Sugarpill Review

About Sugarpill

Sugarpill Review

When you want to make a statement with your makeup, on stage or off, you need something bold to match that fierce personality. And that pigment better be on point!

Thankfully, there are cosmetic companies that can cater to this need. Sugarpill is one such company, specializing in bright, bold, quality color palettes that maintain a cruelty-free construction. 

Celebrity personalities like drag queen Kim Chi are endorsing Sugarpill in a massive way, giving kudos to their diversity and their boldness. Plus, with 1.9M followers on Instagram and being featured in Teen Vogue and Allure, I’d say that the proof is in the numbers.

But, with all the hype, can this makeup brand live up to everyone’s expectations? In this Sugarpill review, I can answer that by taking you through what this brand does well, the products they carry, and most importantly, whether or not they’re worth your money. Get your setting spray ready! 

Overview of Sugarpill

Sugarpill Review

Founded in 2010 by Amy Doan, Sugarpill has the same mission it stands by since its inception, “[making] unapologetically cute makeup and believe in the freedom of limitless self-expression through makeup.” How awesome is that? 

To kick off this Sugarpill review with as much attitude as the company itself, I figured it best to dive straight into some company highlights:


Sugarpill Review
  • Wide variety of richly pigmented makeup
  • Share your phone number and receive 15% off
  • Bundle deals available
  • Some products made in the US
  • Afterpay available on orders over $35
  • Free shipping on orders over $50
  • Most products are vegan
  • All products are cruelty-free
  • International shipping is available
  • Lots of third-party retailers

Though the brand has multiple categories of makeup, my Sugarpill review will only cover select products, you know, the best-selling ones, of course! Are you ready to step into the boldness that you were born for? It’s time to stand out in the crowd. 

Sugarpill Cosmetics Review

Nowadays, you should feel free to express your personality, just as you are. But there are many cosmetic companies out there who just want you to conceal the ‘flaw’ you have, not enhance unique features. 

But that might change once you see the best sellers for this brand! We’re about to set off into a world of rich pigments and wild colors — grab your makeup tools and let’s get started! 

Sugarpill Pro Pan Pressed Eyeshadow Refills Review

Sugarpill Pro Pan Pressed Eyeshadow Refills Review
Sugarpill Pro Pan Pressed Eyeshadow Refills

When you’ve hit pan in a palette, you know refills are a must! A great asset to your Pro Palette, the Sugarpill Pro Pan Pressed Eyeshadow Refills fit perfectly inside a previously existing collection. Mix and match colors to your heart’s content since they’re individually available. 

WIth 24 colors to choose from, and a bunch of them vegan, these eyeshadow refills retail for $10.

Sugarpill Zero Liquid Lip Color Review

Sugarpill Zero Liquid Lip Color Review
Sugarpill Zero Liquid Lip Color

Black lips are bold, witchy, and ever so mysterious. But many of the black liquid lip colors out there tend to have a blue or brown undertones, leaving the bold black a little on the dull side. With Sugarpill Zero Liquid Lip Color, you’ll never have to worry about that.  

This lip color may be matte but it’s never dry on your lips and its long-lasting rich color is a true black. This creamsicle-scented lip color retails for $18

Sugarpill Fun Size Palette Review

Sugarpill Fun Size Palette Review
Sugarpill Fun Size Palette

If you’re ready to uplevel your makeup, you’ll want to take a look at this Sugarpill Fun Size Palette. With fun names like 8-bit, cheat code, and game over, you’ll love the bold and sassy colors. 

Coming 9 blendable colors, this mini collection retails for $30.

Sugarpill Fun Size Too Sticker Sheet Review 

Sugarpill Fun Size Too Sticker Sheet Review 
Sugarpill Fun Size Too Sticker Sheet

What better way to dress up your space or items than with cute 8-bit type stickers? The Sugarpill Fun Size Too Sticker features Amy’s cat, Turkey, as an adorable 8-bit kitty sticker and other cute items, adding a bit of sweetness and sass to your life.

This weatherproof matte vinyl sticker retails for just $4.

Who Is Sugarpill For? 

Sugarpill Review

This company’s product line was designed for makeup enthusiasts who want to step outside of the realms of the ordinary in order to play with color and style while still using high-quality makeup.

The Sugarpill reviews and general reputation of the company confirm that their cruelty-free approach has gained them a wide and committed following.

If you love color, cosmetics, and being one-of-a-kind, then this makeup brand is for you!

Sugarpill Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Sugarpill Review

Sure, I’ve talked about all of Sugarpill’s great products, but let’s get serious. It’s a cute brand but what do their customers really say about them? I went digging through a catalog of ratings, stars, and comments to give you a well-rounded look at the brand. But before we get into that, here are some ratings on their top products from their website:

  • Sugarpill Pro Pan Pressed Eyeshadow Refills: 5/5 stars, 781 customer reviews
  • Sugarpill Zero Liquid Lip Color: 4.4/5 stars, 111 customer reviews
  • Sugarpill Fun Size Palette: 5/5 stars, 386 customer reviews

Aside from their website feedback, Sugarpill reviews are still pretty impressive on other sites, like Influenster, where a mass of their makeup products have been put under the microscope for customer feedback. This brand has managed to rake in a 4.7/5 star average from 137 reviews, including this happy reviewer:

“This is my all time favorite loose eyeshadow. The pigment and quality is out of this world. I use them over a primer and with fix+ to dampen them and there results are amazing. If you’re in to high end makeup at an extremely reasonable price you can’t go wrong with Sugarpill loose eyeshadows. Even though they’re loose, fallout is minimal and they blend like a dream.

Meanwhile, on Temptalia, there are plenty of great Sugarpill reviews too, with an average of 4.4/5 stars out of 54 reviews, including this from a satisfied customer:

“This is my Holy Grail black eyeshadow. I use it wet as an eyeliner and dry to set & darken my gel/liquid eyeliners. It also does a nice smokey eye. This is a very dark black with amazing staying power as well. The pan size on this is really big at 36mm. I used this with a pretty heavy hand daily as eyeliner and it lasted me 1.5 years.”

Finally, we’ve got results from Amazon, where there are plenty of Sugarpill reviews and products. This Capsule Collection Palette from the brand received 5/5 stars from 5 reviews, including this ecstatic makeup user:

“Sugarpill is a legendary brand amongst drag performers and alternative makeup artists and it truly lives up to its claims. Boldy pigmented beautiful pastel shades in a perfectly crafted unique pill capsule-style plastic palette!”

After scouring the web for Sugarpill reviews, I was surprised how many folks are absolutely loving the bold and unique offerings from this brand, and their prices too. It’s easy to see why this makeup company is collecting fans from all over.

Is Sugarpill Legit?

Sugarpill Review

Since their launch in 2010, Sugarpill has gained a fast and excitable following. Why? Because their entry-level prices are far lower than their competitors yet their quality remains the same. 

Between their cruelty-free promise, rave Sugarpill reviews, and diverse selection of products, this popular cosmetic brand has no red flags that I can see!

Is Sugarpill Worth It?

Sugarpill Review

Yes. The founder and owner has made it her mission to uphold the company’s commitment to low prices, high-quality, and cruelty-free products. With widely-accessible makeup supplies, diverse and unique color palettes, and a strong reputation for fashion-forward beauty ideas, Sugarpill is indeed worth it.

Sugarpill Promotions & Discounts 

Sugarpill Review

By sharing your phone number, you’ll receive 15% off your first order. You can also get 10% off when you sign up for their newsletter. They’ve also got bundle deals such as when you buy 6 of their Pro Pans, you’ll get a palette for free.

Sugarpill discount codes are also frequently available. With multiple promotion pages on their website offering deals, bundles, and sales, you’re all set!

Where to Buy Sugarpill

Sugarpill Review

It’s safe to say the best place to purchase Sugarpill supplies is directly from their website, since they offer so many fantastic products and have great deals happening all the time.

But it’s nice to have flexibility in retailers, which is why we’ve listed a few other places that carry the brand’s cosmetics.

  • Amazon
  • Glambot
  • Beautylish
  • Poshmark
  • Ninth Avenue


Sugarpill Review

Who owns Sugarpill?

Amy Doan is the owner and founder of Sugarpill, which was founded in 2010.

Is Sugarpill Cruelty Free?

Sugarpill makes an effort to source and manufacture their products in a vegan and cruelty-free manner. While their cosmetics are 100% cruelty-free, there are still a few outlying products that are not entirely vegan. Thankfully, the brand notes which colors or products aren’t vegan so you can purchase without worry. 

Does Sugarpill ship internationally?

Yes! Sugarpill does ship internationally, and depending on where you are, delivery will take anywhere from 2-6 weeks. On top of that, you’re responsible for any extra duties and taxes. 

What is Sugarpill’s Shipping Policy?

Sugarpill offers free US shipping on orders over $50, and a flat rate of $6 for anything less than that. Delivery typically takes 3-10 business days. For the rest of the world, shipping rates are:


  • Orders under $20: Shipping is $10 (Canada – $8
  • Orders under $40: Shipping is $12 (Canada – $10)
  • Orders $60+: Shipping is $16 (Canada – $14)
  • Orders under $60: Shipping is $14 (Canada – $12)

What is Sugarpill’s Return Policy?

If you bought Sugarpill makeup from the brand’s site, great news! You have 14 days from the date of delivery to initiate a refund with the company. So long as everything is in an unopened and unused condition, they’ll give you a full refund, otherwise, you’ll be given store credit. 

Got a damaged product in the mail? You have 7 days to contact Sugarpill and send them a photo of the damage + your order number.  

To start the return process, contact Sugarpill through email: [email protected]. Make sure to include your order number. Unfortunately, they don’t cover return shipping costs. 

How to Contact Sugarpill

Sugarpill Review

I hope you enjoyed this Sugarpill review! The best ways to contact the brand are listed below:

  1. Email: [email protected] (general inquiries)
  2. Email: [email protected] (return or sales questions)

Check out similar brands you might like:

Beauty Bakerie Review

Iconic London Review

Ogee Makeup Review

Three Ships Beauty Review

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required