

Rastelli’s Round Hot Dogs contain the following ingredients:

  • Beef
  • Pork
  • Water
  • Salt
  • Paprika
  • Flavoring 

These versatile Round Hot Dogs can be cooked on a skillet or grill, boiled in water, or put in a fryer. Each patty is 3 oz. 

This incredibly popular product is currently out of stock, but shoppers can click the “Notify Me” button to get an email as soon as these beloved treats are restocked. Rastelli’s Round Hot Dogs retail for $34 for a 16-pack.

Rastelli’s Faroe Island Salmon Filets Review

Rastelli’s Faroe Island salmon are raised in the Faroe Islands in the North Atlantic Ocean. The salmon live in expansive enclosures built into their natural habitats. The fish are able to swim freely and are raised on an antibiotic-free diet

Then, they are portioned into 6 oz filets, frozen, and packed raw, so your salmon is preserved at the height of freshness. 

Once thawed, you can grill, saute, or bake the salmon. Rastelli’s recommends either marinating or seasoning these filets with simple salt, pepper, and olive oil for a flavourful meal. 

This Rastelli’s review has learned that salmon are high in protein and valuable nutrients such as potassium, omega-3 fatty acids, and a variety of B vitamins

Rastelli’s Faroe Island Salmon is available for $35 for a pack of 4 filets.

Rastelli’s Crab Cakes Review

Rastelli’s Crab Cakes are made from jumbo lump Blue crab meat. This type of crab meat is known for its rich flavor and solid texture

These Crab Cakes have a simple ingredients list with no filler or preservatives. In addition to sweet Blue crab, they contain:

  1. Fresh eggs
  2. Breadcrumbs
  3. Dijon mustard
  4. Mayonnaise
  5. Lemon juice
  6. Worcestershire sauce
  7. Seasonings

These round cakes come ready to cook, and can be baked from frozen for 20-25 minutes for an easy meal. You could also choose to thaw and saute them in a pan for 3-4 minutes per side. 

You can purchase the 4 oz Crab Cakes in a pack of 4 at Restelli’s for $40.

Rastelli’s Seafood Sampler Review 

This extensive Seafood Sampler comes with a selection of Rastelli’s most popular seafood products, all wild-caught or sourced from sustainable fisheries

Rastelli’s Seafood Sampler contains:

  • 6 Faroe Island Salmon Filets
  • 6 Icelandic Cod Filets
  • 2 Packages of Shrimp
  • 6 Faroe Island Salmon Burgers

This variety pack is meant for large families or gatherings when you want to please many palates and enjoy the best seafood Rastelli’s has to offer! 

The salmon burgers and fish filets are ready to be conveniently baked, sauteed, or grilled, and the shrimp comes deveined and pre-peeled

Rastelli’s Seafood Sampler will bring the ocean to your front door for $109.

Who Is Rastelli’s For? 

Rastelli's Review

Rastelli’s will appeal to families who want to eat high-quality meats and seafood produced in humane and ethically responsible conditions.

Because Rastelli’s offers detailed information on the operations they buy from, customers can have confidence that their products are healthy for them and the planet. 

Consumers who are concerned about animal cruelty and the pollution usually caused by factory farming will feel well-served by Rastelli’s commitment to traditional, free-range meat production

Customers trying to avoid harmful traces of steroids, hormones and antibiotics in their food can also rest assured that Rastelli’s products are free of all these contaminants. 

Rastelli’s Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Rastelli's Review

This Rastelli’s review found that customer responses are generally very positive. 

On the Rastelli’s website, customers have complimented their products’ rich flavour, good texture, and overall value.

One verified customer’s review of Rastelli’s Boneless, Skinless Chicken Breasts was enthusiastic about the product quality: “Can’t say enough about these. They stay so juicy and hold so much flavor.”

Other devoted customers have raved about their hot dogs, as one customer shared in their Rastelli’s review, “I am a hot dog Connoisseur and these are unbelievably great!” 

The food reviewer on Meal Find echoed this feedback in their review of Rastelli’s steaks, sharing that: “They are full of flavor and naturally juicy.”

Many of their buyers also appreciate that Rastelli’s sources their meat from high-quality, humane operations and butchers it skillfully.

In a Rastelli’s review for Food Box HQ, one satisfied customer wrote: “Based on our experience with Rastelli’s, they place a huge emphasis on quality. Even the pre-cooked options we’ve had have been packed with flavor (you can taste the difference).”

In taking a look at customer feedback for our Rastelli’s review, we did find that some shoppers had issues with being able to get the products they love. They note that some of Rastelli’s products sell out quickly, so they can occasionally be hard to find when you want them.

Overall, however, Rastelli’s customers find that their services surpass their expectations. As one contented customer wrote in their Rastelli’s review on the brand’s website: “We love our Rastelli orders – everything is delicious, delivered on time, and the highest quality.”

Is Rastelli’s Worth It?

Rastelli's Review

Rastelli’s has proven itself to be a transparent and trustworthy brand for meat, seafood, and even plant-based meat replacement products.

On their website, you can find extensive information about their product production and their safety standards, as well as an impressive amount of information on the products themselves.

This company’s customers have written glowing reviews of their services, and Rastelli’s has been favorably featured in by major media outlets. 

If you live in the continental US and have the opportunity to try Rastelli’s, it could be your next go-to grocery delivery for humanely and sustainably produced meat and seafood products.

This Rastelli’s review has found that this popular food service is certainly worth the buy!

Rastelli’s Promotions & Discounts 

Rastelli's Review

Rastelli’s has a membership and rewards program available on their official website.

Where to Buy Rastelli’s 

Rastelli's Review

All Rastelli’s products can be purchased through their official website.


Rastelli's Review

How long has Rastelli’s been around?   

This Rastelli’s review has learned that this company was founded in 1976 as a brick and mortar butcher shop. Originally called the “Meat Stop,” it was quickly renamed after their owner’s family and Rastelli’s was born. 

The shop quickly found popularity and expanded to other in-person locations. The store would later develop an online presence, and eventually transformed into a meat delivery service.

Where do Rastelli’s products come from?  

Rastelli’s products come from a wide range of sources, depending on the type of meat or seafood you purchase. Most of their products are produced on free-range, sustainable farms in the US, though some come from operations in Australia or the North Atlantic.

How long do Rastelli’s products last in the fridge?  

Rastelli’s explains that their products last for 12 months when stored in the freezer. Once they have been thawed, you can keep their meat products in the fridge for up to a week, while seafood products only last 3 to 5 days in the fridge.

What is Rastelli’s Shipping Policy?

Rastelli’s ships products to addresses within the continental US. You can get free shipping on your order if you spend over $200.

What is Rastelli’s Return Policy?

If you are not happy with your purchase, you can contact rastellis at [email protected] within 21 days of your product being shipped and receive a partial or full refund, depending on the situation.

How to Contact Rastelli’s

Rastelli's Review

You can contact Rastelli’s by email at [email protected] or call 856-214-4325.

For more delicious eats, check out the brands below.

Sizzlefish Seafood Review

Very Good Butchers Review

truLocal Meat Review

The Honest Bison Meat Review

Incogmeato Review

Ask the community or leave a comment


Customer Reviews

Leave a review

5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Stars

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required