My Fancy Feast Customizable Variety Packs Review: Is It the Purrfect Way to Nourish Your Feline?

Paid partnership with My Fancy Feast – Honest Brand Reviews receives a commission when you purchase through the links on this page.

About My Fancy Feast Customizable Variety Packs

Cat owners know the struggle: finding the perfect food to satisfy their feline friend’s finicky palate can feel like an endless quest. Multiple trips to the store, wasted cans of untouched food, or discovering that your cat only likes half the flavors in a variety pack—these frustrations are all too familiar to cat owners.

Fancy Feast, a well-known name in gourmet cat food, aims to alleviate this problem with My Fancy Feast, a customizable cat food subscription service. But can it truly deliver a tailored and satisfying mealtime experience for your furry companion?

In this review, we’ll take a comprehensive look at My Fancy Feast, examining its features, benefits, pricing, and overall offerings. We’ll explore all pack size options, from the smallest 30-count Variety Pack to the largest 75-count Variety Pack, to see how they compare and which might be the best fit for your cat’s needs and your budget.

Highlights

• My Fancy Feast allows cat owners to curate a personalized selection of their cat’s favorite Fancy Feast flavors.
• The subscription service offers various pack sizes to cater to different needs and budgets, ranging from 30 to 75 cans.
• Cat owners can choose from a wide range of Fancy Feast varieties, including classic recipes, as Medleys, Savory Centers, and their new line of Gems. They frequently introduce new flavors.
• My Fancy Feast offers the convenience of home delivery, with the option to schedule shipments as often as weekly or as infrequently as every 12 weeks. Shipping is always free, and potential savings are available through subscription perks.
• The service aims to reduce food waste by allowing owners to select only the flavors their cats prefer.

Why You Should Trust Us?

Our mission is to help you make better, more informed purchase decisions. 

Through paid partnerships, our team spends hours researching, consulting with medical experts, gathering insight from expert professionals, reviewing customer feedback, and analyzing products to provide you with the information you need.

This review is part of a paid partnership with My Fancy Feast. Honest Brand Reviews was gifted the product for this review and receives a commission when you purchase through the links on this page. 

My Fancy Feast Classic Variety Packs Review

For cat owners seeking both convenience and variety, Fancy Feast Classic Variety Packs offer a curated selection of the brand’s most beloved flavors in a single box.  These packs aim to streamline mealtime by providing a diverse range of tastes and textures without the need for individual can purchases. Let’s take a closer look at what these Classic Variety Packs bring to the table (or rather, bowl!).

How Does It Work?

Fancy Feast understands that every cat has unique preferences, which is why their Build a Customized Variety Pack option is a game-changer. Instead of settling for pre-determined flavor combinations, you can now handpick your cat’s absolute favorite Fancy Feast meals to create a truly personalized dining experience.

Choose Your Pack Size

The first step is to select the perfect pack size for your needs. Whether you have a single feline connoisseur or a whole clowder of cats, there’s a size that’s just right:

• 30-count Variety Pack. Perfect for single-cat households or for trying out a few new flavors.
• 45-count Variety Pack. A great option for multiple cats or for those who want a longer-lasting supply.
• 60-count Variety Pack. Ideal for larger households with several feline family members.
• 75-count Variety Pack. The ultimate choice for multi-cat homes or for stocking up on your cat’s favorite flavors.

Curate Your Cat’s Culinary Collection

Once you’ve chosen your pack size, the fun begins! You’ll have access to an extensive selection of Fancy Feast Classic recipes, including:

• Pate. Smooth, creamy, and irresistible to many cats. Choose from flavors like Tender Beef Feast, Chicken Feast, Turkey & Giblets Feast, and more.
• Flaked. Tender flakes with meat or fish in a delicate sauce, perfect for cats who prefer a lighter texture. Try Flaked Fish & Shrimp Feast or Flaked Chicken & Tuna Feast.
• Gravy Lovers. Indulge your cat’s love for rich gravy with options like Beef Feast in Gravy or Turkey Feast in Gravy.

The beauty of this customized pack is that you have complete control. You can choose a variety of flavors to keep mealtime exciting or stick to your cat’s tried-and-true favorites. It’s entirely up to you!

Benefits

My Fancy Feast’s “Build Your Own Variety Pack” option offers a range of benefits tailored to both you and your feline friend’s needs. These include:

1. Personalized Nutrition. You have the power to tailor your cat’s diet to their specific preferences, ensuring they receive the flavors they love most and avoiding those they don’t. This level of customization ensures your cat gets a meal they’ll truly enjoy every time.
2. Convenience. The subscription service delivers food directly to your door, eliminating the need for frequent trips to the store. This saves you time and effort, especially if you have a busy schedule or limited mobility.
3. Variety. With a wide range of flavors and textures to choose from, cats can enjoy a diverse and exciting mealtime experience. This variety helps prevent boredom and keeps your cat interested in their food.
4. Cost Savings. Subscribers can enjoy a 10% discount on every order, along with the added benefit of free shipping on all deliveries. These savings can add up significantly over time, especially for households with multiple cats.
5. Reduced Waste. By selecting only the flavors your cat enjoys, you can minimize food waste and ensure they eat every bite. This not only saves you money but also helps reduce environmental impact.
6. High-Quality Ingredients. Fancy Feast uses real meat and seafood as primary ingredients, providing cats with essential nutrients. This commitment to quality ensures your cat is getting a nutritious and delicious meal.

Price

The price will vary depending on the pack size and the specific flavors you choose, as some varieties may have a slightly higher cost per can.

The base prices for each pack size are as follows:

• 30-count Variety Pack: From $29.69 USD
• 45-count Variety Pack: From $44.54 USD
• 60-count Variety Pack: From $59.39 USD
• 75-count Variety Pack: From $74.24 USD

Keep in mind that these are starting prices, and the total cost will increase if you choose premium flavors like the Savory Centers or Medleys options. However, if you subscribe to the service, you’ll receive a 10% discount on every order, which can help offset the cost.

To get an accurate price for your custom pack, you can use the online builder tool on the Fancy Feast website. Simply select your desired pack size, choose your flavors, and the total cost will be calculated automatically. This allows you to see how your choices impact the price and adjust your selection accordingly.

My Fancy Feast Classic Variety Packs Review: What Do Customers Think?

Based on the reviews, people are generally happy with the Fancy Feast variety packs, finding them to be a good value for the price and a hit with their cats, even the picky ones. Several reviewers mentioned the convenience of having a variety of flavors in one pack, and the small can size was praised for being the perfect portion for smaller cats or for splitting between multiple feedings.

Here are some specific points mentioned in the reviews:

• Value. Many reviewers found the variety packs to be a good value for the price, especially considering the quality of ingredients.
• Variety of Flavors. Reviewers appreciated the assortment of flavors, which helped keep their cats interested in their food.
• Small Can Size. The 3-ounce can size was highlighted as being perfect for portion control and reducing waste.
• Cat Approval. Even picky eaters seemed to enjoy the Fancy Feast variety packs, with several reviewers mentioning that their cats loved the food.
• Convenience. The convenience of home delivery was also mentioned as a positive aspect of purchasing the variety packs.

Overall, the reviews suggest that My Fancy Feast variety packs are a popular and well-regarded choice among cat owners. They offer a convenient way to provide cats with a variety of flavors and textures, and the small can size helps ensure that the food stays fresh and appealing.

Here are the feedback from their customers:

“This is one of the foods I rotate for my two cats. I would choose this one all the time but I have to get another one that’s a little cheaper as well. However this particular one with the poultry and beef flavors is on the recommended list as a lower cost option in my feline nutrition group. It is very important to feed wet food as often as possible to lower the risk of urinary issues. I love the Fancy Feast small cans because I can split one can between my two boys multiple times a day so it doesn’t have to sit out.”

“Why get these heavy items at the store when someone will deliver it to your door? I swear I didn’t mean to rhyme like that but seriously, it beats the price at the store and is less for you to add to your cart. And it comes so fast!”

“We rescued a feral cat. No disease, but very bad teeth, had to all be pulled. This cat food is the perfect size, and pops open with no problem. He loves it and can handle the texture easily . His health is slowly improving.”

“I have 2 Maine Coon cats who are still growing. I give them each a can morning & night (supplemented with dry food in between). Growing Maine Coons eat a LOT! They love this wet food more than any other I tried. The others I tried gave them upset stomachs & a nassssty litter box. Ew! The protein levels in the food itself is in the acceptable range, along with the smell & taste my Maine Coons are happy & healthy eating this wet food”

Is My Fancy Feast Legit?

Yes, My Fancy Feast is a legitimate service offered by the well-established pet food brand Fancy Feast, owned by Nestle Purina PetCare. It is a subscription-based platform that allows you to customize variety packs of Fancy Feast wet cat food, choosing your cat’s favorite flavors and having them delivered to your door.

Is My Fancy Feast Worth It?

My Fancy Feast Classic Variety Packs are a convenient and reliable way to keep your feline friend happy and well-fed. They offer a curated selection of Fancy Feast’s most popular flavors, ensuring your cat enjoys a diverse and delicious dining experience. With a variety of textures like pate, flaked, and gravy lovers, there’s something to please even the pickiest eaters.

The pre-portioned cans make mealtime a breeze, eliminating the guesswork of portion control and reducing food waste. Plus, the convenient delivery options mean you’ll never run out of your cat’s favorite food.

While the Classic Variety Packs may not offer the same level of customization as the “Build Your Own” option, they are a great way to introduce your cat to a range of flavors and discover new favorites.

For cat owners seeking a hassle-free way to provide their feline companions with a delicious and nutritious diet, Fancy Feast Classic Variety Packs are a reliable and satisfying choice.

My Fancy Feast Discount & Promotions

Fancy Feast offers a variety of ways to save on your cat’s favorite gourmet meals:

1. Subscription Savings. When you sign up for a My Fancy Feast subscription, you automatically save 10% on every order, plus you’ll enjoy free shipping. This is a great way to ensure your cat always has their favorite flavors on hand while saving money in the long run.
2. Give $10, Get $10 Referral Program. Fancy Feast also has a generous referral program where you can give your friends $10 off their first My Fancy Feast purchase and receive $10 off your next order when they make a purchase.
3. myPurina App Rewards. Download the myPurina app to access exclusive savings and rewards on Fancy Feast and other Purina products. Earn points for every purchase and redeem them for discounts, free products, and other perks.
4. Other Promotions. Fancy Feast occasionally runs special promotions and discounts on their website and through their social media channels. Be sure to follow them on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram to stay up-to-date on the latest offers.

Where Can I Buy My Fancy Feast?

The exclusive way to purchase My Fancy Feast customized variety packs is directly through their website HERE.

However, if you’re looking for individual Fancy Feast products, you can find them at various retailers, both online and in-store:

Online:

• Amazon  
• Chewy  
• Walmart  
• Target  
• Petsmart  
• Petco  
• Instacart  
• Shipt  

In-Store:

• Most major grocery stores
• Pet supply stores like Petsmart and Petco  

Please note that while individual Fancy Feast products are widely available, the customized variety packs are exclusively offered through the My Fancy Feast website.

FAQ

Is there a minimum quantity for each flavor in the Classic Variety Packs?

Yes, each flavor in a Classic Variety Pack must have a minimum of 3 cans. This also applies to premium flavors like Savory Centers, but they cost extra per can. Gems Variety Packs have no minimum quantity per flavor.  

How many different varieties can I choose in a single pack?

You can choose up to:

• 10 varieties in a 30-count pack
• 15 varieties in a 45-count pack
• 20 varieties in a 60-count pack
• 25 varieties in a 75-count pack

This is more variety than you can typically find in stores, and you have complete control over the flavors you select.

Can I order more than one Variety Pack at a time?

Absolutely! You can add multiple Variety Packs to a single order, whether it’s a one-time purchase or a subscription. Subscription orders with the same delivery frequency are grouped together.

Are there any changes to Fancy Feast recipes and ingredients?

Fancy Feast is committed to providing high-quality meals for your cat. Many of their recipes are being reformulated to remove artificial preservatives and colors while still maintaining the delicious flavors and textures your cat loves.

How do I contact Fancy Feast?

You can contact My Fancy Feast in two ways:

• Email: Send your questions, comments, or concerns to [email protected].
• Phone: Call them at 866-979-2470.  

They are available to assist you with any inquiries you may have about their products or services

---

Next, check out other reviews that you might also like:

About PetSafe® NanoBark™ Collar

Funny Fuzzy Review

Alpha Paw Ramp Review

Embark Dog DNA Test Review