M.Gemi Shoes Review

About M.Gemi

Our MGemi shoes review dug into the foundation and belief system of the brand, uncovering their commitment to quality and developing beautiful pairs crafted by hand. M Gemi offers a variety of luxury Italian footwear for men and women. The direct-to-consumer startup is reviewed as high quality and affordable, more so than the luxury markup of traditional retailers. 

Business Insider recently wrote about M.Gemi’s “cult-favorite” loafers, which are frequently waitlisted due to popularity. Is this brand the real deal, or just hype? This M.Gemi shoes review will take an in-depth look at the brand and a selection of bestsellers, customer ratings, promotions, and more, to help you decide if their products are worth the buy. 

M.Gemi Shoes Review

Overview of M.Gemi 

The mission of M.Gemi shoes grew its roots in Sicily. Founder Maria Gangemi grew up on the Greek island and developed an admiration for the attention to detail of the local artisans. These artisans would make just a few pairs at a time and Maria gained a passion for the unparalleled quality of stunning, handmade shoes. 

M.Gemi’s mission is to make shoes the old way and sell them the new way. Our M.Gemi shoes review highlights some of their most popular designs, shoes that Gangemi describes as Italian luxuries for modern life.” 

M.Gemi Shoes Review

M.Gemi was founded in 2015 and is headquartered in Boston, MA. They partner with small artisanal workshops across Italy. What’s the benefit of this for you as a consumer? Not only are you supporting an age-old craft, but the shoes are made with the knowledge of families who have been perfecting shoemaking for generations. The shoes are made with delicate detail and dependable quality. 

If you would rather catch the highlights of this M.Gemi shoes review, here’s our sum up:


  • Beautiful shoes
  • Good shipping and return policies
  • Many customers reported great customer service
  • Many of the shoe styles fit multi-purposes


  • The shoes ship in the continental U.S 
  • M.Gemi offered rave reviews about the detail and effort put into their quality but some customers were dissatisfied with their purchases
  • While the shoes are affordable, the quality was lost
  • Some customers felt slighted when they tried to make returns
  • Some customers found the shoes uncomfortable

M.Gemi designs high-end flats, sandals, drivers, sneakers, loafers, heels, boots and oxfords. They also offer a range of belts and socks to accent the footwear. This M.Gemi shoes review showcases a selection of the brand’s bestsellers, starting with the ladies.

M.Gemi Women’s Shoes

M.Gemi’s shoes for women range from casual and stylish sneakers, sandals, flats, and drivers, to more elegant heels, boots, and loafers. The classic styles complement many different outfits, and even with the more laidback styles, their Italian leather offers sophistication. Check out these popular pairs:

Sacca Donna Suede Slip-Ons

The Sacca Donna Suede Slip-Ons are one of M.Gemi’s most-loved moccasin-style loafers. The Sacca Donna slip-ons are unlined with a soft kid perforated suede upper. Their leather sole contains a rubber insert to absorb pressure, complemented by a moisture-wicking leather footbed

These elevated casual, comfortable everyday beauties are handmade in Toscana, Italy. Whether you’re clocking mileage on city streets or putting together a glam office look, these M.Gemi shoes will transition flawlessly. 

The Sacca Donna Suede Slip-Ons are also available pink and electric blue, if you want to add brights to your basics. Currently, you can catch the wave of a fantastic sale: These MGemi loafers have been reduced from $248 to $160

Celia Leather Sandals 

In our M.Gemi shoes review, we examined the Celia Leather Sandals, another topseller for women. The Celia’s are the true embodiment of the M.Gemi standard, where luxury meets modern life. Day demands meet night looks with their bold multi-color metallics. Their shine can dress up a pair of jeans, or match with a skirt on an evening out if you feel like ditching heels.

The Celia Leather Sandals feature comfortable leather-wrapped foam straps, a stacked leather 10 mm heel, with a leather lining and footbed. The lightly padded insole adds extra comfort and a durable leather sole provides breathability. Think beach vacation, glam date nights, or put-together errands. 

The Celia Leather Sandals are $198, and you’ve got options with this style. These M.Gemi sandals are available in white leather, anthracite and gold multi metallic, luggage leather, bronze, fuchsia and orange multi metallic, and black leather. 

Felize Leather Moccasins

When you pair practical and graceful, you get the kind of shoes you keep going back to. In both these departments, the Felize Leather Moccasins deliver. With a leather and rubber sole, these loafers will get you from A to B in comfort and style. The tumbled leather upper and oval toe is supported with a leather lining. They have the classic rim stitching along the upper of traditional Italian leather loafers.

Our M.Gemi shoes review showed that these loafers are the number one bestseller for women. They’re made by a small Tuscany workshop and every detail is laboured over because quality counts. Priced at $198, the Felize Leather Moccasins are available in navy, gray, cappuccino, black, pale pink, and white. 

M.Gemi Men’s Shoes

M.Gemi shoes are for the modern man who gravitates toward traditional suave. From laidback drivers and sneakers to loafers, boots, and oxfords fit for a gentleman. M.Gemi also designs belts and socks for guys to match with their shoes. We’ll shine a spotlight on some of their top sellers:

Lucente Calfskin Leather Sneakers

In our M.Gemi shoe reviews, we were struck again by the balance between classy and practical. The Lucente Calfskin Leather Sneakers strike that balance. They’re effortlessly chill. These M.Gemi sneaks are made as thoughtfully as your best dress shoes with a supple leather upper and a rubber sole that is stitched by hand. The padded back collar offers additional comfort, with waxed laces adding more to the distinguished leather look. 

The Lucente Calfskin Leather Sneakers are handcrafted in Marche Italy. The $278 sneakers also come in all white, navy and white, black and white, all grey, and all black.

Brolio Suede Loafers 

The Brolio Suede Loafers are the bestselling driving moccasin according to our M.Gemi shoes review. Built for comfort with a breathable all leather lining and footbed, the shoes are like outdoor slippers. M.Gemi maintains sharp attention to detail with the tonal stitching and the large rubber peg driving sole. 

The Brolio’s are made for slim pants, jeans, chinos, and cotton shorts. Handmade in Veneto, Italy, they’re the kind of premium shoes other guys comment on. The Brolio Suede Loafers are priced at $228 and come in navy, gray, tan, orange and black. 

Volo Due Leather Loafers

The Volo Due Leather Loafers exude fine Italian charm. It’s all in the details with these traditional penny strap loafers. The sewn edge seams, blake stitching construction, and box-stitched penny strap are all handcrafted elements. 

Handmade in Toscana, Italy, these handsome loafers will impress at the office, on a date, at the next wedding, wherever you want your inner gentleman to come out. The Volo Due Leather Loafers cost $278 and are available in tan.

M.Gemi Shoes Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

This M.Gemi shoes review uncovered some contrasting opinions on the footwear, some highly positive, others negative. Some customers were unhappy with the products and said that they would not repeat a purchase or stand behind the shoes. The heart of their dissatisfaction was that M.Gemi made a broad promise and did not deliver to the standard of quality. Some customers’ shoes started to show wear shortly after their purchase. 

M.Gemi Shoes Review

What exacerbated the frustration of these M.Gemi customers and turned them off the shoes was that the customer service was poor and the company was unwilling to back their product when it deteriorated. The return policy, which seemed flexible on assessment, was not as good on the ground, according to reviewers. 

Other customers felt differently. They don’t hesitate to purchase more M.Gemi shoes. From the perspective of these happy shoppers, the shoes are top quality and the customer service is great. Those who loved the shoes described them as seriously attractive and they would recommend the shoes to loved ones. These happier customers had good experiences with return and exchanges, and they thought the prices were reasonable for the quality. 

Is M.Gemi Worth It?

M.Gemi Shoes Review

There are two camps when evaluating the M.Gemi product. One is dissatisfied and the other is glowing. Our take on the divide is to proceed with caution. The footwear is reviewed as beautiful. There is a mixture of reviews on customer service and returns. The clincher is the quality. While the satisfied customers thought the quality was excellent, other customers had a serious bone to pick. 

The glossy frontier of M.Gemi is that the shoes are handcrafted by knowledgeable artisans in Italy but some find that the promise does not deliver. In this M.Gemi shoes review, we don’t see this as a reason not purchase, but to explore your choices with open eyes and weigh beauty against durability. 

M.Gemi Promotions & Discounts 

M.Gemi Shoes Review

Our M.Gemi shoes review discovered that the team offers a welcome gift. When you sign up, you enjoy $50 off your first order. Check back regularly at for an upcoming M Gemi promo code or M Gemi discount code. 

There is a selection of M. Gemi sale items available right now. The website has a Before They Go section, where you can browse discounted shoes from last season, offered at lower prices so that they can make room for the new designs.

Where to Buy M.Gemi 

The brand’s entire product line can be purchased through Select footwear is available at the M.Gemi showroom in Bloomingdales, through Amazon, and discounted on Lyst. 


M.Gemi Sizing 

M.Gemi uses Italian sizing, which is a more exact method of measurement compared to US sizing. There are fit notes on every product details page, developed based on the specific design of each shoe and real-life feedback on fit. For example, some loafers start out snug but stretch with time and the product details page accounts for this. 

Italian SizingUS Sizing
M.Gemi Men’s Size Chart
Italian SizingUS Sizing
37.57W 7.5N
39.58.5W 9N
M.Gemi Women’s Size Chart

M.Gemi Shipping Policy

Good news in this M.Gemi shoes review: the company offers complimentary shipping with the purchase of their product. M Gemi shoes arrive within 3-6 business days after the package has shipped throughout the continental US. Options for 2nd day shipping ($15) and next day shipping ($30) are also available in the continental US. 

M.Gemi offers complementary standard shipping for most U.S. orders and returns. The company ships to Alaska and Hawaii with second day air.  Tracking information will be e-mailed to you when your order ships and you can check the status of your package at any time. 

M.Gemi Return Policy

M.Gemi has a decent return policy. They offer customers the opportunity to try on shoes at home with complimentary returns. You have 14 days from the date of receipt of your order to make a return of full price products. To receive a full refund, your shoes must be in their original, unworn condition.

For orders placed in the US, you can visit to initiate a return. For orders placed in the M.Gemi showroom in Bloomingdale’s, you can initiate a return by emailing your order number to [email protected] 

Contact M.Gemi  

If you want to chat, M.Gemi is available from Monday to Friday 10 AM-7 PM. Our M.Gemi shoes review showed that the best ways to reach them are to: 

Check out these other luxury Italian shoe brands:

Ace Marks

Jack Erwin

Oliver Cabell

Ask the community or leave a comment

Ask a Question
Asked by TJ (1 year ago) Reply

Sicily is not a Greek island. It is a beautiful part of southern Italy.

Asked by Clarence Simms (1 year ago) Reply

I have several pairs of Italian made shoes made in the 80’s. The stylings are almost identical and are still absolutely beautiful and relevant to me. Is it possible that I could have new pairs made for me in today’s market?

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required