Table of Contents
About Cheryl’s Cookies
With the obvious and everyday choices of flowers or chocolates to send for an occasion, Cheryl’s Cookies offer another option that is unique and almost certain to be loved by the recipients.
With 22K followers on Instagram and almost 200K likes on Facebook, this brand has made a tasty name for itself on social media and in mainstream media.
E! Online, Us Weekly, NBC News, USA Today, and many more outlets feature Cheryl’s Cookies as one of the best ideas for gifts for any occasion or holiday.
In this Cheryl’s Cookies review, I’ll take a close look at the brand to see if they are worth your while. I’ll do this through their promotions, products, and, most importantly, their customer reviews.
Overview Of Cheryl’s Cookies
Cheryl’s Cookies started in Ohio as a brick-and-mortar bakery in 1981 by Cheryl Krueger. The bakery became very popular because of her simple, yet tasty, buttercream icing that is second to none.
Part of what makes the buttercream so special is that it is made of four simple ingredients – butter, vanilla, evaporated milk, and powdered sugar.
In 2005, 1-800-FLOWERS bought the brand and brought them under their wing. They are a large company with several online platforms for ordering gift baskets/boxes including baked goods, fruits, flowers, chocolates, and more.
The five bakery locations continue to retail to the public and bake the goods that go to delivery orders, all while keeping Krueger’s original taste.
They are also involved with a couple of charity organizations including food banks and Nationwide Children’s Hospitals as well as running the Summer of a Million Smiles employee volunteer campaign.
Before I take this Cheryl’s Cookies review over to check out some of their baked goods, let’s take a gander at what makes this brand so special.
Highlights
- Sells ideal gift baskets and goodies for any occasion
- Tastiest buttercream icing across the nation
- Delivery to anywhere in the US
- Large selection of yummy cookies
- Gluten-free options
Cheryl’s Cookies Boxes Review
Since the ‘80s, Cheryl’s Cookies has been famous for their buttercream icing. With only four ingredients that grandma would have used – powdered sugar, butter, evaporated milk, and vanilla – this icing is natural and scrumptious.
They also offer a variety of cookies, with and without the buttercream icing, to grab any sweet tooth. They also freeze well for freshness.
Cheryl’s Cookies boxes come in a selection for every occasion and holiday. Each has cookies specifically chosen for an event for their shape, color, and flavor.
Birthday boxes for children include cookies decorated with hundreds and thousands and Spring occasions have bright colors in flower shapes. In this section of my Cheryl’s Cookies review, I’ll take a look at some of their best sellers.
Cheryl’s Cookies Mystery Flavors Box Review
The Cheryl’s Cookies Mystery Flavors Box is a great way to tell someone that you are thinking of them or as a treat for yourself.
With a variety of tasty flavors, the recipient is bound to find some that they can’t resist. Or you can find your new Cheryl’s Cookies favorite.
There are at least eight individually-wrapped flavors in each box of 36 cookies for $20.
Cheryl’s Cookies Birthday Party in a Box Review
No birthday is complete without cookies and the best box of cookies for the occasion is Cheryl’s Cookies Birthday Party in a Box.
This box comes with an assortment of 15 cookies including buttercream and chocolate chip, many in bright colors as well as hundreds and thousands.
This birthday in a box also comes with four confection pretzel clusters, a 4 oz bag of sour gummy stars, and a confetti birthday Gracelet cake for the person of honor. This whole box-sized celebration is $33.
Cheryl’s Cookies Thank You Gift Tower Review
What better way to say thank you than Cheryl’s Cookies Thank You Gift Tower? Three colored boxes of varying sizes come stacked in clear film, with a large “Thank You” tag attached.
Not only is the presentation cheerful, but it also makes sure the recipient is aware of how much their work, help, services, or friendships meant to you.
This box set includes 28 baked goods:
- Buttercream cookies, assorted flavors
- Snack-sized oatmeal, chocolate, and sugar cookies
- Confection pretzel clusters
- Confection covered pretzels
When words aren’t quite enough to say how thankful you are, you can get this tasty tower for $40.
Cheryl’s Cookies Our Best Buttercream Cookie Box Review
Since they are known for their buttercream cookies, their Cheryl’s Cookies Our Best Buttercream Cookie Box is a given favorite. It comes with an assortment of 11 buttercream cookie flavors, all individually wrapped for freshness. The yummy tastes include:
- Buttercream Frosted Cut-Out Cookie
- Buttercream Frosted Key Lime White Chip Cookie
- Buttercream Frosted Orange Citrus Cookie
- Fudge Buttercream Frosted Chocolate Chocolate Cookie
- Strawberry Buttercream Frosted Sugar Cookie
- Buttercream Frosted Chocolate Chocolate Cookie
- Buttercream Frosted Salted Caramel Chocolate Cookie
- Buttercream Frosted Lemon Burst Cookie
- Buttercream Frosted Wedding Cake Cookie
- Buttercream Frosted Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookie
- Buttercream Frosted Butter Pecan Cookie
These delicious cookies come in boxes of 12 to 100. The box of 12 was $35 and is now $18, making multiples of it your best bet until you reach the 72 cookie size.
Who Are Cheryl’s Cookies For?
Based on the research done for this Cheryl’s Cookies review, I think that these baked goods are for anyone looking to brighten a person’s day by sending them an assortment of delicious cookies.
They are also ideal for any occasion or holiday with themed boxes. If you are a fan of these cookies, you can treat yourself anywhere in the US and they also have gluten-free options.
Cheryl’s Cookies Reviews: What Do Customers Think?
Okay, so on to my favorite part of this article: the Cheryl’s Cookies reviews from their customers.
Starting with Influenster, which has 1,487 reviews and a rating of 4.3/5 stars, we can easily see that these gift boxes are perfect for brightening up a person’s day when they are going through a difficult time. One customer wrote:
“SO GOOD. My best friend is battling cancer right now, and with the launch of each new round of treatments, I send her Cheryl’s Cookies. They cheer her up, and they taste delicious. They’re also shipped promptly and stay remarkably fresh. Looking for a sweet gift? Look no further.”
What a perfect way to say that they are thinking of you as well as delivering a crowd-pleasing, yummy treat.
On the flip side, the next Cheryl’s Cookies review wanted a great way to say thank you for a hospital stay that was made bearable by the staff. They bought a box to create smaller thank you bags and wrote the following testimonial:
“These cookies were amazing I got mostly butter cream cookie cut outs. There were a few others like gingerbread and chocolate. I recently had a surgery – I made bags of cookies for individuals (surgeon & anesthesia) and teams (nurses station & preop team). This is a great way to try different cookie’s. Thank you for creating.”
But not everyone wants these cookies for a present. Some want them just for themselves so this bakery offer boxes of cookies for anyone.
On QVC, this Cheryl’s Cookies reviewer bought the 34 Piece Buttercream Frosted Cutout Cookies for themselves. They were among 28 reviews with an overall 4/5-star rating. They rave:
“I recently ordered these just for myself. I kept them in my freezer and took out two everyday for my desert after dinner. They are soft and the icing is thick, sweet and LUCIOUS!!! I’m thrilled to have them to look forward to each day and will continue to order them as long as Cheryl’s makes them!!! OUTSTANDING! TERRIFIC! THE BEST!!!”
Wow, that review made me hungry for these cookies. I just may have to order some but I’ll show some discipline and wait until I finish this Cheryl’s Cookies review.
The last review is from the brand’s website about Cheryl’s Cookies Birthday Party in a Box. This delivery put smiles on many faces with their charitable works. They say:
“My granddaughter loved it! I work with adults with disabilities so supporting Smile Farms was a no brainer. The package came nicely wrapped and arrived a little early for her birthday. She called me immediately and said it came right on time as she had a sweet tooth”
Before I wrap up this section, let’s take a look at their product ratings from their website:
- Cheryl’s Cookies Mystery Flavors Box – 61 reviews – 4.4/5 stars
- Cheryl’s Cookies Birthday Party in a Box – 356 reviews – 5/5 stars
- Cheryl’s Cookies Thank You Gift Tower – 32 reviews – 4.8/5 stars
- Cheryl’s Cookies Our Best Buttercream Box – 3 reviews – 3.4/5 stars
So, as we can see, they usually rate very well based on their products. There are some complaints on the Better Business Bureau site that are mainly about delayed shipping times that led to a box being delivered late.
In COVID times, it is a reality that shipping companies are sometimes late. Fortunately, Cheryl’s Cookies contacts and tries to resolve each complaint.
Are Cheryl’s Cookies Legit?
Yes, Cheryl’s Cookies is a legitimate platform to shop for cookies for yourself or as a gift. They sometimes have issues with delivering on time, which is not unusual when companies must rely on courier services to send their products.
Are Cheryl’s Cookies Worth It?
So, does this Cheryl’s Cookies review writer think the brand is worth it? Yes, absolutely. These cookies are something that you can’t get anywhere else as they have a 40-year history of making these tasty treats.
As a gift, they are perfect for any occasion or holiday, with themed boxes. Best of all, Cheryl’s Cookies make a perfect gift to cheer up anyone who needs it.
Cheryl’s Cookies Promotions & Discounts
Cheryl’s Cookies offers one way to save on their website which is their sales section. While the brand doesn’t have any Chery’s Cookies promo codes available at the moment, there are still savings to be had.
Where To Buy Cheryl’s Cookies
You can only get Cheryl’s Cookies online through their website at cheryls.com. For a brick-and-mortar location, there are a few in Ohio.
FAQ
Who owns Cheryl’s Cookies?
Cheryl’s Cookies is owned by 1-800-FLOWERS, a large company with several delivery gift service platforms.
Does Cheryl’s Cookies ship internationally?
Cheryl’s Cookies ships internationally to Canada only, which needs to be done through a customer representative by telephone, not online.
What is Cheryl’s Cookies’ Shipping Policy?
Shipping with Cheryl’s Cookies depends on the price of your order and how quickly you would like to ship it. The brand’s website has a full list of prices and shipping options.
What is Cheryl’s Cookies’ Return Policy?
Since they deal in perishable foods, there is no return policy. If you are not happy with your order for any reason, contact them at 1-800-443-8124.
How To Contact Cheryl’s Cookies
If you have any questions that this Cheryl’s Cookies review didn’t cover, you can contact them directly at:
- Phone: 1-800-443-8124
- Use the Live Chat feature on their website
Check out some of our recently published articles:
Ask the community or leave a comment
WRITE A REVIEWCustomer Reviews
Leave a review