Sizzlefish Seafood Review
We’re independently supported by our readers and we may earn a commission when you buy through our links.
Table of Contents
Sizzlefish is your one-stop-shop for delicious seafood. Operating solely online, this brand sells a variety of shrimp, scallops, salmon, tuna, and more. Customers can purchase either a single box or sign up for a membership plan.
With a steady following of 46K on Instagram, Sizzlefish has also stirred the appetite of the press, including Delish, Business Insider, Forbes, and Bon Appetit.
Despite the hype, is this brand truly ‘the catch of the day,’ or are they chum at best?
Climb aboard, as my Sizzlefish seafood review will take an in-depth look at their services, products, customer ratings, promotions, and more to help you decide if they’re worth checking out.
Overview of Sizzlefish
It should come as no surprise that Sizzlefish was born out of a love for seafood. Founder Rob Mayo has been in the seafood industry for 30+
years. His passion and drive to share great seafood with others, not just locally, led to the birth of Sizzlefish.com
Rob quickly realized that locally caught fish and shellfish served as the ultimate source of vitamins, minerals, and fatty acids. With a brave decision to leave his main job, Mayo founded Sizzlefish to better promote the health benefits of seafood.
Today, this American-based brand celebrates its 7th anniversary. Throughout the years, Sizzlefish has expanded its operations by partnering with the Chesapeake Bay Foundation.
They donate a portion of their revenue to support conservation efforts around the area. Customers can also visit their blog, which offers useful articles pertaining to health and seafood recipes.
“Our mission is simple: We want you to eat well and live better. We want you to enjoy both the health and performance benefits of fish, in the most consistently delicious form that you’ve ever experienced,” via a statement made by Sizzlefish fish delivery.
Before we get into this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review, let’s go over some initial highlights.
- A wide variety of fresh seafood to choose from
- Customers can either sign up for the Sizzlefish subscription or buy their products as a one-time purchase
- Products are categorized by their richness in omega-3/ special dietary concerns (keto, paleo-friendly)
- Seafood sourced through sustainable fisheries
- The Sizzlefish online seafood market donates to the Chesapeake Bay Foundation
- Many Sizzlefish recipes offered online
- Customers can peruse the Sizzlefish Seafood Gifts category for ideas
- Free shipping on every order
Is Sizzlefish wild-caught?
If you’re a seafood lover, you’ve probably come across the terms wild-caught and farm-raised. Sizzlefish is between the two, as some produce (such as Wild Ocean Blend and the CTS Endurance Pack) are labeled as ‘locally caught.’
Now, there’s a debate to be made in terms of these two sourcing varieties—more so with the farm-raised method.
While it’s often rumored that wild-caught salmon or cod tastes the best, Sizzlefish maintains that good and bad catches depend on species and distribution practices.
Farming usually gets a bad reputation, as some brands are notorious for watering down their catches or using a mix of harsh chemicals and additives during the cultivation process. Thankfully, this company does none of that.
Suppose you’d like to learn more about the brand’s distribution methods or the difference between Sizzlefish wild-caught fish vs farm-raised. I recommend heading over to their official website for more in-depth information.
Is Sizzlefish sustainable?
For those who’ve jumped on this article after watching Seaspiracy on Netflix, I can assure you that Sizzlefish ensures sustainable practices through its manufacturing process. Whether it’s wild-caught or farm-raised, this online brand prioritizes quality over everything.
If you like to shop ethically, I’d recommend heading over to FishChoice.com. They rate most of the seafood with a positive or negative ranking.
Sizzlefish also uses recyclable coolers to package their food. As mentioned earlier, they have partnered with the Chesapeake Bay Foundation and the Monterey Bay Seafood Watch program to support conservation efforts.
How Does Sizzlefish Work?
Depending on your love of seafood, you can test the waters with single purchases, or switch to a subscription plan once hooked. For the purposes of this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review, I will go over their Membership Programs.
Currently, buyers can choose from 3 different plans:
- Wild Seafood Favorites Box
- Sizzlefish Prime Subscription
- Sizzlefish Prime Plus membership
While all three differ in terms of species, size, and cost, two of these three subscriptions, the Prime Subscription and Prime Plus allow you to customize your own order, while the Wild Seafood Favorites Box is a wild card! With this box, you’re surprised each month with 10-14 pieces of the best-in-class seafood from the list on their website.
Once the purchase is finalized, the brand will ship its frozen items within a reliable, recyclable container. This ensures that the quality and freshness of the fish are preserved.
Customers have full control over modifying subscription plans. This includes skipping orders and changing the date of shipment. Charged monthly, members can view their order settings by logging into their accounts.
Moving forward, this Sizzlefish seafood review will take a brief look at all of their offerings.
Sizzlefish Wild Seafood Favorites Box Review
Dads, I’m pretty sure that this plan was invented for you. Featuring a large assortment of fish, shrimp, scallops, and other delectables, the Wild Seafood Favorites Box serves as a temporary fix for those lost fishing days.
To keep customers surprised, the brand will pre-select their catch for you to try out. This pack includes 10-14 portions, which is more than enough for one family of 4.
If you need a sneak peek, you may get a cut of fresh Atlantic Cod, succulent Alaska Sockeye Salmon, or a tasty fillet of Black Sea Bass. Is your mouth watering? Perhaps the Wild Seafood Favorites Box is for you.
Sizzlefish Subscription Review
For those that love a bit of fish now and then, the Prime Subscription is definitely the way forward. Containing 14 portions in total, customers have the power to decide which cut they prefer.
The selection includes wild Alaska Salmon, Sizzlefish Gulf Shrimp, Rainbow Trout, Atlantic Cod, and more. While waiting for an order to arrive, I recommend kicking up your feet and relaxing because all this fish needs is a bit of olive oil and sea salt to bring out its rich flavor.
This is a great membership plan to have if you have fish or shrimp once or twice a week. If the in-laws are coming over for a visit, why not treat them to a seafood feast? Cook up a storm by signing up for the Prime Subscription.
Sizzlefish Prime Plus Subscription Review
Seafood aficionados, the Prime Plus Subscription plan is most certainly for you. Customers can enjoy 14 total portions of 19 different fish and dish varieties.
Some inviting options include Korean BBQ salmon, Mahi-Mahi, Red Snapper, Haddock, and even Maryland style Crabcakes.
If you’re cooking up poke bowls, fajitas, cioppino, or tacos—you’ve automatically scored points in our book. For those looking to expand their seafood palette, this is definitely the plan to go for.
Depending on the items you choose, this plan can be paleo or keto-friendly. All you have to do is pour a nice glass of crisp white wine after opting for the Prime Plus Subscription program.
Our Favorites from the Menu
Although all of their seafood comes uncooked, you can opt for some of their pre-seasoned items such as the Thai Curry Salmon. My Sizzlefish seafood delivery review will offer a tasting menu of some of their available dishes. Pack a picnic blanket and keep reading.
Gluten-Free Maryland Crabcakes
The Gluten-Free Maryland Crabcakes come in a package of 12 and can serve as a small appetizer or the main meal.
Made with sumptuous jumbo lump and backfin meat, this tasty treat is finished off with a range of Chesapeake spices and toasty gluten-free breadcrumbs.
Eat as much as you like, as they’re only 190 calories each. As always, crabcakes are best served with a slice of lemon. Rich in calcium, this flavorsome dish is also completely friendly to those who have celiac disease.
When unpackaged, customers can pan-sear, bake in the oven, or cook these beauties in the air fryer for added crispiness and flavor. Loaded with taste and texture, the Gluten-Free Maryland Crabcakes cost $130 per box.
Korean BBQ Salmon
Sometimes a wedge of lemon and a dab of butter isn’t going to cut it. For those looking for a bit of kick, I recommend the Korean BBQ Salmon.
Cooked with bulgogi seasoning, this meaty treat is enhanced with a tasty combination of soy sauce, green onion, brown sugar, garlic, ginger, and of course, Atlantic Salmon.
High in omega-3 fatty acids, customers are in for a finger-licking yet healthy meal. Flaky and tender in texture, the fish is sourced directly from the Faroe Islands, located near Scotland and Ireland.
Amounting to 231 calories in total, grill up a slice of Korean BBQ Salmon for $95. One pack includes 14 portions.
Smoked Fish Smorgasbord
For those anticipating a fancy night in, I’d suggest getting an order of the Smoked Fish Smorgasbord plate. Featuring a variety of cuts, this tasting platter includes nothing but salmon—smoke-roasted, cold-smoked, spruce point gravlax, Kendall brook, and pastrami style.
Low in saturated fat, this appetizer is also rich in protein and Vitamin B-12. Containing 6 packs in total, this seafood charcuterie board is best served with some aged cheese, crackers, oysters, dried fruits, and shrimp cocktail.
Sourced directly from the Ducktrap River of Maine, the Smoked Fish Smorgasbord rings up to a total of $79.
Omega-3 Protein Mix
On a health binge? Stay on track with the Omega-3 Protein Mix. Only amounting to 191 calories per serving, this assorted mix is high in protein, minerals, vitamins, while low in saturated fats.
Treat your loved ones to a variety of cuts, including wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Wild-Caught Cod, Sablefish, North Atlantic Haddock, and more. For recipe ideas, I suggest fish and chips, fish pie, chowder, or good ol’ fashion grill and sear.
Portioned into 14 containers, this bundle has you set for the weeks to come. The Omega-3 Protein Mix comes to $110.
How Much is Sizzlefish?
I won’t beat around the bush for this one. Since customers must buy their fish in bulk, prices are slightly higher compared to your local grocery store.
Up ahead in this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review I will go over the pricing details for their subscription plans for you to compare.
From what I’ve gathered so far, they don’t differentiate the one-time purchasing cost from their membership programs.
- Wild Seafood Favorites Box: 14 portions in total for $110
- Prime Subscription: 14 portions in total for $112 ($8 per serving)
- Prime Plus Subscription: 14 portions in total $126 ($9 per serving)
Sizzlefish Reviews: What Do Customers Think?
This online company seems to be making waves across the seafood industry. On Shoppers Approved, a massive total of 15k reviews were written for Sizzlefish, with an average total of 4.9/5 stars.
Several buyers noted that their service was easy to use and that they had positive interactions with the brand’s representatives. Others were happy with the taste of their fish, stating that it was delicious when cooked up.
“Best salmon SMORGASBORD! The salmon pate should be sold separately! My husband finished it in 2 days. Sizzlefish products are fresh and delicious. The ease of home delivery is as good as their superb customer service,” one reviewer wrote on Shoppers Approved.
While writing this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review, I also found a range of online blogs that recommended this company. On MealFinds, the author gave word to the convenience of choosing Sizzlefish—especially for those who have large families.
The writer for Buyerseafood stated that Sizzefish did a great job in packaging their products. They were happy with the quality of the fresh meals, too. In a Sizzlefish seafood review on Buyerseafood:
“So the sablefish was great, the delivery was flawless, the price was reasonable…I highly recommend trying out Sizzlefish for yourself and I’m pretty sure I’ll be using them in the future when I have a craving for fish I can’t get here in Gloucester.”
Is Sizzlefish Subscription Worth It?
If you’re a lover of fish, shrimp, and other fruits of the ocean, as I’m sure you are if you’re reading this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review, I would highly recommend this company.
I was generally impressed with the variety they offered, as customers can choose between everything from Sizzlefish Alaskan Halibut to a tasty assortment of Gulf Shrimp.
Their subscription plans are quite reasonable too, as they can save buyers on their grocery bills in the future. The brand also provides a wide selection of delicious and nutrient-packed meals such as the Sizzlefish Smoked Mackerel Platter.
You can also peruse through their blog in your free time for a number of flavourful recipes and health-related articles.
For the sake of looking at things from all perspectives in this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review, I was not a fan of the minimum purchase requirement. Buyers may not need a huge amount of fish if they are only willing to try a small bite.
Still, based on the number of positive testimonials online, Sizzlefish earns an approving seal of satisfaction from us.
Sizzlefish Promotions & Discounts
At the time of this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review, I found out that they have a refer-a-friend program. For every successful referral, customers receive $20 off their next order. Friends can get a 10% discount as well.
Be sure to sign u p for their e-letter and receive exclusive offers, new recipe ideas, and intriguing articles.
Sign Up For Sizzlefish Subscription
There are three ways that customers can sign up for a subscription plan. I’ll outline them below in this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review:
- Choose from 3 of their offered membership plans. Customers will be redirected to the appropriate page after plugging in their email address
- On the landing page, click the ‘Sign In’ button to create an account
- Pick from their assortment of products and fill out your information at checkout
What is Sizzlefish?
This online retailer sells sustainably sourced seafood. One of their most raved about products include their dry-packed sea scallops. Harvested off the North Atlantic, these are worth trying out for yourself!
Customers can either buy their products as a one-time purchase or sign up for one of their subscription plans.
Depending on your appetite, they offer options with varying portion sizes. The next time you’re hosting a party, try out the Sizzlefish colossal shrimp bundle.
Where is Sizzlefish located?
While doing my research for this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review, I found out that their headquarters are located in Ayden, North Carolina.
How much does Sizzlefish cost?
Each of their subscription plans varies in cost. Scroll right up to the ‘How Much is Sizzlefish?’ chapter of this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review for specifics.
How do I cancel my Sizzlefish subscription?
To cancel your Sizzlefish subscription, customers must contact the company. The brand states that members must notify their team 72 hours in advance if possible. Generally, if you let their customer service team know before it bills they are able to accommodate.
What is Sizzlefish’s Shipping Policy?
I’m happy to report in this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review that they offer free shipping on all orders. Using their main courier FedEx, it approximately only takes 1–3 days for packages to arrive.
Each purchase is packaged in a reusable cooler to seal in freshness. Unfortunately, they only deliver within the US. So far, I haven’t come across any indication of a tracking number or confirmation email that customers can use.
What is Sizzlefish’s Return Policy?
As you might’ve guessed, the company does not accept returns. Those Sizzlefish sea scallops need to be gulped up on the spot! Customers can still request a replacement free of charge in case they are unsatisfied.
If your package arrives thawed due to any delays during transit, Sizzlefish will replace your box, free of charge.
To initiate this process, and for more specifics, contact Sizzlefish’s customer service.
How to Contact Sizzlefish
For inquiries unrelated to this Sizzlefish seafood delivery review, you can get in touch with the company through:
- Phone number: (833) 603-0888 (Monday to Friday from 7:00 am to 4:00 pm ET)
- Email: [email protected]
- Filling out their message form online
- Mailing address:
PO Box 10
Ayden, NC 28513
Looking for more meal subscription options to choose from? Here are a few other plans to choose from: