Menlo Club Subscription Review

About Menlo House

Menlo Club Subscription Review

Menlo House is an e-commerce site selling casual clothing and accessories for men. The brand also offers a monthly and quarterly style subscription to club members. We’ll cover this service in our Menlo Club subscription review, to help you decide whether or not it’s worth your money.

Overview of Menlo Club 

Menlo Club Subscription Review

Fashion entrepreneurs Andres Inquieta and Dee Murthy founded the Five Four clothing brand in 2002. Their initial mission was simple: to help men dress better. Menlo House evolved from this starter brand and has since attained international status.

Within the last year, Menlo House upped their style subscription game with the launch of two exciting new brands. In the words of Inquieta and Murthy:

“Going into the new year, we asked ourselves, how can we create a more personalized experience for you, our Five Four Man?” 

Their answer: Grand AC athletic wear and New Republic footwear. The Menlo Club subscription has become increasingly popular in the realm of urban style, providing members with modern and trend-savvy clothing through Five Four, Grand AC, and New Republic. 

Menlo Club members have access to exclusive perks, receiving monthly or quarterly package deliveries containing 2-3 premium items, free shipping, and access to private sales not available to other Menlo House shoppers.

This Menlo Club subscription review will take a deep dive into their style service. We’ll start with the benefits and downsides to the Menlo Club:


  • Menlo House offers free shipping on purchases valued at $75 and higher
  • Menlo Club members receive a variety of perks including free delivery, 25% discount off all Menlo House apparel and access to exclusive deals and promotions
  • Club membership can be paused or delivered seasonally
  • Based on an individual style quiz, club members receive items selected for them that will build on their existing wardrobe
  • Menlo staff appear to be highly accessible to their customers via phone, email and Live Chat
  • Many Menlo Club promo codes are available online for discounted pricing


  • There are additional shipping costs associated with package deliveries to Alaska, Hawaii, Canada and the UK
  • Shipments to Canada and the UK may be subject to duties and tariffs that the customer must cover
  • Menlo House shipment costs for non-club members are not stated on the site 
  • Items delivered to club members cannot be returned unless a size exchange is required
  • Most clothing styles are limited to young, hipster and casual looks
  • Extensive customer complaints on the difficulty of subscription cancellation

How Menlo Club Works 

Menlo Club Subscription Review

Signing up as a Menlo Club member makes shopping for clothes simple—no more endless website browsing or wandering through retail stores aimlessly looking for something that inspires you. 

New subscribers complete a brief quiz, to help Menlo Club stylists assemble curated boxes based on sizing and personal style preference. The quiz only takes a few minutes and involves choosing images of apparel that you find most appealing. More details on the sign-up process can be found later on in this Menlo Club subscription review.

By joining the Menlo Club, you agree to pay a $60 monthly styling fee. Members receive 2-3 items of Menlo Club clothing and shoes each month. That’s at least 24 new pieces every year, ensuring that your outfits are always fresh and in style.

Menlo Club Subscription Review

This Menlo Club subscription review, we’ll give you a taste of the core brands. We’ll start with the one that started it all:

Five Four

Menlo House grew from Five Four and this is the brand that features most in Menlo Club packages. Five Four apparel has the look of streetwear, with casual pieces including hoodies, sweatshirts, jeans, tees, and shorts. Most Five Four clothing comes in darker neutrals, some featuring graphics and fun prints like camo and tye dye. 

Five Four x Mark McNairy is a new collaboration featured in the subscription. It has an elevated vibe compared to Five Four, with styles ranging from traditional, to bold prints and patterns, to sleek leather pieces. 

Menlo Club Subscription Review

Grand AC

Grand AC has the casual same vibe as Five Four, and a lot of the same colors and prints. Where Five Four does streetwear, Grand AC blurs the line between athleticwear and athleisure. If you like the idea of camo workout gear, you’ll like Grand AC. A Menlo Club package featuring Grand AC could deliver you anything from shirts inspired by soccer jerseys, to workout tanks, shorts, and tights.  

New Republic

New Republic footwear offers a switch up to the apparel most often found in Menlo Club packages. New Republic’s classic shoes, boots, and sneakers are designed using premium leather and suede. Paired with Five Four and Grand AC, New Republic footwear completes the personally curated outfits for Menlo Club subscribers. For more on New Republic, check out our in-depth review.

In a typical year of package deliveries, A Menlo Club member can expect to receive:

  • Five Four contemporary wear for 8 months
  • Grand AC athleisure wear for 2 months
  • New Republic footwear for 2 months

Is the Menlo Club Subscription Worth It?

Menlo Club Subscription Review

While writing this Menlo Club subscription review, I googled online customer reviews in hot pursuit of any stand-out complaints or red flags. I’m happy to report that in general, most customers appeared satisfied with the service.

The website AskMen gave Menlo Club a 4.5/5 star rating, and their rating is 3.6/5 on My Subscription Addiction. Many customers claimed that the items were good quality and that all-in-all they considered their monthly costs money well spent. 

While I did come across several complaints that the clothing did not fit well and was of flimsy quality, by far the most common complaint I encountered focused on difficulties experienced when cancelling a subscription. Several customers complained that Menlo House staff ignored their cancellation requests.

One customer stated that upon making contact with staff, he was informed his Menlo Club cancellation was not possible due to security concerns. This last one sounds pretty strange, and I’m curious to know how things ended up. 

Putting this negative feedback aside, most Menlo Club reviews online are positive. Based on my findings for this Menlo Club subscription review, I feel that $60 is a small price to pay for 2-3 items of mens’ apparel and shoes each month.

The Menlo Club sounds like an interesting shopping solution for those not interested in actually hitting the pavement or even going through online sites to hand-select items for themselves.

Menlo Club Promotions & Discounts 

Menlo Club Benefits 

Menlo Club Subscription Review

One of the highlights of this Menlo Club subscription review is the benefits that come with the membership. Check them out:

  • 25% off Menlo house brands: Menlo Club Five Four apparel, New Republic footwear and Grand AC athleticwear
  • Free shipping on all orders
  • Exclusive promotions and deals offered through brand partners
  • Option to become a Menlo Brand Ambassador which has its own incentives

New club members receive 50% off their first package as well as free sunglasses. This promotion is applied at checkout.

Visit the website regularly for Menlo Club coupons and Menlo Club promo code only available to club members. Simply input your Menlo Club login to check for exclusive deals.

Join Menlo Club

Menlo Club Subscription Review

This Menlo Club subscription review found that the membership process can be boiled down into four easy steps:

  1. Complete the 5 question survey 
  2. Submit your contact information including email, mailing address and phone number
  3. Fill out the section on how often you would like to receive Menlo Club packages
  4. Provide Menlo with your payment information

Once receiving payment, Menlo staff starts preparing your individualized package which typically consists of 2-3 items from Five Four, Grand AC, or New Republic. 

Club Members also receive additional incentives including discounted pricing on all Menlo House products and access to exclusive deals and promotions.


Menlo House Sizing

Here’s a standard sizing guide for Menlo House apparel:

Measurement in inchesSMLXLXXLXXXL
Waist 28”-30”31”-33”34”-36”37”-40”41”-43”44”-47”
Neck15”-15 ½”16”-16 ½”17”-17 ½”18”-18 ½”19”-19 ½”20”-20 ½”
Sleeve25 ½”26”26 ½”27”27 ½”28”

Inseam measurements for Menlo brand pants are offered in 2 distinct sizes:

  1. For waist measurements of 29”-33”, the inseam is 32”
  2. For waist measurements of 34”-44”, the inseam is 34”

Potential members can easily convert their shoe sizes by consulting the chart within this Menlo Club subscription review. See the conversion table below.

US shoe sizesUK shoe sizesEU shoe sizes

How to Cancel Menlo Club

To cancel a Menlo House order or process a Menlo Club cancel, customers must contact a Menlo representative in one of two ways:

  1. By telephone at 888 341 2381 between Monday and Friday 9am-5pm
  2. Via Live Chat between 8am-5pm daily

Menlo Club subscriptions can be paused for up to 3 months at a time. Something important to note in this Menlo Club review: cancellations and subscription pauses must occur prior to the 14th of each month. Otherwise, you’ll be charged for the next month.

Menlo Club Shipping Policy

Menlo House ships throughout the US, Canada and the UK. Only purchases valued at $75 or more ship for free within the continental US.

A Menlo Club subscription review found that all shipping within the continental US is free for club members. All other subscribers and customers will be charged for shipping:

  • $7 to Alaska and Hawaii
  • $25 to Canada
  • $30 to the UK

Any incurred fees due to tariffs and/or duties are the responsibility of the customer.

Once a package ships, Menlo House customers will receive the tracking information via email. Tracking details are also available within their personal membership account dashboard.

In most cases, Menlo packages are shipped within 7-10 days of the charge date and typically arrive 2-5 days later. This can vary depending on the shipping destination. 

Menlo Club Returns Policy

Menlo House customers have 30 days from the date of delivery to return items. In order to secure a refund or exchange, apparel must not have been worn or washed and tags must still be attached. Any items marked as final sale are not eligible for refund or exchange.

To initiate a return or exchange, contact Menlo staff via email: [email protected]

Before concluding this Menlo Club subscription review, be aware that since Menlo Club packages are specially curated per customer, there are no returns or refunds available for these purchases.

Sizing exchanges are permitted so long as they occur within 30 days of delivery and the item is in new condition with tags still attached. Customers seeking a size exchange should contact Menlo Club staff through email or Live Chat to receive a Size Exchange Request Form.

Costs acquired from return shipping outside the continental US are at the customer’s expense.

Contact Menlo House

Menlo House headquarters is located at:

6380 Wilshire Blvd

Los Angeles, California  90048

To get in touch with Menlo staff, you can reach out by:

  • Email at [email protected]
  • Telephone at 888 341 2381  from Monday to Friday between 9am-5pm
  • Live Chat (through their website) from Monday to Friday between 8am-5pm 

You’ve got other options for style subscriptions. Check out these other men’s clothing and lifestyle brands:

Sprezzabox clothing & accessories

Bespoke Post lifestyle

Scentbird fragrances

Birchbox lifestyle

Ask the community or leave a comment


Customer Reviews

Leave a review

5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Stars
Anthony E Singletary
3 years ago Reply

This was my absolute worst online shopping experience ever!! I never even heard of this company but a Black Friday deal was being offered if you purchase the monthly deal you would receive 200 dollars worth of merchandise for 39 dollars. I was supposed to receive a pair of sneakers, a t-shirt, pants and also a pair of socks. On the supposed delivery date a got a confirmation email saying my package was delivered. So not the case. Apparently, my package was delivered to another address and it was never returned to me. I reached out to customer service and they sent me a replacement order. I finally received it but there were only 2 items in the package. On top of that my credit card was being charged the full 75 dollars and essentially told me that they couldn’t honor that coupon code because I never used it when I ordered initially but I did. I reached out via live chat and just canceled my whole subscription. Horrible customer service and horrible guest experience!! Byers beware!!!!

4 years ago Reply

Garbage company with sub-par clothing and even worse customer service. What is the point of setting up a style profile if you could possibly get a style that you would never wear??!! It’s like throwing away money! They would not work with me at all when I received a shipment that I absolutely hated. I am glad to no longer be a customer and will look forward to the day that they are out of business! Their styles aren’t even “forward” at all…very basic items. Save your money and use another similar service if you want to try something like this.

Ask the community or leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required