Petsafe Guardian® GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking vs Halo vs. SpotOn GPS Dog Fences

Dogs get out. Some dig under fences. Some charge after a bird or squirrel without a second thought. Others slip through gates that look closed but aren’t. It only takes a few seconds, and they’re out of sight. You can search the street, call their name, check every corner of the yard, and still have no clue where they went.

It’s scary, and it happens more often than most people expect. That’s why more dog owners are turning to GPS collars. Instead of relying on a physical fence or a leash alone, you can create a safe zone and track your dog’s location right from your phone. It gives you more control, especially if your dog’s the type who likes to test boundaries.

In this review, we will dive into GPS dog fences, focusing on three prominent options: PetSafe, Halo, and SpotOn. Each system offers unique features and approaches, catering to different needs and preferences. By the end of this comparison, you’ll clearly understand what each brand offers. You will be empowered to decide and select the ideal GPS fence to safeguard your four-legged friend.

Whether you have a small yard, a sprawling estate, or simply want peace of mind while out on walks, we’ll guide you through the features, benefits, and considerations of each system.

About PetSafe Guardian® GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking

PetSafe has been making pet products for over 25 years. They’re known for collars, fences, and training tools that are easy to use and built to last. The Guardian® GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking is their newest GPS collar, designed for everyday dog owners who want simple setup and strong tracking.

It connects to the My PetSafe app, where you can create up to 50 virtual fences, track your dog’s location, and get alerts if they leave the safe zone. No wires or digging. Setup takes less than an hour.

The collar is lightweight, waterproof, and fits dogs with necks as small as 8 inches. It runs for up to 70 hours per charge and includes tone, vibration, and static correction options.

With a global presence and a commitment to giving back to the community, PetSafe has become a trusted partner for countless pet parents worldwide. Their dedication to innovation and animal welfare shines through in their product offerings and their ongoing efforts to promote responsible pet ownership.

About Halo

Halo is a relative newcomer to the GPS dog fence market, but it’s quickly gaining attention for its innovative approach to dog safety and training.  Founded by a team of tech experts and dog behaviorists, including renowned trainer Cesar Millan, Halo aims to create a more holistic solution that addresses both containment and behavior.

The Halo Collar utilizes advanced GPS technology and a smartphone app to create customizable virtual fences, eliminating the need for traditional physical barriers. This flexibility allows you to define safe zones wherever you go, whether it’s your backyard, a park, or a campsite. Halo also stands out with its personalized training programs, which are designed to help you build a stronger bond with your dog while establishing clear boundaries and expectations.

While Halo may be a newer brand, their commitment to innovation and dog well-being has already garnered a loyal following. Their unique approach to training, combined with advanced technology, offers a compelling alternative to traditional dog fences and training methods.

About SpotOn

SpotOn’s GPS dog fence system presents an intriguing option for dog owners seeking a reliable, accurate, and customizable solution for pet containment. 

One of SpotOn’s key differentiators is its True Location™ technology, which utilizes multiple satellite systems for unparalleled accuracy in tracking your dog’s location. This advanced GPS capability, combined with the ability to create customizable virtual fences of any shape and size, makes SpotOn a compelling option for those seeking a high level of precision and adaptability.

In addition to its technological potentia, SpotOn offers several notable features designed to enhance the user experience and ensure your dog’s safety. The system includes various correction options, such as tone, vibration, and static stimulation, allowing you to tailor the feedback to your dog’s temperament and training style. Furthermore, SpotOn’s Home Zones feature allows you to designate areas within your home where the collar won’t issue corrections, preventing any accidental triggers.

Petsafe Guardian® GPS 2.0 Dog Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn: What to Consider

As you weigh your options between PetSafe, Halo, and SpotOn, several key factors will influence your decision. This ensures that you get the best fit for your furry friend and your lifestyle.

1. GPS Accuracy and Range

• PetSafe: The Guardian® GPS 2.0 uses dual-frequency GPS and AccuGuard™, which combines satellite signals and motion detection. It sends faster alerts and responds more quickly when your dog moves near the edge of the safe zone. It’s reliable in open areas and works best on ½ acre or larger properties. Like other GPS collars, it can lose signal under thick tree cover or in remote spots with poor satellite access.
  
• Halo: Halo uses GPS backed by multiple satellite networks to reduce drift and keep the boundary stable. It performs well in most areas, even without strong cellular coverage. Some users have noticed occasional lag in location updates, especially when switching zones or tracking in real time.

• SpotOn: SpotOn relies on four satellite systems to improve signal strength and location accuracy. It’s built for larger properties or rural land where layout and terrain make precise tracking more important. The signal is usually strong, but the setup can take longer if the area has uneven coverage.

2. Geofencing and Virtual Fence Capabilities

• PetSafe: The Guardian® GPS 2.0 lets you store up to 50 virtual fences. You can create zones for your yard, a second home, or anywhere you travel. Setup happens in the My PetSafe app, and each zone can be turned on or off as needed. It’s a simple system that works well if you want to switch between safe areas without starting from scratch.

• Halo: Halo also provides customizable virtual fences, catering to different property layouts and outdoor activities. Its smart fence technology adds an extra layer of adaptability, automatically adjusting the boundary based on your dog’s location and behavior. However, the number of fences you can create might be limited compared to other systems.

• SpotOn: SpotOn has no limit to how many fences you can create. You can walk the boundary or draw it in the app. It’s a good fit for large, open land or properties with unusual layouts. Setup takes longer but gives you more control over the shape and size.

3. Activity Tracking and Health Monitoring

• PetSafe: The Guardian® GPS 2.0 shows your dog’s location on a live map through the app. It tracks movement in real time, so you know where your dog is and if they’ve left the safe zone. It doesn’t log behavior or health stats.

• Halo: Halo tracks more than just location. It logs activity levels, rest time, and behavior changes. Some users use it to watch for stress or patterns over time, though it’s not a full health monitor.

• SpotOn: SpotOn tracks your dog’s location and boundary status but doesn’t include health or behavior data. If you want training feedback or daily reports, this one stays focused on containment only.

4. Training Features and Remote Commands

• PetSafe: The GPS 2.0 collar includes tone, vibration, and static correction. You choose what level to use based on how your dog responds. There’s no training program inside the app, but the collar gives clear feedback when your dog nears the edge.

• Halo: Halo includes training videos and step-by-step guidance. It uses sound, vibration, and static like the others, but adds built-in lessons for new users. Good for people who want structured help during setup.

• SpotOn: SpotOn supports tone, vibration, and static corrections. You manage it all through the app. It doesn’t include tutorials or coaching, so it works best if you already know how to train with these tools.

Petsafe Guardian® GPS 2.0 Dog Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn: Quality

Some collars are built for everyday wear. Others are better for big dogs who spend time outdoors in all kinds of weather. Here’s how the materials and build quality compare.

PetSafe
The Guardian® GPS 2.0 is built for daily use. The collar is waterproof, holds up in rough weather, and fits securely on dogs with neck sizes as small as 8 inches. The shell feels solid without being heavy, and it’s compact enough for smaller dogs to wear comfortably.

Halo
Halo has a smooth design and holds up well under normal wear. It’s slightly bulkier than PetSafe’s newer collar but still durable enough for most dogs. The materials feel solid, though some owners with larger breeds have reported needing tighter strap adjustments.

SpotOn
SpotOn’s collar feels tough and handles outdoor conditions well. It’s a good fit for larger dogs or those that spend a lot of time in woods, fields, or water. The size and weight may be too much for smaller breeds, but it’s built to last.

Petsafe Guardian® GPS 2.0 Dog Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn: Price

Investing in a GPS dog fence is an investment in your pet’s safety and your peace of mind. However, the cost can vary significantly between brands and models, with additional factors like subscription fees to consider. Let’s break down the pricing structures for PetSafe, Halo, and SpotOn:

PetSafe

The Guardian® GPS 2.0 costs $399.95. That includes the collar, charger, and a free one-month trial of GPS service. After that, the subscription is $9.99 per month or $89 per year. You’ll need the subscription to use features like real-time tracking, alerts, and saved fences. It’s one of the more affordable GPS collars that still offers strong performance.

Halo

Halo collars start around $699. The price includes access to the app, basic tracking, and training features. A subscription is required for things like live updates, advanced settings, and training videos. Plans vary depending on how much you want to use, but expect to pay monthly or annually on top of the collar price.

SpotOn

SpotOn is the most expensive upfront. The collar usually runs between $999 and $1,295, depending on sales or bundles. You don’t need a subscription to create fences.

While SpotOn’s basic fence functionality does not require a subscription, you’ll need a monthly plan to access features like real-time tracking, escape notifications, and the ability to use the app to guide your dog back home. The subscription cost is relatively competitive compared to other brands.

Petsafe Guardian® GPS 2.0 Dog Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn: What Do Customers Think?

PetSafe

The true test of any product lies in the hands of its users. The Guardian® GPS 2.0 has earned a strong 4.5-star rating from 63 reviewers on the official PetSafe site. Most say setup is simple and the collar is easy to manage, even for first-time users. The app is often mentioned as being clear and reliable.

Several owners highlight how well the GPS tracks in real time and how the fence settings are easy to adjust as needed. Others note that the collar fits well on both small and medium dogs, and that it works even without using static correction.

“Set up was quick and easy and ready to go in a short period of time.”
“I didn’t have to watch any tutorial videos… it was so easy!”
“Both trackers show him in the same spot, so the GPS is accurate.”
“I really like the peace of mind knowing where he is.”
“The charge lasted about 4 days.”
“I chose it mainly for the tracking and containment features, not for any shock functions.”

The overall feedback points to a product that’s straightforward, responsive, and dependable for daily use.

On Amazon, the collar has a 4.6-star average rating from U.S. buyers. Reviews praise the fit, tracking accuracy, battery life, and how quickly dogs adapt to wearing it. Many highlight how the system helps them feel more at ease when their dog is in the yard.

Reviewers also like the app’s layout and mention that the collar works well across different properties. Some users upgraded from earlier PetSafe systems and appreciated the added tracking features.

“Exactly what we were looking for and so easy to set up.”
“Made being outside with our young Golden Retriever so much more relaxing.”
“My dog is super picky and hated the last GPS collar we tried, but she took to this one right away.”
“The app was easy to use, and I love that I can track her and set up zones.”
“The small size fits comfortably on my dog without weighing her down at all.”
“I can check on her location for days without having to recharge.”
“We used the same PetSafe wireless system for the last 13 years! Only upgraded to have the tracking.”

The response from Amazon buyers supports what’s seen on PetSafe’s site: the collar works, the app is easy to handle, and it gives dog owners more peace of mind.

Halo

Halo Collar has garnered a reputation for its advanced technology and comprehensive approach to dog safety and training. On their own website, Halo boasts an impressive 4.7-star rating, highlighting a high level of customer satisfaction among those who have invested in the system. This positive feedback aligns with their emphasis on technology, training, and customer support.

While ratings on other platforms like Amazon and Trustpilot are slightly lower, averaging around 4 stars, they still reflect a generally positive sentiment towards the product. User reviews often praise Halo’s advanced features, such as precise GPS tracking, customizable virtual fences, and the effectiveness of the Cesar Millan-backed training programs. Many users find the real-time tracking and virtual fence features to be particularly valuable, providing peace of mind and flexibility for dog owners. Additionally, Halo’s customer support team is frequently commended for their responsiveness and helpfulness.

Some users have mentioned the higher price point and the subscription model as factors to consider. However, many find the investment worthwhile for the peace of mind and effective training it provides. While a few users have reported occasional issues with GPS connectivity or the app, these instances seem to be relatively infrequent compared to the overall positive feedback.

SpotOn

SpotOn has garnered a generally positive reception among users, with an average rating of 4.4 stars on their website. This feedback highlights satisfaction with its accuracy, customization features, and overall performance.

On Amazon, however, the rating is a bit lower at 3.8 stars. Some users mention experiencing challenges with setup or occasional inconsistencies in certain environments. However, the majority of reviews still acknowledge the collar’s strengths in accuracy and customization.

On Chewy, SpotOn receives a 4.5-star rating, indicating a high level of satisfaction among users who have purchased the collar from this platform.

Overall, the feedback for SpotOn is largely positive, with users praising its accuracy, customization options, and reliability in challenging terrains. While some users have experienced minor issues, the overall sentiment towards SpotOn remains favorable, making it a strong contender in the GPS dog fence market.

Promotions & Discounts

PetSafe

PetSafe understands that investing in your pet’s safety shouldn’t break the bank. That’s why they offer several enticing discounts and promotions to help you get the most out of your purchase of the Guardian® GPS 2.0.

• First-Year Subscription Savings. You can choose between a monthly or annual subscription plan for the Guardian® GPS 2.0 Dog Fence + Tracking. By signing up for the annual plan, you receive a free 1-month trial. After the trial, the monthly plan auto-renews at $9.99, while the annual plan costs $89.
• Free Shipping. To sweeten the deal, PetSafe offers free shipping on orders of $49 or more. This means you can enjoy the convenience of having this cutting-edge technology delivered right to your doorstep without any additional shipping costs.

Halo

While Halo Collar’s advanced technology and comprehensive features come at a premium price point, the company offers several ways to make its system more accessible and budget-friendly for pet owners.

• Subscription Savings. Halo encourages users to opt for annual billing on their Pack Membership Plans, which include essential features like GPS tracking, virtual fences, and training programs. By choosing annual billing, you can save 15% compared to monthly payments, making it a more cost-effective option for long-term use. They even offer a 2-year plan that provides a 20% discount.

• Referral Program. Halo also offers a generous referral program that allows you to earn $50 in gift cards for each friend you refer who purchases and activates a Halo Collar. Additionally, if you refer two or more friends during their special bonus period, you can receive an extra $100 gift card.

SpotOn

While SpotOn’s cutting-edge technology and premium features do come with a higher initial investment, the company recognizes the importance of affordability for pet owners. To that end, they offer a few ways to save on their GPS dog fence system:

• Refer a Friend, Give $25, Get $25. SpotOn encourages its community of satisfied users to spread the word about their product through a generous referral program. By sharing a unique discount link with friends and family, you can gift them $25 off their purchase and earn $25 for yourself when they make a purchase. This win-win situation allows you to save on your own SpotOn investment while helping others discover the benefits of this innovative system.

• Limited-Time Offers and Discounts. SpotOn occasionally offers limited-time promotions and discounts on their website or through authorized retailers. These deals can range from percentage-based discounts to flat-rate savings on the collar or subscription plans. It’s worth checking their website regularly or signing up for their email list to stay informed about any current or upcoming offers.

Shipping & Returns

PetSafe

PetSafe prioritizes fast and convenient shipping for its US customers. Enjoy free standard shipping on orders exceeding $69 within the contiguous United States. 

Need it faster? Expedited shipping options are available for a fee. Subscription orders also come with free shipping. 

However, shipping to Alaska, Hawaii, and international locations may have limitations and additional costs. If you’re not completely satisfied with your purchase, PetSafe offers a 45-day return policy for a full refund of the product price.

Halo

Halo Collar ships to all 50 states in the US and most Canadian provinces, excluding Quebec and Yukon. While they don’t ship internationally at this time, orders within their coverage area typically ship within the timeframe indicated at checkout and include a tracking number for easy monitoring. 

Shipping costs $19.99 for complete collar kits and $9.99 for accessories.

SpotOn

All orders are manufactured, processed, and shipped from their facility in Manchester, New Hampshire, typically within two business days.

For US customers, this translates to a relatively quick delivery time, with most orders arriving within a few days of shipment. However, Canadian residents are responsible for all shipping costs, sales tax, customs duties, and brokerage fees associated with importing the product.

Also, it’s worth noting that they currently do not offer international shipping to other countries. This might be a limiting factor for potential customers outside of the US and Canada who are interested in the SpotOn system.

Who Will You Shop With?

With three compelling options to choose from, deciding on the perfect GPS dog fence for your furry friend ultimately comes down to your individual needs and priorities.

Each GPS collar has its strengths, and the best choice depends on how you plan to use it, where you live, and what kind of setup you’re comfortable managing.

PetSafe
The Guardian® GPS 2.0 is the most balanced option overall. It sets up in about an hour, handles up to 50 custom fences, and tracks your dog in real time with dual-frequency GPS and AccuGuard™. The collar is light, waterproof, and fits necks as small as 8 inches, which works for most dogs. If you want strong tracking, solid hardware, and a system that won’t overwhelm you with settings or learning curves, this one does the job.

You don’t need to walk the property or watch long tutorials. You open the app, draw the fence, and it’s ready. It works well for homes with open space, travel setups, or dogs that need freedom with clear limits. At around $400, it’s more affordable than Halo or SpotOn and still gives you core features like alerts, vibration, or static correction, and live tracking. For a lot of dog owners, that’s exactly enough.

Halo
Halo is a better fit if you want built-in training features. The collar includes video lessons and behavior tools, which help if you’re just starting out with training or want more structure. The app is full of features, but the collar costs more, and a subscription is required to unlock most of what it can do.

SpotOn
SpotOn makes sense for large properties or hard-to-fence areas. You can walk the perimeter or draw it in the app, and the collar supports unlimited fences. The GPS is accurate, and the hardware is tough. It’s the most expensive option up front, and setup takes longer than the others, but it gives you the most control.

Verdict

If you want a system that’s quick to set up, easy to use, and accurate enough to trust daily, PetSafe’s Guardian® GPS 2.0 stands out. It does what you need without trying to do too much, and it handles both backyard and travel setups with no problem. It’s a smart choice if you’re ready to move beyond a basic fence and want to keep your dog safe wherever you go.

---

Check out other related articles that you might also like:

Ollie Dog Food Review

SpotOn GPS Fence Review

Sundays Dog Food Review

Pet Plate Dog Food Review