SuperJeweler Review

About SuperJeweler 

SuperJeweler Review

SuperJeweler is an online jewelry company that designs necklaces, earrings, bracelets, and rings. With a sizable following of 15k on Instagram, SuperJeweler has been featured countless times in the media.

This includes appearances on television shows such as The Price is Right, Dr. Phil, The Doctors, and The View, and in Woman’s World and Good Housekeeping magazines. SuperJeweler was also the 2019 winner of SiteJabber’s customer service award.

This SuperJeweler review will explore the brand by taking an in-depth look at its products, customer ratings, promotions, and more, to help you decide if their products are worth the buy. 

Overview of SuperJeweler 

SuperJeweler Review

Founded in 1999 in the glamorous city of New York, SuperJeweler was established with the help of its CEO, Andrew Fox. With over 25 years of experience, Fox employed only the most experienced staff to be on his team.

Most employees have 50 years of experience working in the gemstone industry and are located all around the world. According to, the company employs staff from India, the Dominican Republic, Sri Lanka, Belize, Puerto Rico, China, Vietnam, Philippines, North Carolina, and New Jersey.

With an in-house factory, SuperJeweler has over 35,000 styles of necklaces, bracelets, rings, and earrings to choose from. The company states that no other jewelry store has such unique designs in such large quantities. They pride themselves on being an affordable option for those looking to buy quality jewelry

As SuperJeweler continues to grow rapidly as a business, Fox has recently made appearances on several media outlets. He has been invited as an expert to offer insight into jewelry worn by celebrities such as Sarah Hyland, Jennifer Lawrence, and Scarlett Johansson. 

“Our dedicated staff works harmoniously from sun-up to sun-down to fulfill your orders and satisfy your wishes, hopes and dreams for really beautiful fine jewelry,” via a statement on their website.

SuperJeweler Review


  • 35,000 jewelry designs to choose from
  • Affordable pricing
  • SuperJeweler offers a custom design program where customers can create their own styles 
  • Positive customer reviews 
  • Installment payment options available for most jewelry
  • Free international shipping 
  • All jewelry comes with a Lifetime Guarantee and a no-risk, 60-day money-back guarantee 


  • The website is dated and is hard to navigate, with too much information on the landing page
SuperJeweler Review

Shopping for a special occasion or looking to treat yourself? Whatever the case may be, SuperJeweler offers thousands of designs to choose from. This ranges from necklaces, bracelets, earrings, and rings.

Customers can either shop by collection or gemstone. From amethyst to aquamarine, there are styles suited for both men and women[1]. This SuperJeweler review will highlight only their bestsellers for both categories within this feature. 

SuperJeweler Women’s Jewelry Review

Ladies, nothing says treat yourself quite like jewelry. It’s about time that we reward ourselves with something sparkly and glittery. This SuperJeweler review will highlight four of their bestselling jewelry within the women’s section.

Who knows? You may end up adding one of these pieces to your cart. Also, it’s important to keep in mind that most pieces offered by the brand can be purchased with monthly Layaway installments.

SuperJeweler 1 Carat Round Diamond Solitaire Ring Review

Simple jewelery is becoming quite popular on social media, and for good reason. Minimalistic trinkets are not only beautiful by themselves, but can pair with an entourage of outfits.

The 1 Carat Round Diamond Solitaire Ring is the embodiment of exquisite simplicity. This design features a 14k white gold band with a 1 carat round diamond[2] nestled in the center.

According to the product description, “The diamond color is I-J, which is whitish in color, and I2-I3 Clarity Enhanced which shows eye visible inclusion and is very bright and fiery.” For those not fond of white gold, they can opt for rose gold or yellow gold.

The 1 Carat Round Diamond Solitaire Ring is perfect for those who prefer a minimalistic aesthetic, and are not particularly fond of frills and feathers. This piece is priced at $1998 (originally priced at $3000).

SuperJeweler 14K White Gold 3 Carat Diamond Halo Teardrop Earrings Review

Is it just me or do the 14K White Gold 3 Carat Diamond Halo Teardrop Earrings give off Bridgerton vibes? While they aren’t exactly regency appropriate, you can totally imagine Daphne or Queen Charlotte wearing these beauties on the show.

These earrings feature 80 diamonds in I-J color with SIJ-I1 clarity. Fastened with a secure screw back, these SuperJeweler earrings would look gorgeous in a regency-inspired empire waist dress detailed with gorgeous embroidery.

Achieve the Daphne Bridgerton aesthetic with these halo teardrop earrings for $8000 (discounted from $11,000).

SuperJeweler 1ct Blue Diamond Solitaire Pendant Review

There’s something about the Blue Diamond Solitaire Pendant that gives off a mysterious allure. It’s probably the 1ct blue diamond[3] pendant, evoking the shallow seas with a gradient-like hue.

Set in 14K yellow gold, this stunning pendant comes with a complimentary gold chain. If you’re not a fan of the size of the gemstone, you can opt for ⅛ ct, ¼ ct, ½ ct, ¾ ct, or 1 ½ ct. You can also opt for sterling silver or white gold as alternatives.

If you want to look secretive and bewitching, add this to your cart for  $1809 (discounted from $2,783). The significant discount caught this SuperJewelry review’s attention, that’s for sure.

SuperJeweler 3 ½ Carat Diamond Tennis Bracelet Review

Here’s a fun fact: the tennis bracelet was coined by professional tennis player, Chris Evert. During a match, her diamond necklace broke and fell off her wrist. After famously stopping the game to get it fixed, the media made the situation a widespread news story, with jewelers trying to recreate the iconic piece.

The 3 ½ Carat Diamond Tennis Bracelet is nearly an exact replica of the iconic Evert bracelet, just fastened more securely. This 8” bracelet is decorated with diamonds in a J-K color and I1-I2 clarity.

Offered in white gold, customers can opt for different lengths, including 6”, 6.5”, 7”, or 9”. Even though you may not get publicity wearing this iconic piece, you’ll definitely catch the attention of some onlookers from its sparkling design.

The 3 ½ Carat Diamond Tennis Bracelet is offered at a discounted price of $1,300 (originally priced at $2,000). You can save even more with the SuperJeweler promo code SJBRR.

SuperJeweler Men’s Jewelry Review

Diamonds can be a man’s best friend, too. SuperJeweler has a wide selection of men’s jewelry including rings, bracelets, earrings, necklaces, and cufflinks.

Keep reading this SuperJeweler review for our take on four of their most popular items:

SuperJeweler Jewelry Heavy Mens Wedding Band Review

Why should women only get the diamond ring? This wedding band breaks the traditional gender norm that gets to rock ice. Featuring a 14k white or yellow gold band, this ring features 8 diamonds that total a ¼ carat weight.

Finished with milgrain highlights, the diamonds are set in G/H in color and SI2 in clarity. The Heavy Mens Wedding Band is currently listed for the reduced price of $2,100 (discounted from $4,000).

SuperJeweler 1.6 Carat Diamond Single Mens Hoop Earring Review

Instead of opting for a simple diamond stud, a plain gauge, or a miniscule hoop, the 1.6 Carat Diamond Single Mens Hoop Earring is perfect for those looking to add more glamour to their overall look.

This beauty features 6 diamonds that total ⅙ of a carat. With the diamond color set at K-L with I2-I3 clarity, these SuperJeweler earrings are set with secure hidden snapbacks to lock in place.

Offered in various metal including rose gold, white gold, and yellow gold, the 1.6 Carat Diamond Single Mens Hoop Earring comes in two different cuts. You can purchase the earring as single or a pair:

  • Black diamond pair/K-L diamond pair: $800 (originally priced at priced at $900)
  • Black diamond single: $400 (reduced from $600)
  • K-L diamond single: $600 (discounted from $800)

SuperJeweler 9 Carat Three Row Diamond Men’s Tennis Bracelet Review

This men’s tennis bracelet is one of the most high-end pieces that SuperJeweler offers. Featuring 180 sparkling diamonds in I-J color, I1-I2 clarity, and an astounding 9 carat weight. Each diamond is arranged in a singular line, stacked in rows of 3.

You can also opt for a different metal type, which includes rose gold, white gold, and yellow gold. Secured with a box tongue clasp, make sure you don’t lose the 9 Carat Three Row Diamond Men’s Tennis Bracelet, since it retails at $13,900 (discounted from $15,000).

SuperJeweler 925 Sterling Silver 3.5mm Popcorn Chain Necklace Review

On the less extreme scale, the 925 Sterling Silver 3.5mm Popcorn Chain Necklace is one of their more affordable pieces. This simple sterling silver necklace has a chain length of 18”.

Fastened with a lobster clasp to keep the necklace secured, you can display this popcorn chain with a simple white t-shirt and tan blazer for a classy, casual look. Available in silver or yellow, you can choose between two widths:

  • 3.5mm in width: $50 (discounted from$100)
  • 4.9mm in width: $70 (discounted from $100)

SuperJeweler Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

SuperJeweler Review

This SuperJeweler review found a generally positive customer response based on its research. On their official website, there are countless reviews that praise the jewelry as beautiful, affordable, and high quality. There are also reports of good customer service.

“When I received this ring, I was so amazed at how beautifully white and bright the diamonds were, and it fits perfectly. My husband bought it for my birthday and 50th wedding anniversary. Thank you so much for such a beautiful ring,” one reviewer wrote on the SuperJeweler website.

There are also positive reviews on their Trustpilot page. SuperJeweler has 3.8/5 stars out of over 620 reviews. Buyers have noted that their customer service team was helpful and quick to respond to any problems or complaints. There are also continued accounts of people stating their prices are very affordable

“I placed an order for a beautiful necklace and somehow it ordered 3 necklaces. I contacted SuperJeweler’s customer service and the wonderful representative took care of the problem immediately. Customer service like this is one reason that I am a repeat customer,” one Trustpilot reviewer wrote. 

This SuperJeweler review found a few customer complaints and red flags. We researched the question, ‘Is SuperJewler legit Reddit?’ Unfortunately, this review found zero SuperJeweler threads on Reddit. However, there are some negative reviews on a few of their Amazon product pages. 

Is SuperJeweler Worth It?

SuperJeweler Review

This SuperJeweler Jewelry review readily recommends this jewelry brand to anyone looking for high-quality designs at an affordable price. One of the main advantages of this brand is their massive inventory of jewelry, amounting to at least 35,000 designs.

Most SuperJeweler pieces are heavily discounted from the original price. They also give you an estimate of the average listing price for each of their items, so you know you’re getting your product for a steal. You can also customize your own designs by choosing a select template on their website, which is always a plus.

This SuperJeweler review also found that the company donates a portion of their revenue to the Wounded Warriors Project. You can feel good by contributing to a good cause, which can’t be said for some other jewelry brands. With hundreds of positive customer reviews, be sure to visit the SuperJeweler website to find quality items for reasonable prices.

SuperJeweler Promotions & Discounts 

SuperJeweler Review

This SuperJeweler review found that the company has an Icy Blue Sale, in which select jewelry is up to 80% off if customers use the promo code SJBRR.

Currently, they have a Valentine’s Day Sale, where customers can receive an extra 20% off engagement rings and wedding bands if they use the SuperJeweler discount code LOVE2021.

They also have a clearance section in which items are 40% off with SuperJeweler coupon code CLEAR40.

Where to Buy SuperJeweler Jewelry

SuperJeweler Review

Customers purchase necklaces, rings, earrings, and bracelets from


Where is SuperJeweler located?

SuperJeweler headquarters are located in New York City, which is where they were first founded. 

Does SuperJeweler provide gift wrapping?  

According to their FAQ page, SuperJeweler is packaged in their quality jewelry gift box, or mesh bag at no cost. Options include their standard, keepsake, and luxury presentation boxes. 

What is SuperJeweler’s Shipping Policy?

One of the main advantages of shopping at SuperJeweler is that they offer free shipping all over the world. Their options for shipping within the United States include Free DHL Smart Mail, Free Two Day FedEx, Free USPS Priority, Free Overnight FedEx, FedEx Two Day, and FedEx Overnight.

Customers can find a full list of other shipping options, prices, and delivery times in other countries, such as Super Jeweler Canada, by visiting their website.

SuperJeweler ships five days per week from Monday to Friday. All international shipments may be subject to duties and taxes at the recipient’s expense. Customers can find the status of their order by signing into their SuperJewler login and checking the order status.

What is SuperJeweler Jewelry’s Return Policy?

According to the SuperJeweler returns policy, they offer a 60-day money-back guarantee in which customers can return their orders within that time period for a full refund.

All items must be returned in their original condition. Customers can also exchange their items or request repairs by contacting their customer service team. You can find the details for this on their website. 

How to Contact SuperJeweler Jewelry

If you have questions that were not addressed in this SuperJeweler review, you can contact the company through:

  • customer service number: (877) 888-0175
  • Fax: +1 (917) 779-8165
  • Phone number for all countries outside of the US and Canada: +1 (212) 738-9494
  • Live chat through website
  • Submitting email form via website

The company can be reached from Monday through Friday, 7 am to 7 pm EST, and Saturday 9 am to 6 pm EST.

For more diamond and gemstone jewelry options, check out these popular brands:


Gabriel & Co

James Allen

Blue Nile

Article Sources

[2] Taylor, W.H. Structure and Properties of Diamond NASA/ADS Nature, [online] 159(4048), pp.729–731
[3] Mitchinson, A. The origin of blue diamonds Nature Nature, 560(7716), pp.35–35

Ask the community or leave a comment

Ask a Question
Asked by Jill Russell (2 years ago) Reply

Thinking of purchasing a moissanite ring. Has anyone purchased Moissanite from them? Their prices are super cheap

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required