Categories
Reviews

Gentleman’s Box Subscription Review

About Gentleman’s Box

Gentleman’s Box is a monthly style subscription for the modern man, including everything from clothing and accessories to grooming products. Our Gentleman’s Box subscription review will go through how the style service works, what customers think of it and more, to help you decide whether or not Gentleman’s Box is worth your wardrobe.

Gentleman's Box Subscription Review 1

Overview of Gentleman’s Box

Gentleman’s Box was founded in 2014 in Detroit, Michigan by John Haji and Christopher George. The subscription service was born out of their passion for living a supreme and stylish lifestyle. In the words of John Haji, “Gentleman’s Box was created to bring awareness to today’s gentlemen on what it takes to be distinguished in this day and age.”

The monthly men’s clothes subscription offers 4-6 fashion accessories or lifestyle items per month. Each Gentleman’s Box revolves around a new theme, usually honouring a noteworthy or historical man. The contents inside each box are crafted and chosen to capture the essence of the featured gentleman’s legacy.

Choosing a men’s subscription box can be difficult—there are others on the market to choose from, and this is a purchase that you’ll be making every month. In this Gentleman’s Box subscription review, we’ll take a look at the benefits and downsides to the service, including what customers have to say about their boxes.

Gentleman's Box Subscription Review 2

Pros

According to Gentleman’s Box reviews submitted by customers, people who subscribed to Gentleman’s Box generally had a good experience with the subscription. 

  • Gentleman’s Box offers products from a wider and more international range of companies than their competitors
  • Customers appreciated the literature included in each box explaining ways to wear each accessory
  • Subscribers enjoyed the option to have either the regular or premium plan, depending on their price range and interests
  • Each Gentleman’s Box comes with a copy of GQ magazine, and subscribers liked the extra added value

Cons

On the flip side, there are some negative reviews from subscribers that could influence your decision: 

  • Some customers say that Gentleman’s Box offers less items than its competitors — usually more like four items, rather than five or six
  • It was extremely hard to cancel existing subscriptions, and confusing to get in touch with customer service
  • Some customers criticized the quality of the products offered in their Gentleman’s Box review
  • Each box is basically the same for each subscriber, which was disappointing for customers who wanted customization or flexibility
  • Information on the materials used in each product isn’t always included, which is problematic for people with allergies or skin sensitivities
  • The regular Gentleman’s boxes are only offered on a monthly basis and the Premium boxes are only offered on a quarterly review (lack of flexibility)
  • Unless you are a resident of California, you have to call to cancel your Gentleman’s Box subscription, which was considered inconvenient

What’s In the Gentleman’s Box?

In this Gentleman’s Box subscription review, we’ll give you a sense of past boxes to help you decide if it reflects your style.   

February 2020: Irish Boss

Gentleman's Box Subscription Review 3
Gentleman’s Box
Irish Boss February 2020

Last month, subscribers opened their Gentleman’s boxes to find items centered around an Irish Boss theme. The box was inspired by Irish actor Cillian Murphy, known for his roles in The Dark Knight Trilogy and Inception. Subscribers found a Gentleman’s Collective tie, a pair of socks from Gentlemen of the North, a Lord of Ties lapel flower and pocket square, and a tie clip from Windsor Tie Co. 

If you’re noting an early 1920s vibe, you’re not wrong: the pieces included in the box were inspired by Murphy’s role in Peaky Blinders, revolving around the exploits of a crime family in post-WWII England. Subscribers may feel like they’re living in another era right about now.

October 2019: Honour Our Favourite Rising Star

Gentleman's Box Subscription Review 4
Gentleman’s Box
Honour Our Favourite Rising Star February 2020

Last fall featured the Gentleman’s Box theme Honour Our Favourite Shining Star, dedicated to Oscar award-winning actor and filmmaker Jack Nicholson. Subscribers received a pain relieving gel from Capsiva, sunglasses from Shades Club, an A.K. Timepieces watch, Hitsu socks, and a Mr. Lapel tie.

The suave brown colour theme is really cool and this neutral shade goes with anything. Note the pamphlet featuring Jack Nicholson’s iconic crazy expression from The Shining, and everyone knows the star loves to wear sunglasses.

July 2019: Protector of the Sea

Gentleman's Box Subscription Review 5
Gentleman’s Box
Protector of the Sea
July 2019

Last summer, subscribers opened their Gentleman’s Box to find items honouring their favorite Protector of the Sea, Jason Momoa, an actor of Hawaiian descent who starred in Aquaman. Customers received Sock Life UK anchor socks, a polka dot AusCufflinks Tie, a Soft Landing Brand Notebook and Pen, and a Gentleman Collective Tie Bar.

Ok, so it would be pretty difficult to include pieces that resembled Aquaman’s outfit (also, that would probably look pretty strange in public). Instead, subscribers were given the chance to rock a sophisticated sailor aesthetic, which I bet looked killer with boat shoes.

Mystery Boxes

Gentleman’s Box also offers Mystery Boxes, which include 4 to 6 items from previous standard boxes. Mystery Boxes cost $140 for the Premium Mystery box, or $100 for the Regular Mystery box.

Gentleman’s Box Subscription Options

Gentleman’s Box offers two subscription options: the Classic Gentleman’s box and the Premium Gentleman’s box. Here’s an easy way to differentiate between the two:


Gentleman’s Box ClassicGentleman’s Box Premium 
Price $29$100
FrequencyEvery monthEvery three months
Guaranteed Retail ValueAt least $100 per boxAt least $300 per box
Example ItemsPocket squares, grooming samples, socks, ties, cufflinks, and tie clipsElectronics, leather goods, premium homeware, and luxury watches

Deciding whether the regular or premium box is right for you depends on the products you are looking for, how often you want your box delivered, and your price range. 

Is Gentleman’s Box Worth It? 

Gentleman's Box Subscription Review 6

There are many different monthly subscription boxes for men on the market, and it can be difficult to figure out which ones are best for your wallet, and your closet.

Gentleman’s Box can be compared to other monthly subscription boxes for men:

Gentleman's Box Subscription Review 7

Clearly, Gentleman’s Box holds up against other men’s subscription boxes. Gentleman’s Box doesn’t offer much in the way of customization options, but it does offer a wider range of products for a pretty low price point, and sends a wide variety of items from different companies every month. What it comes down to is this: whether or not Gentleman’s Box is a good choice for you depends on what you’re looking for in a men’s monthly clothing subscription. 

Gentleman’s Box Promotions & Discounts 

For this Gentleman’s Box subscription review, we hunted for the best deals offered by the brand. You can often find a Gentleman’s Box promo code on their social media. Visit their site regularly for a Gentleman’s Box coupon when it’s offered.

Gentleman’s Box also offers a program for social influencers and other affiliates, but the requirements make it somewhat difficult to qualify for. You’ll need over 100K followers for influencers, and you’d need to have an online store to be an affiliate. But, if you do qualify, they could be a great way for you to save (or even earn) money.

How to Sign Up for Gentleman’s Box 

Gentleman's Box Subscription Review 8

Signing up for monthly subscription boxes for men can be super confusing. No worries though. We’ll go through the steps to sign up for Gentleman’s Box quickly and easily:

  1. Start by navigating to the Gentleman’s Box website.
  2. Choose between the Classic Box and the Premium Box, depending on your preference
  3. Select Start Your Membership, and scroll down to click Start Your Subscription
  4. You’ll then be offered the opportunity to choose from add-ons, including additional accessories and Mystery boxes
  5. Once you’re satisfied, select Check Out Now and you can enter any coupon codes you have
  6. Enter your billing and shipping address, and you’re done!

FAQ

Cancel Gentleman’s Box 

There are no fees charged for cancelling your subscription. You can cancel monthly or premium Gentleman’s Box subscriptions at any time by calling 1 (248)-479-6066 during business hours. To cancel before the next billing date, you must call at least one full day before that date

Note that annual or gift subscriptions cannot be cancelled. Both will automatically expire after their term. 

Due to California Automatic Renewal Law, residents of California can email their cancellation. All other subscribers must cancel by phone.

Shipping Policy

United States:

Gentleman’s Box ships to the continental United States, Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, all other U.S. territories, and APO/FPO/AA/AE/AP addresses.

International:

Gentleman’s Box ships to the following international locations: Canada, the United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand,  Denmark, Estonia, Germany, Finland, Austria, Belgium, France, Gibraltar, Hong Kong, Spain, Hungary, India, Svalbard and Jan Mayen, Sweden, Israel, Italy, Japan, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Philippines, Poland, Thailand, Republic of Ireland, Saint Martin, Singapore, South Korea, Switzerland, and Portugal.

There may be additional charges for shipping internationally, and shipments could be subject to additional duties or fees. 

The shipping time for Gentleman’s Box is approximately between 3-5 business days within the US, and 8-13 business days for other countries.

Return Policy

Gentleman’s Box does not offer returns on boxes that have already been delivered. If your package is missing or damaged, you can contact Gentleman’s Box within 30 days of the delivery date.

Contact Gentleman’s Box 

Gentleman’s Box can be contacted via their website’s Contact Us form, Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, or Youtube.


If you want to play the field with subscription boxes, check out our reviews for competing brands:

Sprezzabox

Bespoke Post

Frank & Oak

Menlo Club

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *