Table of Contents
Persona Nutrition vs Care Of: Brand Showdown
Persona Nutrition takes care of your nutrient needs by delivering exactly what you need on schedule. Featured in Oprah Magazine, ABC News, and Forbes among other outlets, the brand excels at helping you create a vitamin and supplement wellness routine that is clinically approved and reliably delivered.
Care Of wants to make a healthy body and lifestyle so easy that anyone can do it. They accomplish this mission by assessing your daily nutritional needs and creating balanced formulas that help you optimize each day. It all starts with a quiz that acts as an ice breaker and makes Care Of familiar with what you’re hoping to accomplish in life.
This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of review will examine in great detail the differences between the two brand’s best-selling products, how effective they are, the overall benefit-cost ratio, the fine details of their subscription options, and a whole lot more.
Overview of Persona Nutrition and Care Of
Persona Nutrition uses the cold skill of scientific analysis for human good. All of their research and testing goes into improving the lives of their customers by keeping their bodies healthy.
The brand was founded in 2016 by Jason Brown, an entrepreneurial veteran; Tamara Bernadot, a nutrition specialist; and Prem Thudia, an IT guru. The team ensures that Persona Nutrition’s quality products are easily available.
The founding trio behind Persona Nutrition have worked together for more than 20 years, which is a great sign that the company is well-managed and serious about long-term success.
In keeping with their commitment to transparency, they also provide details on their team of 15+ nutritional specialists, who help deliver exactly what you need from their products. They also have accessible information on the doctors who make up their Medical Advisory Board and keep Persona Nutrition up to date with new research breakthroughs.
Persona Nutrition also has a philanthropic connection to Vitamin Angels, bringing proper nutrition to children across the world. To date, the brand—through their customer support—has helped over 1 million children grow up healthy and free from disease. Their key focus is providing Vitamin A to avoid children from going blind.
At Care Of, their number one promise is honesty about the vitamins they give you. They dive deep into the science behind high-quality nutrition and bring back only the best of the best. But they don’t keep the behind the scenes process a secret, instead telling you how rigorously backed their products are by modern science through 6 categories:
- Limited Research
- Emerging Research
- Good Research
- Strong Research
- Very Strong Research
- Traditionally Used
None of this is arbitrary. Care Of relies on their Scientific Advisory Board of doctors, researchers, and nutritionists to analyze the latest research and help develop powerful products.
Naturally, this process is limiting; Care Of doesn’t hide the fact that their intense selection criteria means they offer fewer products than their competitors. For them, it’s a source of pride to have every single product come from a clean source and provide verified results. They will give you the best or nothing at all.
This journey of creating the highest-quality vitamins, personal for your needs, began in New York City in 2016 when Akash Shah and Craig Elbert founded the company. A great thing about Care Of is that the CEO (Craig) and Head of Product (Akash) publicly list their own daily vitamin routines.
While still based in New York city, Care Of’s Research and Development and Supply Chain teams operate out of beautiful Vermont.
Persona Nutrition Digestive Enzymes vs Care Of Probiotic Blend Review
Persona Nutrition’s Digestive Enzymes are a cure to stomach aches and pains that so many people accept as a part of everyday life. But in addition to resolving digestive sensitivity, each capsule also supports your natural ability to transform carbs, fats, and proteins into the nutrients that keep you healthy.
All of these features work together for the same goal: increasing your digestive health. In doing that, the Digestive Enzymes capsules get rid of the nasty symptoms of improper digestion, including a bloated stomach and heart ache. Each pill is smaller than a penny and packed with all-vegetarian ingredients to assist your body break down meals.
Care Of’s Probiotic Blend comes from Denmark and is a non-GMO, vegan supplement that promotes a healthy gut and immune system. Probiotics are increasingly recognized as an important facet of having a healthy body, and many people turn to yogurt or kombucha to incorporate these live microorganisms into their diet.
Care Of isn’t the first brand to create a probiotic pill, but they are definitely popularizing it as a regular supplement that should be taken daily. True to their commitment to transparency, Care Of says up front that they are “Good Research” but still far from “Very Strong Research” or “Traditionally Used”.
At the same time, there are many intense scientific studies showing the benefits of probiotics, which of course caught Care Of’s eye. They now offer it to you as a daily supplement, delivered to your home, with 100% transparency and no gimmicks.
WINNER: Care Of
The Digestive Enzymes offered by Persona Nutrition are a legitimate way to ease digestive problems, but they only attack symptoms, not the source. The high-quality probiotics that Care Of puts forward help your whole body flourish and become strong, while also easing annoying symptoms.
Plus, Care Of takes the time to actually share the research behind probiotics in detail, so that you can read for yourself why the brand decided to put it on the market.
Persona Nutrition Milk Thistle vs Care Of Milk Thistle Review
Persona Nutrition added Milk Thistle to their product catalog to help your liver function optimally and to promote wholesome inflammatory reactions. Liver and inflammation issues are common for people having trouble with diet, stress, alcohol, or the deteriorating effects of old age.
Milk Thistle is a natural plant that has silymarin, an antioxidant ingredient that is essential to cleansing your liver and making it work the way it’s supposed to. In addition to helping your reactions function at full capacity, Milk Thistle also helps rejuvenate the cells in your body.
The Milk Thistle supplement offered by Care Of is sourced from Austria, the Czech Republic, and Germany, and then processed in Spain—where ethanol is used as a gentle way to prepare it for your consumption and, ultimately, where it will promote a healthy liver through antioxidation.
Care Of lets us know that the seed in the Milk Thistle is what makes it so valuable as an antioxidant, and that even the ancient Romans knew about its healing properties.
Care Of is also transparent about the “Limited Research” backing any claims about Milk Thistle’s health benefits. At the same time, they can and do honestly cite it as “Traditionally Used”.
But while science shows that Milk Thistle should have amazing effects, the clinical data has yet to match it. As usual, Care Of lists the studies and their details for your viewing pleasure.
WINNER: Care Of
Once again, Care Of goes the extra mile and gives us in-depth details about their ingredient sourcing and the research behind the supplement. Persona Nutrition only gives us information secondhand which, in addition to vague claims about Milk Thistle benefitting “cellular health” and “inflammatory response” makes them just a little bit less trustworthy.
Persona Nutrition Immune Boost Lemon Ginger vs Care Of Vitamin C Review
Immune Boost Lemon-Ginger by Persona Nutrition has everything you need to stave off cold and flus. It’s meant to be taken throughout the year, mixed into beverages, to keep your immune system strong no matter what life throws your way. Persona says that (similar to their Milk Thistle) the Immune Boost also “supports healthy inflammatory response”, which this Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review still finds a little vague.
This vegan supplement supports your digestive system, which is the biggest part of your immune system. ResistAid, the essential component, is made in the US. One clinical study is cited to prove its efficacy. Persona Nutrition also notes that sleep, exercise, and quality meals also help your immune system function properly.
Care Of’s Vitamin C is a staple vitamin and made from organic, vegan, and non-GMO ingredients. The production process involves fermentation, which makes your body benefit more from each capsule.
Vitamin C has “Strong Research” backing its use as an antioxidant and minor immune system support. The brand goes on to say that this element is overhyped in its ability to support your immune system. It is found in a wide range of fruits and vegetables, which Care Of recommends that you consume.
Care Of goes out of their way to tell you that Vitamin C isn’t going to magically enhance your immune system, and that you should really be eating healthy foods to get it, not taking vitamins.
But, if your diet doesn’t include Vitamin C-rich foods, then this supplement is available for you at a reasonable price. They summarize and provide full access to the scientific studies proving Vitamin C’s potency.
WINNER: Care Of
Neither product is particularly appealing, but Care Of’s Vitamin C simply seems more effective than Persona Nutrition’s Immune Boost formula.
This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review appreciates that Care Of doesn’t try to sell Vitamin C as a magical cure, while also citing the research that shows how it’s useful. In comparison, Persona Nutrition’s claims about their Immune Boost supplement appear inconclusive.
Persona Nutrition vs Care Of: Quality
Persona Nutrition works tirelessly with suppliers they have built long-standing relationships with. At the same time, their science is cutting edge and they have real people (plus machines) examine each shipment before it goes out. Additionally, they showcase a virtual tour of their production process, so you can see for yourself where your orders come from.
Care Of has a strict quality standard for research that products must meet to be finalized in their catalog. All of their offerings are then double checked and confirmed, after production, to meet set expectations. They always choose the premier option when given the opportunity (isolate vs concentrate) and source ingredients from across the world.
WINNER: Persona Nutrition
It’s difficult to choose a winner for this contest. Persona Nutrition inches ahead of Care Of because they offer a virtual tour of their production and fill us in on key details—like the human inspection of each package, and how they can pinpoint exactly which ones need to be recalled in case of an emergency.
Persona Nutrition vs Care Of: Customer Ratings
Persona Nutrition is loved by thousands of customers across the world, as well as top influencers such as Oprah and Forbes. Across all platforms, they have an average rating of 4.1/5 stars.
Nearly 6,000 customers on notoriously negative Trustpilot rated them 4.3/5 stars, while happy Amazon shoppers went a bit lower in the 4/5 star range—still making for a very strong rating overall.
This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review put together a list of the most common feedback, both good and bad.
Pros:
- Capsule packets arrived torn/opened
- Convenient
- Impressive customization option
- Excellent customer service
Many customers shared on Trustpilot that the service representatives were attentive and helpful. One 5-star comment read, “Very personal service, I had a phone call and emails trying to reach out and make sure all my questions were answered. The process has been very simple. Awesome experience.”
While another testimonial discussed the efficiency of the products, “Feel great. It’s only been almost a week with all the new supplements, but I feel like my body got what it needed!”
Cons:
- Pricey
- Wasteful packaging
- Delivery issues
An unhappy buyer wrote, “I did not receive correct supplements. Auto ship was [too] early so over-stocked in supplements.” This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of review notes that all of the complaints were followed up by the brand’s nutritionists, who were quick to offer solutions.
Care Of doesn’t have as many customer reviews as Persona Nutrition, but they get just as much love in their ratings. On Trustpilot, this Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review found an astonishing average rating of 4.6/5 from a little over 1,800 ratings.
The other major source of reviews is retail partner Target’s online store, where Care Of has a 4/5 star average from over 1,000 ratings.
This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of review parsed through customer feedback for Care Of to make the following list.
Pros:
- Compostable and recyclable packaging
- Convenient
- Easy to use Care Of vitamin phone app
One customer left this 5/5 star review on their official website, echoing the sentiments of many: “Each item listed is full of information that you would need, readily available instead of having to do the footwork on your own. Fast shipping and great customer service.”
Testifying for Care Of’s convenience factor, a buyer shared, “I have a very stressful job, working from home, and just 2020 in general. I needed help with all of the above and in an easy way to remember. Thank you Care for having my back. In a nice box that I can leave on my desktop, everything in one little package. It’s perfect.”
Cons:
- Deliveries not always on time
- Pricey
One customer left 2/5 stars for the brand and summed up her experience, “My last order was a week late and now I’m getting my vitamins in bottles rather than individual packs. That defeats the whole purpose for me. I can get exactly that at a local store for half the cost.”
WINNER: Persona Nutrition
On Trustpilot, where reviewers are notoriously fickle and negative, both Persona Nutrition and Care Of are rated, on average, above 4.2/5 stars. But Persona Nutrition has nearly 6,000 reviews, whereas Care Of has nearly 2,000.
Persona Nutrition simply has a greater volume of feedback and a high rating that has sustained over a longer period of time.
Persona Nutrition vs Care Of: Promotions & Discounts
There were no Care Of discounts or promotions at the time of this review. Persona Nutrition, on the other hand, has a standing offer of 50% off your first month.
To use this offer, all you have to do is take a simple assessment about your lifestyle and nutritional needs, then complete your profile. The discount will be applied once the order is confirmed.
WINNER: Persona Nutrition
When it comes to allowing customers to save some money, there’s no contest. This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review found zero for one brand and 1 for the other, leaving us with an obvious winner.
Persona Nutrition vs Care Of: Shipping & Returns
Persona Nutrition ships internationally to more countries than this Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review can list. They do warn that, for non-domestic orders, the process of getting through customs is longer, due to the “health” category of their products.
The brand does their utmost to have your supplement delivery arrive by the date scheduled in advance. When it comes to returns, Persona Nutrition holds their cards close. All we ascertained was that it takes around 47 hours for them to process a refund.
Care Of lays out their shipping and returns information in great detail. They cover delivery charges on orders $20 and up (the likely scenario), while you will have to shell out $8 per monthly shipment for orders under that amount.
International customers of any kind must pay an extra $6 for handling—but, at the time of this Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review, that’s only Canada. The company tells us they will expand to more countries in the near future.
WINNER: Care Of
Care Of is much more open about their shipping and returns process. While they don’t deliver internationally, we at least know the cost and process. Persona Nutrition probably would have taken this section, had they included more information on their website.
Persona Nutrition vs Care Of: Price & Value
Similar to their shipping and returns policies, Persona Nutrition shares nearly nothing about their pricing on their official website. They inform us that since their recommendations vary due to individual needs, so do their price points.
This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review went to their Amazon page, and after going through many products “currently unavailable”, found a 28-day supply of the Persona Detox Premium Vitamin Pack for $33.
There is also a 5-capsule blend Sleep & Restore Premium Daily Vitamin Pack available for $29. Unfortunately, this doesn’t tell us nearly enough for a comprehensive comparison.
Care Of, on the other hand, tells you the cost of each vitamin as soon as you click on its product page. You learn everything you need to know from their official website, and the cart simply lists each vitamin, its individual price for a 30-day supply, and then the total at the bottom. This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of review found the purchasing process very clean and simple (it doesn’t require any guesswork).
This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review created a sample order from Care Of roughly equivalent to Persona Nutrition’s Amazon offerings and found the pricing to be almost identical. The real difference between the brands is how transparent they are.
Conclude section with WINNER: Care Of
This Persona Nutrition vs. Care Of vitamins review can say that we favor brands that are upfront about their pricing. With that in mind, Care Of is the clear winner.
Their pricing is clearly available for each vitamin, making it easy for you to plan out a specialized order down to the last detail, without having to worry about the total bill until the end.
We Choose: Care Of
Care Of is the clear winner. They are more transparent about their ingredients, health research, shipping information, and much more. That is the biggest point in their favor, and it makes the brand overall more trustworthy. Excellent customer reviews match Persona Nutrition’s in all but quantity.
Care Of either matches or beats Persona Nutrition in nearly every category, largely due to lack of information from Persona. They don’t yet ship internationally, but when they do, we have every reason to believe it will be with the same quality of product and straightforward purchasing process that has built them a great reputation.
Looking for even more comparisons between top-selling brands? Here are a few more you can take a look at:
Noom vs. Weight Watchers Review
Ask the community or leave a comment
WRITE A REVIEWCustomer Reviews
Leave a review