Reviews

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

About Mayfair Toilet Seats

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

Toilet seats are typically ignored in house flips. The image alone is far from glamorous, but it’s important to invest in a durable cover. As the king of the castle, your commode requires the very best. Thankfully, Mayfair Toilet Seats offers a great selection of models to choose from. 

Headed by the Bemis Manufacturing Company, Mayfair focuses on re-inventing houseware to appeal to the modern-day palette. Over the years, the brand has managed to capture some public attention, as its Facebook page boasts 27.6k followers. A few magazines have endorsed their products in the past, including Healthline and the New York Magazine. 

Is Mayfair deserving of its number one title, or is it clogged with unnecessary hype? In my Mayfair Toilet Seats review, I will get to the ‘bottom’ of this, as I’ll take a closer look at the brand, its products, customer ratings, promotions, and more to help you decide if they’re worth checking out. 

Overview of Mayfair Toilet Seats

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

The story begins in 1932 when founder Albert Bemis decided to take on a different career path. Instead of producing kid toys, he switched over to making toilet seats.

In the brand’s first few years, Bemis was known for its compression molding process to help create enameled wood covers. Over time, the brand was passed down from generation to generation. 

In 1950, Bemis saw the birth of Mayfair: a retail brand devoted to selling toilet seats to the public. Now found in stores across the western hemisphere, Mayfair is considered the top choice for many homeowners. Today, the company’s headquarters are located in Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin. 

Before we get into my Mayfair Toilet Seats review, I thought it best to go over some highlights first. 

Highlights

  • A curated selection of toilet seats with a variety of modern features
  • Available in different colors to fit your aesthetic
  • Built with several features such as added stability and increased adjustability
  • Affordable options from the brand
  • The brand offers a ‘compare product’ feature for customers to use
  • Available at reputable retailers 

The furniture industry loves to glamorize love seats, chaises, and bar stools. Aesthetics matter when it comes to marketing, which is probably why toilet seats are often left in the dark. 

It may seem like a stretch to call commode covers furniture, but they do play a crucial role in our daily lives. Case in point, Mayfair acts as a subtle reminder for homeowners to pay attention to their toilets. 

From potty training models to designs made with extra stability, Mayfair offers a curated assortment of toilet seats. Customers can narrow their search down by color, added features, material, color, price, and more which helps simplify the shopping process. 

Care for some recommendations? If so, keep reading my Mayfair Toilet Seats review as I will feature a few of their best-selling models for customers to consider. 

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

It’s worth noting that customers cannot buy Mayfair products on the brand’s official website. Instead, buyers will be re-directed to one of their partnered retailers. Thankfully, the brand’s selection of toilet seats can be found at your local department store, such as Bed Bath & Beyond.

Moving forward, this Mayfair Toilet Seats review will highlight a couple of their top-selling designs to help customers get started. 

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Caswell Review

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Caswell Review
Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Caswell

I swear, the toilet seat slam is as loud as a fire alarm. Especially in the middle of the night. Users should gently settle the cover down to minimize noise, but sometimes accidents happen. 

Thankfully, the Caswell seat ensures zero noise, thanks to its patented design. Constructed with an STA-TITE Seat Fastening System, users can look forward to a secure, whisper-quiet experience for numbers ones or twos. 

Made out of durable plastic, there’s no need to worry about chipping, scratches, and stains. On the plus side, this cover is designed with eco-friendly materials to help mitigate waste. Offered in pearl white, the Caswell seat retails for $20

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Basket Weave Review

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Basket Weave Review
Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Basket Weave

The Basket Weave toilet seat directly proves that commodes can also be aesthetically pleasing. Decorated with scalloped edges, this cover can easily complement the modern bathroom. 

In terms of product specs, it’s constructed with an STA-TITE Seat Fastening System and a whisper close component to ensure durability and zero slamming. Once it’s time to clean, customers can easily disassemble the cover to better reach those pesky nooks and crannies. 

Built with enameled wood and finished with high-gloss polish, this commode cover is definitely suited for kings and queens. Price-wise, the Basket Weave toilet seat sells for $40 at Walmart. 

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis TruComfort Review

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis TruComfort Review
Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis TruComfort

On average, it takes 5 minutes for users to do the ‘duty.’ Obviously, some days require extra time if you’re suffering from constipation or an upset stomach.

Sitting around shouldn’t result in much discomfort, but trust me, stiff butt syndrome is a real thing. To avoid shifting and soreness, the TruComfort cover ensures a cloud 9 experience from start to finish.

Designed with ErgoCurve Technology, this toilet seat features built-in flex inserts to help relieve pressure. It also comes with whisper-close innovation and the STA-TITE Seat Fastening System to ensure stability and minimize noise.

Offered with super grip bumpers to prevent shifting, the TruComfort cover’s suggested retail price is $50

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis NextStep2 Review

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis NextStep2 Review
Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis NextStep2

Got a toddler in the house? Instead of resorting to pricy mini toilets, the NextStep2 is designed to affix to your pre-existing commode. This 2-in-1 cover is enhanced with a magnetic fastening, an STA-TITE Seat Fastening System, easy hinges, and whisper-close technology for added convenience. Plus, it eliminates the need for cleanup as opposed to portable potties. 

As a bonus, the NextStep2 toilet set is easy to disassemble just in case your toddler is reaching their preschool years.

Offered in white, biscuit creme, and bone, this potty-training necessity retails for $48

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Kendall Review

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Kendall Review
Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Kendall

To help clear any misunderstandings, the Kendall toilet seat is in no way affiliated with the Jenners. With that being said, its quality design definitely deserves some celebrity backing.

Considered one of Mayfair’s more simplistic models, this product features an E4 hinge system, a durable build, and whisper close technology to help give users peace of mind. 

Constructed out of enameled wood, the Kendall toilet seat is designed to last for years. Plus, it’s relatively easy to clean, thanks to its hinge removal system. If you’re looking to update your home commode, this durable cover’s suggested retail price is $38

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Round Plastic White Never Loosens Removes for Cleaning Slow-Close Review

Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Round Plastic White Never Loosens Removes for Cleaning Slow-Close Review
Mayfair Toilet Seats By Bemis Round Plastic White Never Loosens Removes for Cleaning Slow-Close

Impressive in construction, the Round Plastic White Never Loosens Removes for Cleaning Slow-Close seat is considered a step-up from your usual toilet seat. 

It comes with the same patented features as Mayfair’s other models, which include the STA-TITE Seat Fastening System, easy hinges, and whisper-close technology. You can practically say goodbye to pesky cleanup and accidental slams. 

Polished to perfection, going number one or two has never felt so classy. In terms of price, this versatile toilet seat is offered at $29

Mayfair By Bemis Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat Review

Mayfair By Bemis Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat Review
Mayfair By Bemis Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat

Untextured toilet seats were so last season. For those in need of a more fashionable alternative, the Round Enameled Wood cover comes with decorative edging to help complement your bathroom space.

Built from enameled wood, this durable model is further enhanced with the STA-TITE Seat Fastening System and whisper hinges to ensure soft closing. 

Best of all, this commode cover comes in a polished finish, which helps protect the product from scratches and stains. Provided in standard white, the Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat retails for $42 on Amazon. 

Mayfair By Bemis Cameron Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat Review

Mayfair By Bemis Cameron Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat Review
Mayfair By Bemis Cameron Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat

Tired of standard white? If so, the Cameron Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat comes in a variety of different colors, such as blue, pink, and black. 

Aside from aesthetics, this commode cover offers the same level of convenience and durability found in other Mayfair products. This includes an STA-TITE Seat Fastening System and easy hinges to ensure pain-free cleanup. 

Offered in a round shape, the Cameron Round Enameled Wood Toilet Seat costs $19 MSRP.

Who Is Mayfair Toilet Seats For?

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

Every house has a toilet. With that in mind, I think it’s safe to say that Mayfair is for everyone. From porta-potty installations to secure-grip covers, the brand offers a great selection of models fit for any age demographic. In terms of price, they’re relatively affordable, given that most of their products retail for around $20 to $40.

Unfortunately, customers cannot buy their products on the brand’s official website. But to Mayfair’s defense, their models can be purchased at several reputable retailers which makes them a highly accessible company compared to other leading competitors. 

Mayfair Toilet Seats Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

Toilet seats may seem like a worry-free expense, but it’s still important to don your responsible shopper hat. Trust me, there’s nothing more disappointing than seeing your money go down the drain. 

Fortunately, for this section of my Mayfair Toilet Seats review, I found a decent amount of positive feedback online. This includes ratings posted on websites such as Amazon, Walmart, and The Home Depot. Here’s what I found for some of the best sellers I featured: 

  • Caswell toilet seat on Walmart: 292 reviews with 4.2/5 stars 
  • TruComfort cover on Home Depot: 13 reviews with 4.7/5 stars
  • NextStep2 on Amazon: 14k ratings with 4.7/5 stars 
  • Round Plastic White Never Loosens Removes for Cleaning Slow-Close on Walmart: 37 reviews with 4.6/5 stars 

According to several satisfied customers, Mayfair Toilet Seats lived up to their expectations. As promised by the brand’s product descriptions, their models are durable, comfortable, and elegantly designed. Of course, don’t take my word for it, let’s look closer at some reviews. 

This was perfect and the round size fit well. I like that it does not slam when you close it. I have young children and it prevents them from closing their fingers on it,” one Walmart customer wrote about the Round Plastic White Never Loosens Removes for Cleaning Slow-Close. 

One Home Depot user said this about the TruComfort: Definitely a conversation piece, when company comes! It is, however, very comfortable and helps Eliminate that tingling numb feeling in your legs and feet.”

Others commended specific features such as the easy hinge system, which helped simplify cleanup. Most customers were impressed by its soft-close component, as it allowed the toilet seat to fold gently without much noise. 

“The shape of both seats makes them comfortable for adults and children to sit on. The soft-close feature of the seats/lid is very slow, but it’s a nice feature (it prevents a lot of toilet seat slamming),” one Amazon reviewer said about the NextStep2.

While writing my Mayfair Toilet Seats review, I also found a decent amount of independent blogs that offer critiques of the brand. According to CleanMySpace.com, the brand’s selection of toilet covers proved to be a valuable asset in the modern bathroom. The author also commended the company’s use of eco-friendly materials

They wrote: “An enameled wood seat is a strong, comfortable seat with a glossy finish that complements any sleek, modern bathroom…The result is a versatile toilet seat with superior strength and performance and a warm, inviting feel.”

So, what’s the overall consensus? Does this brand get two thumbs up? Before you settle on a toilet seat cover, I thought it best to go over some customer complaints first. Hopefully, it will help you decide whether this company deserves your undivided attention.

Is Mayfair Toilet Seats Legit?

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

Unfortunately, Mayfair Toilet Seats isn’t totally free of crappy customer experiences. Some buyers reported cracked seats and manufacturing defects with their covers. Others stated that their products showed scratches after a few initial uses.

Despite all of this, you can take care knowing that these issues are quite rare compared to the number of positive reviews I found online. 

Is Mayfair Toilet Seats Worth It?

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

As far as standard toilet seats go, Mayfair is considered the gold standard if you need a decent upgrade. Most of the models come with several nifty features, including soft-close technology and flex inserts. Elegantly designed and easy to install, Mayfair toilet covers provides a world of convenience that you’d never expect. 

On the plus side, the brand’s selection of covers is styled for the modern bathroom. From scalloped designs to textured edging, you’ll think twice about your plain toilet seat. All in all, after conducting my Mayfair Toilet Seats review, I highly recommend that you give this brand a try. 

Mayfair Toilet Seats Promotions & Discounts 

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

At the time of writing my Mayfair Toilet Seats review, the brand wasn’t currently holding any sales. But they do have some sales from time to time, so I recommend keeping tabs on Mayfair’s social media for any future updates.

Where to Buy Mayfair Toilet Seats

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

Looking to upgrade your toilet? If so, you can visit toiletseats.com to see what they have in store. You can also find their products sold at:

  • Amazon
  • The Home Depot 
  • Rona 
  • Walmart 

FAQ

Mayfair Toilet Seats Review

Who owns Mayfair Toilet Seats?

Mayfair is owned by the Bemis Manufacturing Company.

Does Mayfair Toilet Seats ship internationally?

Unfortunately, customers cannot buy their products on the brand’s official website. For shipping information, you’ll want to visit one of their retail partners such as Walmart or Amazon.

What is Mayfair Toilet Seats’ Shipping Policy?

As previously mentioned, the brand’s catalog for toilet seats is only for viewing purposes. If you wish to buy their products, you’ll need to visit one of their partnered retailers. With that in mind, it’s only natural to assume that they don’t have a shipping policy.

What is Mayfair Toilet Seats’ Return Policy?

I’m happy to report that all of the brand’s products are covered under a one-year warranty. It’s worth noting that this doesn’t include components such as solid wood, decorator, or if it’s used by businesses such as hotels.

Otherwise, to start a return, you should follow the information provided by whichever store you buy it from. 

How to Contact Mayfair Toilet Seats

For any comments or concerns you have after reading my Mayfair Toilet Seats review, you can contact the brand through one of these methods below:

  1. Phone number: 888-722-6488
  2. Email: [email protected]
  3. Fill out the contact form
  4. Using the chat function

Their customer service team is available Monday through Friday from 8:00 am to 5:00 pm CST.


Check out similar reviews you might like:

Kohler Review

Kohler Review

Kingston Brass Review

10 Best Faucet Brands

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This field is required