Reviews

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

Scentbird Vs Scentbox Review

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

We’ve all heard of a signature scent, a wedding scent, or a holiday scent… but what about a subscription scent? I’m talking about the perfect way to find the perfume or cologne you’ve been searching for or help with switching your scents up from time to time. 

In this Scentbird vs Scentbox review, I’ll cover two of the best perfume subscription boxes that will up your scent game.

Scentbird was founded in 2013 by three friends: Mariya Nurislamova, Sergei Gusev, and Andrei Rebrov. The trio began the brand as a marketplace for mini versions of all the best fragrances, offering shoppers a way to buy their faves without committing to (and wasting) full-size bottles. 

Based in NYC, the brand is on a mission to help users experiment and have fun.

Scentbox was founded in SoCal in 2016 by two brothers, Craig and Les Dualba, who loved luxury colognes, but hated how expensive it was to test out new fragrances. So, they decided to develop an affordable way to try scents without having to purchase an entire bottle. But, if you end up loving a perfume, you can always purchase the full size directly from the website. 

Not sure where to start? Down below, my Scentbird vs Scentbox review will tell you everything you need to know about both brands, taking into account how they work, what kind of subscription plans they offer, customer testimonials, promo codes, and more, to help you determine which one is worth the subscription.

What To Consider

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

This Scentbird vs Scentbox review knows you’ve got a lot on your mind when it comes to choosing a subscription service. To help make your decision easier, I’ll break down all the things you need to keep in mind—which might help clarify which brand is the right one for you. 

Target Audience

These perfume subscription plans are ideal for scent lovers. If you like to switch things up often, especially if fragrances are connected to memories for you, these brands will send you a new one monthly!

Customization

Scentbird offers scents that are chosen based on the customer’s answers to their questionnaire, while shoppers are able to choose which one they’d like to try from the monthly lineup of scents for both brands. 

Flexibility

The plans can also be easily canceled when you’d like to take a break, but only Scentbird offers the option to skip a few months without canceling.

Product Range

Gourmand, spicy, floral, sweet—these are just a few of the different scents you’ll find in either of these subscription boxes. Both companies offer designer brands so you can test out the best of the best, with a few newer options sprinkled throughout. 

Accessibility 

Shoppers can subscribe to either brand directly from their websites. Both offer super affordable monthly payments, especially for designer perfumes. 

Scentbird Vs Scentbox: How Do They Work? 

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

Obviously, there’s no way to sample a scent you buy online before you actually try it out in person. That’s what these two subscription plans are for: they provide an easy way to sample fragrances, switch your daily options up, and always have a new scent to try out. Down below, this Scentbird vs Scentbox review will tell you how the two companies operate.

Every month, shoppers will be able to choose a fragrance from Scentbird’s list of best sellers or an entire catalog of the best brands after subscribing. The first scent comes in a refillable spray bottle that the glass perfume refills simply slip in and out of, as well as a case to store refills in. Plus, every 8ml comes with 140 spritzes and should last until the next order arrives.

Scentbox follows a similar protocol. Shoppers will be able to choose a scent out of over 850 designer fragrances every month. Then, the brand ships a 30-day supply (a few sprays a day) in a sleek refillable spray bottle and cute box. 

Overall, both brands’ subscription plans are pretty customizable since shoppers are able to choose the scent they would like. Plus, the free refillable tubes with the first purchase make the refills look super cute and travel easily in your bag or pocket. 

All in all, they’re pretty similar when it comes to how they work, but there’s still a lot to consider. So keep reading this Scentbird vs Scentbox review to find out more!

Scentbird Vs Scentbox: Subscription Plans  

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

When you’re choosing your subscription plan, the best option is the one that suits your lifestyle best. Scentbird currently has one plan, while Scentbox offers two. Down below, I’ll explain how to subscribe and tell you a little bit about what the different subscriptions entail. 

Scentbird’s subscription box comes with one free fragrance a month and shoppers are able to choose out of about 500 different options for $16 a month. 

Here’s how to get started:

  1. Start with the quiz, filling out which kinds of scents you prefer
  2. Next, you’ll be able to see your scent profile (the results of your quiz)
  3. Shop for recommended perfumes 
  4. Fill out your info
  5. Start receiving scents monthly
Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

Scentbox operates similarly, although they offer two monthly plans. With both plans, customers will receive one or two scents every month (depending on how many they choose). With the standard plan, shoppers have access to 500 fragrances for $15-$25, while the premium plan gives you access to over 850 options for $20-$33

Here’s how to get started:

  1. Choose whether you’d like one or two fragrances monthly
  2. Choose the plan you want
  3. Browse the fragrances and pick your faves
  4. Enter your info 
  5. Receive new scents every month

With both options, customers can cancel at any time. Scentbird does allow for users to skip months, however, which may be ideal for people who use perfume less frequently and haven’t finished using their items yet. Keep in mind that if you find a scent you love, you can shop on either website for the full-size bottle. 

If you’re looking to test out some new fragrances, either brand offers loads to choose from, but Scentbird is a little more customizable since their questionnaire highlights some of the most suitable fragrances for each person. However, if you’d like more options, Scentbox’s premium subscription is the way to go.

Scentbird Vs Scentbox: Gift Subscriptions  

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

Perfumes and colognes are classic gifts, but you might not always know which one is the right pick. Luckily, Scentbird and Scentbox both offer gift subscriptions so the recipient will be able to test out a few new scents and pick their faves

For the Scentbird gift subscription, there are three subscription options:

  • 3 months for $44 
  • 6 months for $84
  • 12 months for $144 

The scents will ship for free to the recipient monthly and they’ll receive a free reusable perfume case with their first delivery. All you have to do is choose the plan, purchase it, and fill out their email address so the brand can send the gift their way! 

Scentbox offers a similar gift subscription with free shipping, where recipients will be able to choose one fragrance from a list of 575 monthly for three months to a year. 

Here’s a breakdown of the three subscription options: 

  • 3 months for $45
  • 6 months for $85
  • 12 months for $160

Overall, the two gifting options are pretty similar. Scentbird is more affordable for the year-long subscription. But, Scentbox does seem to offer more fragrances for the recipient to choose from, which is ideal if you’re buying for someone who’s super picky!

Scentbird Vs Scentbox: Price & Value

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

This Scentbird vs Scentbox review found that both brands charge around $15 for one new scent a month (plus the travel container in the first month). The value for the price can technically change depending on the fragrance that the shopper chooses, but the customization is what makes these subscriptions so great.

With both subscriptions, users will find 8ml bottles with the same amount of sprays (or a one-month supply). Plus, there are often discounts if customers do end up deciding to purchase a full-size bottle of perfume, so they’re able to try out plenty of options at a low cost and then choose the fragrance they want for a lesser price!

While the two brands are pretty similar when it comes to price and value, Scentbox is the better choice for customers who want more than one scent a month because the second fragrance costs only around $10 extra, saving you $5. So if you’re only looking for one scent a month, try out Scentbird. 

Scentbird Vs Scentbox: What Do Customers Think?  

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

To help this Scentbird vs Scentbox review determine which brand is worth the buy, I decided to take a look at testimonials on Influenster, Sitejabber, and Reddit.

Overall, I found more reviews for Scentbird, which makes sense since it has been around for a few more years. But, how do they stack up against each other? Let’s find out.

On Influenster, Scentbird has a 4.4/5 stars rating based on 2724 reviews. On the other hand, Scentbox received the same 4.4/5 stars rating based on a smaller pool of 91 reviews. 

Both brands also received similar ratings on Sitejabber: Scentbird has a 3.9/5 stars rating based on 634 reviews and Scentbox has a 4.8/5 stars rating based on four ratings.

Now let’s check out what customers actually have to say about the brands. Here is some feedback I found online.  

Scentbird:

  • Plenty of designer fragrances to choose from
  • Scent quiz provides accurate results and is easy to retake (if you want new scents)
  • Super convenient and affordable
  • Great for gifting
  • Unisex fragrances
  • The product lasts until the next subscription shipment or longer

One shopper summarizes the experiences of many in their review: “A small sample is great for a couple of days, but trying perfume for a couple of weeks helps me decide on whether or not to buy a full-sized bottle. Scentbird has a great selection at great subscription prices!”

Scentbox:

  • Wide range of scents from top brands 
  • Helps shoppers discover new scents
  • Easy-to-use website
  • Fragrances for men and women
  • Lots of product in every bottle
  • 500-850+ designer fragrances to choose from
  • Ideal for sharing with friends if you opt for two fragrances a month

A customer describes all their fave things about the brand, especially its affordability: “I love scent box!!! I love to smell good but buying perfume can be expensive, especially when you’re only going based off of a sample. I love the fact that I can PICK the fragrances sent to me and premium ones at that! I can mix and match without breaking the bank.”

For both boxes, there appears to be some frustration with the cancellation policies. While the process is easy in theory, sometimes it’s unclear when shoppers need to cancel in order to stop the next month’s shipment. Also, some customers aren’t always in love with the scents they receive, but contacting the brand is the best way to solve that issue!

Both brands receive pretty great ratings, with shoppers commending the products and overall company design. The products seem to be worth the price, especially since they are often expensive designer fragrances. And, more often than not, customers really love the scents recommended to them and opt to gift them because they loved their own experience so much.

A shopper on Reddit actually compared the two brands and sums things nicely, stating that they are “both great for different things.” This Scentbird vs Scentbox review agrees since they both seem to have similar offerings with different perks that are dependent on what the shopper is looking for, but I’ll share some final thoughts down below!

Scentbird Vs Scentbox: Promotions & Discounts

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

Promos and discounts can play a big role in helping you choose a brand. To help you decide which brand to pick, this Scentbird vs Scentbox review sourced some deals that might help you make that decision. I found that Scentbird offers customers 50% off their first month, while Scentbox offers 40% off the first month.

There don’t seem to be any promotional offers for either of the brands very often, but be sure to keep your eyes peeled around the holidays in case they do offer any! Scentbox does currently offer the better deal upon signing up, but you could always try out both subscriptions for two super deals!

Scentbird Vs Scentbox: Shipping & Returns 

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

Before I conclude, this Scentbird vs Scentbox review will fill you in on the details surrounding shipping and returns. Both brands offer free shipping, but there’s a little more to it that might affect your decision!

With Scentbird, orders are shipped within 10-12 days after the order has been placed (or the fragrance has been chosen monthly). Once it has been shipped, shoppers can track their order with the info in the confirmation email. Items cannot be exchanged, but returns can be made within 30 days if the fragrance has been damaged. 

Scentbox ships on the 7th, 14th, 21st, and 28th of each month, so your box will ship depending on when you have subscribed. Once shipped, the order should arrive within 7-10 business days and can be tracked when shoppers log into their accounts online. 

Plus, customers are permitted one free exchange per month, with a total of five exchanges in a 12-month period (as long as there is still about 90% of the product left). Full-size bottles can be returned within 30 days, although the customer is responsible for return shipping.

Ultimately, the two brands offer fast and tracked shipping, which is a definite pro. But, if you’re not 100% sure about every fragrance choice, Scentbox might be the better choice since exchanges can be made. 

While Scentbird doesn’t offer an exchange policy, there may be fewer instances where the shopper doesn’t love the scent because the results of the quiz are pretty accurate!

Who Will You Shop With?

Scentbird vs Scentbox Review

All things considered, both brands offer a wide variety of affordable, trial-size fragrances that give shoppers an opportunity to try scents out before they buy them (or simply keep trying). 

This Scentbird vs Scentbox review also appreciates the gifting options, since fragrances have been a long-loved present. Plus, the fact that the recipient can choose their fave scents adds a fun and personal touch to the gift.

Both subscriptions are affordable—although Scentbox offers a few more options—which is ideal for customers who are looking to share their subscription with a friend or try out more fragrances monthly. 

However, Scentbird offers a little more room for customization, with a quiz that selects some ideal fragrances for the user so they don’t have to sift through all 500 options at once.
All things considered, both brands offer subscriptions that make trying out new perfumes fun, easy, and affordable.

So whether you’re on the hunt for a new go-to fragrance or a scent to make memories in, you’ll find your pick with either of these brands. At the end of this Scentbird vs Scentbox review I just have one question: which one will you test out first?


Next, check out some of our other comparison articles:

Flora vs Athletic Greens Review

Curology vs Proactiv Review

Yumi vs Little Spoon Review

Liquid IV vs Drip Drop Review

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required