Brook and York Review

About Brook and York

Brook and York Review

Customized jewelry is very trendy these days, so lots of people have nameplate necklaces and bracelets. To stand out, you need to do something a little different. 

That’s where Brook and York come in. They make beautiful, custom jewelry with unique twists, like stylized writing and coordinate jewelry, making them the perfect gift or statement piece.

Covered in major media like Men’s Health, NBC Today Show, ET, and Vogue, this brand is no slouch when it comes to social media either, garnering  60.3k followers on Instagram and about 20k on Facebook. 

My Brook and York review will take an in-depth look into this brand and their promotions, products, customer testimonials, and more, all in the hopes that you can make an informed decision before you buy.

Overview of Brook and York

Brook and York Review

According to an article in Elle, Brook and York launched in 2016 with two missions. 

The first is to create affordable, customized jewelry and the second is to do it quickly. The aim was to get the piece that you ordered into your hands in 4 to 5 days.

By being solely digital and cutting out the middlemen, Brook and Young can pass on the savings to you. All their jewelry is made in Rhode Island, while the company headquarters and warehouse are in Saybrook, Connecticut. 

They are owned by Tenth Avenue Holdings, a privately-held holding company with headquarters in New York.

Before I steer this Brook and York review into some of the eye-catching jewelry, let’s go over what exactly makes this brand so special:


Brook and York Review
  • High-quality, affordable jewelry
  • American inspired, American made
  • Customized jewelry
  • Free shipping in the US
  • Thoughtful gift ideas
  • Financing options available via Afterpay

Brook and York Jewelry Review

The Brook and York jewelry collections include necklaces, bracelets, earrings, rings, and fine jewelry. Their most popular items, however, are the custom ones with initials and nameplates. 

Their styles draw from American architecture making them “American inspired and American made.” I can definitely get behind that.

The range of materials comes in gold, silver, and rose gold colors, which look as stunning as fine jewelry with more durability and at a more affordable price.

Moving forward, my Brook and York review will take a look at some of their best-sellers and see what all the fuss is about.

Brook and York Madeline Two Initial Pendant Review

Brook and York Review
Brook and York Madeline Two Initial Pendant

As the name suggests, with two initials to choose from, the Madeline Two Initial Pendant necklace can represent someone or something meaningful to you. 

It can be your significant other’s initials or perhaps your best friend’s, maybe your kids’. This beautiful necklace is all about recognizing the special people in your life. The materials are a choice of gold, sterling silver, or rose gold if you’re feeling adventurous. 

To keep things nice and secure, this product is made with a satellite chain that has beads or disks at intervals for a pretty design detail but it also keeps the pendants from traveling up the chain and ending on the back of your neck. 

Keep loved ones close to your heart for $82.

Brook and York Fulton Classic Monogram Necklace Review

Brook and York Review
Brook and York Fulton Classic Monogram Necklace

Although there are monogram necklaces available everywhere, they don’t have the style and sophistication of the Fulton Classic Monogram Necklace

With space for three stylized and vine-inspired letters, this unique pendant is attached with a break in the necklace to keep it in place. It comes in sterling silver, 18K gold plated, and 18K rose gold plated silver.

With three colors and four sizes to choose from, you can find whatever best suits you. All come on a 16” chain with a 2” extender. Here are your options if you want to be caught styling this eye-catching necklace:

  1. Mini – ⅝”  – $108
  2. Small – ⅞” – $118
  3. Medium – 1 ¼” – $128
  4. Large – 1 ½” – $138

Brook and York Coordinate Cuff Bracelet Review 

Brook and York Review
Brook and York Coordinate Cuff Bracelet

For many of us, there are places that hold a special place in our hearts. It could be where we or our children were born, maybe where you got married, or perhaps where you found yourself. 

While pictures are a nice way to remember, a Brook and York Coordinate Cuff Bracelet is a great way to take it with you anywhere while dressing up any outfit.

Available in 14k gold plated, rhodium-plated, and 14k rose gold-plated brass, this bracelet is a ¼” wide and 5 ½” long with a space between ends. It is stamped with coordinates marking anywhere in the world you want to remember. 

Pick up this attractive conversation starter for $74.

Brook and York Nella Nameplate Ring Review 

Brook and York Review
Brook and York Nella Nameplate Ring

Nameplate necklaces made a resurgence in the 21st century thanks to the “Carrie necklace” in Sex and the City. But what if you want that fun without plastering it around your neck? Then the Nella Nameplate Ring is perfect for you. 

Dainty and pretty, this ring can fit up to about five letters in a calligraphy print. On your hand, it is less noticeable to strangers but you can look at it throughout the day.

The font is lowercase throughout and the ring comes in sterling silver, 18k gold, and 18k rose gold plated sterling silver. The band is 2mm while the name is about ¼” high. It is available in sizes 5-9. 

You can slip this cute ring on your finger for $92

Who Is Brook and York For? 

Brook and York Review

Brook and York are for any woman looking for jewelry that means something to you and tells a story. Perhaps it’s a necklace with the initials of your best friends or maybe the coordinates of where you met or married your husband on a stylish bracelet.

This jewelry is great if you buy it for yourself but even better as a gift from a loved one or significant other. It’s hard to resist such a beautiful and thoughtful gift.

Brook and York Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Brook and York Review

Now, it’s time for me to take a look at what Brook and York reviews from across the internet have to say about the brand. 

Let’s start with this 10/10-star review on US reviews. They’re spreading the love with presents for their loved ones because they love the quality and customer service: 

“I’d give 1,000 ⭐️ If I could! Beautiful jewelry and reasonable price! I had to change an error in shipping address and they were on it! Had it fixed in just minutes! I ordered a necklace for myself, mom and sister and… ordered a ring for myself and a necklace for two wonderful friends, bc they deserve the quality of Brook and York… Thank you Brook and York!!!! ♥️⭐️”

While there is no doubt that they were really happy with the ring, they are most happy to share the joy. That’s because Brook and York is the ideal place to get a thoughtful and seemingly expensive gift. 

This Brook and York review from a customer got their girlfriend the Madeline Two Initial Pendant on Macy’s website where it had 4/5 stars over 3 reviews. They say:

“Wow! Very high quality for the price. My girlfriend loved this gift. She has worn it almost every day since I gave it to her. The quality of this is fantastic and she thinks I paid a lot more for it than I did. The customization came out very well and I’m surprised I received it so quickly.”

It’s always good when someone thinks that you paid more than you did on their present. The thing about this jewelry is that these pieces are conversation starters, especially the Coordinate Cuff Bracelet

This Brook and York review, taken from Amazon where the bracelet has 4.4/5 stars on 19 reviews, found it to be the ideal gift for his lady:

“Perfect Gift. I got this for my girlfriend for our 2 year anniversary and she won’t take it off. She gets constant compliments and the coordinates make for a great story. Great product! Super high quality!”

Well, I wish I knew what that story is but the point is that people can’t help but ask what the numbers stand for. 

While all the customers so far found this custom jewelry great for gifts for someone else, the following Brook and York review said that the Nella Nameplate Ring to be a great gift for themselves: 

Cutest ring EVER! I was pleasantly surprised with the quality. I was skeptical ordering a custom ring at first, but I’m glad I did I’ve work it for 2 weeks straight and there has been no bending that usually happens with cheaper rings. It’s subtle and perfect with any outfit highly recommend!”

Before we move on, let’s take a look at how this brand’s jewelry rates with their customers (sourced from their website):

  • Brook and York Madeline Two Initial Pendant – 51 reviews – 5/5 stars
  • Brook and York Fulton Classic Monogram Necklace – 52 reviews – 4.9/5 stars
  • Brook and York Coordinate Cuff Bracelet – 118 reviews – 4.9/5 stars
  • Brook and York Nella Nameplate Ring – 46 reviews – 4.9/5 stars

Wow, those are some very impressive ratings. With no reviews on Trustpilot and no complaints on the Better Business Bureau’s website, most of their customer reviews are glowing.

There were a few complaints about tarnishing, so it should be noted that, because these pieces are not pure gold or silver, they can tarnish. 

While some people have no issues wearing them all the time, it is recommended that you don’t wear them where they may get wet often. Also, some people’s PH levels can naturally cause tarnishing. 

Is Brook and York Legit?

Brook and York Review

While there were lots of great Brook and York reviews from their customers, a tiny number complained about tarnishing. On a whole, everything seems pretty kosher with this brand.

Is Brook and York Worth It?

Brook and York Review

So, let’s get down to business about whether this brand is worth your money or not. In our humble opinion, they are definitely worth it

Firstly, the number of complaints of tarnishing is really minimal and to be expected. Secondly, many customers report that this is high-quality and beautiful jewelry. Thirdly, these are truly unique pieces that you won’t find anywhere else.

But there is more. Their customized jewelry makes the perfect gifts because they are thoughtful and beautiful. All of this for an affordable price. 

The jewelry looks as good as fine jewelry with more durability and at a fraction of the price. So, again, yes, Brook and York are worth your money whether for yourself or for a loved one.

Brook and York Promotions & Discounts 

Brook and York Review

At the time of this Brook and York review, I found a few ways that you can save money by going through the brand’s website:

  • Brook and York promo code ONEDAY for 15% off your order
  • Sign up for insider perks
  • Check out the sale section on their website
  • Financing options available with Afterpay 

Where to Buy Brook and York

Brook and York Review

With free shipping and other money-saving promotions, Brook and York’s website at is the best place to buy their jewelry. 

Their products can also be found on Amazon and at high-end department stores like Nordstrom and Macy’s.


Brook and York Review

Who owns Brook and York?

A large, privately owned holding company called Tenth Avenue Holdings owns Brook and York.

Where is Brook and York jewelry made?

All Brook and York jewelry are handmade in the US.

Does Brook and York ship internationally?

I’m happy to report that Brook and York ships internationally to Canada, Australia, and Mexico at this time.

What is Brook and York’s Shipping Policy?

Brook and York offer free economy shipping in the US with options to upgrade if you would like faster service. Economy takes about 5-7 business days after they process your order. 

Most items are processed within 24 hours while monogram jewelry and a small number of other items take 3-5 business days.

What is Brook and York’s Return Policy?

With Brook and York, you have 60 days from the date of purchase to return items. Returns and exchanges must be in good condition. Personalized jewelry cannot be returned or exchanged. 

Here’s how to go through the return process:

  1. Find the invoice and indicate the reason for return or info on the item you want in exchange
  2. Write “return” or “exchange” on the invoice
  3. Write your daytime contact number
  4. Pack up the returned items with the invoice and address to: P.O. Box 482 Old Saybrook, CT 06475
  5. Mail using the US Postal Service

If all is well, you should receive your refund within 15 days of receipt by Brook and York.

How to Contact Brook and York

Brook and York Review

If you have any questions that this Brook and York review didn’t answer, you can reach out to them through the following methods of contact:

Customer service hours are Sunday – Friday 9 am to 6 pm EST.

Check out similar brands you might like:

Gorjana Jewelry Review

Purely Diamonds Jewelry Review

Pompeii3 Jewelry Review

Bayam Jewelry Review

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required